Dattajirao Balwantrao Mane v. Nani Palkhivala & others
1987-10-16
B.G.KOLSE PATIL, S.C.PRATAP
body1987
DigiLaw.ai
JUDGMENT - S.C. PRATAP, J.:---Learned Advocate Mr. Niteen Pradhan for the petitioner submits that in view of the first respondent Nani Palkhivala's letter to the learned Advocate Mr. S.B. Jaisinghani---and which letter is now part of the record of these proceedings---the question of contempt will not arise. But---and we now quote the very words of the learned Advocate---the petitioner desires to highlight the conduct of Advocates and their growing tendency to hurl abuses on Judges and under criticism of courts. 2. Now, what the petitioner, who is also himself a practising member of the Bar, should do or desires is not for us to advise. Living, as we all are, in a free democracy ...the one visible symbol thereof, significantly, is this very petition and its subject-speech but the vital symbol whereof is our independent judiciary...citizens are free to choose and charter out their course of action subject, of course, to the basic norms enjoined upon us all by the rule of law end the Constitution. But it is well to remember that as in the case of a nation, so in the case of a profession or an institution, it reveals itself--- "Not only by the men it produces but also by the men it honours, the men it remembers." May, we all then as citizens of this great country, like those who have in fact laboured almost their life-time, endeavour to keep alive in our countrymen--- "that little spark of celestical fire called conscience" which in turn helps keep ideals alive. Albeit a few, there nevertheless have been and are, great and noble citizens of this country who unflinchingly stand out as illustrious examples of devotion and dedication, in their pristine selflessness, to the maintenance of the rules of law, the sanctity of the Constitution and above all, human rights and eternal values. May their life-history inspire others also to likewise may their lives sublime and"...departing leave behind them footprints on the sands of time" 3. So far as the instant proceedings are concerned, suffice it to state and conclude that there is no contempt. This petition is hence dismissed. Petition dismissed. -----