JUDGMENT Reilly, J. 1. The case to which this suit relates appears to have come before the Assistant Registrar under the provisions contained in the second sentence of the present Sub-rule (1) of Rule XIV of the Rules under the Co-operative Societies Act, 1912, and Sub-rule (2) of that rule. I see no reason to think that the second sentence of Sub-rule (1) of Rule XIV is, as suggested for the appellant, beyond the rule-making powers granted by Section 43 of the Act apart from the special provision in Sub-section (5) of that section. Moreover, it now appears from Ex. VII, a letter addressed by the appellant to the Assistant Registrar, that he himself invoked jurisdiction of the Assistant Registrar in this matter. 2. This appeal is dismissed with costs.