Integrated Joint Farming Cooperative Society Ltd. v. State of Manipur and Ors.
2005-03-14
T.NANDA KUMAR SINGH
body2005
DigiLaw.ai
Heard Mr. N. Surendrajit Singh, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner as well as Mr. R.S. Reisang, learned Addl. G A .for the respondent Nos. 1 to 3 and Ms Sundari Devi, learned counsel for the respondents 4 and 5. 2. The petitioner is a society formed for the benefits and welfare of its members. The petitioner society consists of members/land owners from different parts of Manipur. The simple case of the petitioner is that agricultural lands belonging to the members of the petitioner society had been inundated beyond any use as a consequence of the implementation of the Loktak Hydro Electric Project at Komreirap/Leimatak. The particulars of the members of the petitioner society along with their respective affected land are described at Annexure-A/2 to the writ petition which read as follows: “List and particulars of the members of the petitioner society with their respective patta land affected by the project: Sl. No. Name & Address Patta No. Area 1. Ph. Brojen Singh S/O (L) Ph.Koba Singh 1945 5.00 acres of Mayai Imphal 2. Ph. Kumar Singh S/O (L) Ph. Koba 54 4.35 acres Singh of Mayang Imphal. 3. Ph. Somendro Singh S/O (L) Ph. Koba 107 62 acres Singh of Mayang Imphal 4. Ph. Shandani Devi W/O(L) Ibochou 608 1.09 acres Singh of Mayang Imphal. 5. I. Ibopishak Singh S/O (L) Ibochou 86 1.12 acres I.Bheigo Singh of Mayang Imphal 6. A Debata Sobit Committee/Secy. 1835 2.50 acres Of Mayang Imphal. 7. K. Kriti Singh S/O (L) K. Naba Singh 1849 2.50 acres Of Mayang Imphal. 8. N. Mani Singh S/O (L) N. Thonglen 563 3.35 acres Singh of Mayang Imphal. 9. A.Jalin Mia S/O)(L) Abdul Mia 563 3.55 acres of Bengul. 10. N.Nilasing Singh S/O(L) N.Khonou 1746 72 acres Singh of Konchak. 11. N. Budhichandra S/O (L) M. Goshai 1771 56 acres Singh of Konchak. 12. S. Abhiram Singh S/O (L) Anghal 1975 1.42 acres Singh of Konchak. 13. Ph. Rajendro Singh S/O (l) Ibochou 608 1,08 acres Singh of KOnchak. 14. Th. Ibomcha Singh S/O(L) Th. Bihari 615 1.60 acres Singh of Konchak. 15. Ph. Raejndro Singh S/O (L) Ph.Ibochou 38 1.21 acres Singh of Konchak. 16. Ph.Basanta Singh S/O Ph.Kumar Singh 38 2.50 acres of Konchak. 17. N.Khamba Singh S/O N. Angou 458 1.26 acres Singh of KOnchak. 18. L. Nabdo Singh S/O (L) L.Chaoba 1983 5.00 acres Singh of Konchak. 19.
Bihari 615 1.60 acres Singh of Konchak. 15. Ph. Raejndro Singh S/O (L) Ph.Ibochou 38 1.21 acres Singh of Konchak. 16. Ph.Basanta Singh S/O Ph.Kumar Singh 38 2.50 acres of Konchak. 17. N.Khamba Singh S/O N. Angou 458 1.26 acres Singh of KOnchak. 18. L. Nabdo Singh S/O (L) L.Chaoba 1983 5.00 acres Singh of Konchak. 19. Kh.Shyamkanhai S/O (L) Kh. Braja- 1059 1.21 acres Mohal Singh of KOnchak. 20. Ph. Ongbi Memcha Devi W/O Ph. 1867 2.50 acres Kumar Singh of Konchak. 21. Ph. Basanta Singh S/O Ph. Kumar 1867 2.50 acres Singh of KOnchak. 22. Ph. Ratan Singh S/O Ph. Kumar 1867 2.50 acres Singh of KOnchak. 23. L. AShothama Singh S/O (L) 1192 3.20 acres L.Ningshirei of M.I. Thana. 24. W.Sanajao Singh S/O (L) W.Chaoba 1482 1.27 -do- Singh of Mayang Imphal. 25. Kh.Kunjashwor Singh S/O Kh. 1456 4.12 -do Thambalngou Singh of Konchak. 26. Kh. Bigyanda Singh S/O Kh. 1456 2.15 -do Thambalngou Singh of Konchak. 27. Ph. Rajendro Singh S/O (L) Ibochou 535 2.43 -do- Singh of Konchak. 28. Ch.Tomal Singh S/O (L) Ch. Angahal 435 1.24 -do- Of Konchak. 29. L. Thoiba Singh S/O(L) L.Ibochou 2073 2.50 -do- Singh of M.I. 30. L.Ibochou Singh S/O(L) L. L. 2075 2.50 -do- Singh of Mayang Imphal. 31. L.Ranjit Singh S/O (L.Ibochou Singh 2072 2.50 -do- Of M.I. 32. L.Tomba Singh S/O (L) Ibochou 2074 2.50 -do- Singh of M.I. 33. P.Ibotombi Singh S/O (L) P.Shamu 578 .66 -do- Singh of Mayang Imphal. 34. L.Amor Singh S/O(L)L.Tomba Singh 578 2.50 -do- Of Thana. 35. N.Shamchand Singh S/O (L) N. 578 .25 -do- Angongyaima Singh of Thana 36. L.Ibochou Singh S/O (L) L. 578 2.50 -do Babuyaima Singh of Mayang Imphal. 37. Kh.Ibopishak Singh S/O (L) 578 .90 -do- Kh.Megha Singh of Mayang Imphal. 38. N.(N)Wahengbam (O) Laphoi Devi 414 .78 -do- W/O Shanajaoba Singh of Mayang Imphal. 39. L.Omor Singh S/O (L)L.Tomba Singh 744 .57 -do- Of M.I.Thana 40. L.Ingobabee Singh S/O (L) L.Thambou 774 .57 -do- Singh of M.I.Thana 41. L.Anau Singh S/O (L)L.Babuyaima 1636 1.25 -do- Of M.I.Thana 42. L.Ingobee Singh S/O(L)L.Thambou 6/05 1.10 -do- Singh of M.I.Thana. 43. T.(O) Manbee Devi W/O Mangi Singh 323 1.24 -do- of M.I. 44. L. Anou Singh S/O (L) L. Babuyaima 575 3.18 -do- Singh of M.I. 45. L. Anou Singh S/O (L) L.Babuyaima 1389 1.50 -do- Singh of M.I. 46.
L.Anau Singh S/O (L)L.Babuyaima 1636 1.25 -do- Of M.I.Thana 42. L.Ingobee Singh S/O(L)L.Thambou 6/05 1.10 -do- Singh of M.I.Thana. 43. T.(O) Manbee Devi W/O Mangi Singh 323 1.24 -do- of M.I. 44. L. Anou Singh S/O (L) L. Babuyaima 575 3.18 -do- Singh of M.I. 45. L. Anou Singh S/O (L) L.Babuyaima 1389 1.50 -do- Singh of M.I. 46. A.(N) Thoibi Devi W/O Lokhon Singh 2149 1.78 -do- Of Waheng Khuman. 47. Y.(N) Chaoba Devi W/O Kesho Singh 2149 1.78 -do- Of Waheng KHuman. 48. T.(N) Pujari Devi W/O Amu Singh of 34 1.36 -do- Konchai. 49. T(O) Manbee Devi W/O Mangi Singh 34 1.25 -do- Of M.I. 50. Th.Radhash yam Singh S/O(L) Th. 74 0.84 -do- Thambou Singh of M.I. 51. Th. Iboyai Singh S/O(L) Iboton Singh 99 2.17 -do- of M.I 52. I. Nabakumar Singh S/O I.Jatra 545 2.50 acres Singh of M.I. 53. I.Radharani Devi W/O Nabakumar 545 2.50 acres Singh of M.I. 54. I.Sony Devi W/O I. N abakumar Singh 545 2.50 -do- of M.I. 55. L.Sunita Devi WE/O I. Nabakumar 545 2.50 -do Singh of M.I. 56. I.Angamba Singh D/O I.Nabakumar 545 2.50 -do- Singh of M.I. 57. Y. Ibungo Singh S/O Ibopishak 226 1.86 -do- Sinhgh of M.I. 58. Y.(O) Laiyon Devi W/O L.Ibopishak 696 2.50 -do- Singh of M.I. 59. Ph.(O) Memcha Devi W/O Kumar 696 2.50 -do- Singh of M.I. 60. Y.Ibungo Singh S/O (L) Ibopishak 696 2.50 -do- Singh of M.I. 61. Y.Shyamjai Singh S/O (L) L. 696 2.50 -do- Ibopishak of M.I. 62. Y.Premananda Singh S/O (L) -do- 696 2.50 -do- 63. Ph.Basanta Singh S/O Ph. Kumar 696 2.50 -do- Singh of M I. 64. Ch. Meipak Singh S/O Ch. Thambu 417 2.08 -do of M.I. 65. Ch. Iboton Singh S/O Ch. Thambou 417 2.08 -do- of M.I. 66. Ch. Koklai Singh S/O Ch. Thambou 417 2.08 -do- Of M.I. 67. Th. Kulabee Singh S/O Th. Iboyaima 165 3.11 -do- Singh of M.I. 68. Ch. Sanatomba S/O Ch. Lokhon Singh 165 1.25 -do- Of M.I. 69. W. Sanajao Singh S/O W. Chaoba 306 1.30 -do- Of M.I. 70. Th. Mani Singh S/O (L) Anghak of M.I. 306 .73 -do- 71. Y.Ibungo Singh S/O(L) Ibopishak of M.I. 65 2.95 -do- 72. W. Sanajao S/O(L) Chaoba Singh 227 3.19 -do- Of Thana. 73. Md.Phajarudin Mia S/O (L)Md.Tonu 916 2.50 -do- Mia of Uchiwa. 74. Md.
W. Sanajao Singh S/O W. Chaoba 306 1.30 -do- Of M.I. 70. Th. Mani Singh S/O (L) Anghak of M.I. 306 .73 -do- 71. Y.Ibungo Singh S/O(L) Ibopishak of M.I. 65 2.95 -do- 72. W. Sanajao S/O(L) Chaoba Singh 227 3.19 -do- Of Thana. 73. Md.Phajarudin Mia S/O (L)Md.Tonu 916 2.50 -do- Mia of Uchiwa. 74. Md. Mansur Ali S/O Md.Musamiya 915 2.50 -do- Of Uchiwa. 75. Md. Naoba Miya S/O Md. Jamamiya 914 2.50 -do- Of Uchiwa. 76. H.Chaoba Singh S/O N. Lala Singh 913 2.50 -do- Oof Uchiwa 77. H.Ibomcha S/O H. Lala Singh -do- 912 2.50-do- 78. H. Abhiram Singh S/O (L) An goton-do- 911 2.50-do- 79. Md.Abhirkhan Miya S/O Md. Yaima 910 2.50-do- Miya of Uchiowa. 80. H.Nabakumar S/O H.Nabadweep -do- 673 2.50-do- 81. H.Surchand S/O H>kora Singh of -do- 672 1.82-do- 82. H.Nabadweep S/O (L) Sarat Singh -do- 671 1.90-do- 83. Ph.(O) Memcha Devi W/O Kumar Singh 845 5.00 -do- 84. Th. Ibohal Singh S/O Th.Mangol Singh 758 2.50 acres of M.I 85. N.Nabadweep Singh S/O(L) Chaongou 758 2.50 -do Singh of M.I. 86. L. Tingku Singh S/O Muhindro of 202 5.00 acres Thongam 87. L.Muhindro Singh S/O Mangi Singh 220 5.00 -do- Of Mangul. 88. Md.Abdul Kadir S/O (L) Md. Abdul 8 .62 -do- Jabar Miya of Lamhupat. 89. Md. Tombi Bibi Md. Abdul Jabar Miya 8 .30 -do- Of Laphupat 90. Md. Tombi Bibi W/O Md. Abdul Jahar 8 .14 -do- Mia. 91. Md.Helia Miya S/O Md. Abdul Kadir 435 1.78 -do of Laphupat. 92. Md. Rahman Miya S/O Md. Abdul Jabar -do- 25 .89 -do- 93. Md.Niyam Tulo S/O Md. Bani Miya 25 2.59 -do- Of Komlakhong. 94. Md. Abdul Kadir S/O Md. Ningthoujao 274 .62 -do- MIya of Laphupat. 95. Md. Abdul Jalia Miya S/O Md. Kadir 274 1.00 - do- Miya of Laphupat. 96. Tahara Bibi W/O Md. Alimudin of 274 1.25 -do- Komlakhong. 97. Md.Salaudin W/O Md.Alimudin of -do- 274 .62 -do- 98. Md.Tomba S/O (L) Md. Niram of -do- 274 1.98 -do- 99. Md.Rahman S/O (L) Md.Khongnamba -do- 98 1.25 -do- 100. Md.Basimuddin S/O Md. Kiramiya of 455 2.02 -do- Laphupat. 101. Md.Abdul Jalin Miya S/O Md. 192 2.21 -do- Sanatomba of Laphupat. 102. Md.Huishan Ahamad S/O (L) Md. Haji 192 1.26 -do- Abedule of Laphupat. 103. Md.Mansur Ali S/O (L) Md.Haji Muzafir 192 2.69 -do- Ali of Laphupat. 104.
Md.Rahman S/O (L) Md.Khongnamba -do- 98 1.25 -do- 100. Md.Basimuddin S/O Md. Kiramiya of 455 2.02 -do- Laphupat. 101. Md.Abdul Jalin Miya S/O Md. 192 2.21 -do- Sanatomba of Laphupat. 102. Md.Huishan Ahamad S/O (L) Md. Haji 192 1.26 -do- Abedule of Laphupat. 103. Md.Mansur Ali S/O (L) Md.Haji Muzafir 192 2.69 -do- Ali of Laphupat. 104. Y.Bijoykumar Singh S/O Y. Chaoba 751 1.74 -do- Singh of Singjamei Makha Thokchom Leikai. 105. Y.Bijoykumar Singh S/O Y. Chaoba Singh -do- 676 1.74 -do- 106. Y.Bijoykumar Singh S/O Y. Chaoba Singh -do- 713 2.48 -do- 107. Th.(N) Memcha Devi W/O (L) Ibotombi Singh 496 2.47 -do- of Thangmeiband Yumnam Leikai. 108. Y. Chaoba Singh S/O L.Y. Goura Singh of 712 2.23 -do- Singjamei Mathak Thokchom L. 109. Y. Chaoba Singh S/O(L) Y. Gouro Singh 750 1.67 -do- of -do- 110. (a) L. Angou Singh S/O L.. Kumachandra Singh of Mayang Imphal 1863 7.50 -do- (b) L.Ratan Singh S/O L.Rakhum Singh of Mayang Imphal Konchak. (c) L.Raju Singh S/O Rakhumani Singh of -do-. 111. Mutum Tombi Singh S/O M. Tompok Singh 308 3.46 -do- of Komlakhong. 112. Th. Iboyaima Singh S/O L. Aber Singh 1360 2.50 -do- of Thokchom Leikai. 113. N.Joikumar Singh S/O N. Koireng 262 2.73 -do- Singh of -do- 114. N.Kunjabihari Singh S/O N. Koireng 361 2.50 -do- of -do-. 115. R.K. Sanamacha Singh S/O Amusana 1527 2.06 -do- Singh of Ishopk village. 116. R.K. Manao Singh S/O R.K. Sanayaima 853 2.50 -do- Singh of Ishok village. 117. R.K. Amusana Singh S/O R.K. Sanayaima 1107 3.26 acres Of Ishok village. 118. R.K. Sanamacha Singh S/O R.K. Sanayaima 1928 1.70 -do- Singh of -do- 119. R.K. SAnamacha Singh S/O R.K. -do- 1278 1.25 -do- (b) R.K. Thambou Sana Singh S/O R.K. Amusana Singh of -do- 4.64 -do- 120. (a) R.K. Open Singh S/O R.K. Sanamacha 7.50 -do- Singh of Ishok village. (b) R.K. Bijoi Singh -do- 1528 2.69 -do- 121. W. Komol Singh S/O W. Heramani Singh 212 2.50 -do- Of -do- 122. L. Koknang Singh S/O L. Modhu Singh 874 2.50 -do- Of Khuman. 123. L.Koknang Singh -do- 1080 2.50 -do- 124. A. Tona Singh S/O A,Mani Singh 252 2.50 -do- Of Ishok. 125. I.Ibopishak Singh S/O L. Tomba Singh 1799 2.50 -do- Of Mayang Imphal. 126. L. Tompishak Singh S/O L. Khoudan 1124 2.46 -do- Of M.I. 127. I. Ibokpishak Singh Singh S/O L.Tomba of-do- 616 1.56 -do- 128.
123. L.Koknang Singh -do- 1080 2.50 -do- 124. A. Tona Singh S/O A,Mani Singh 252 2.50 -do- Of Ishok. 125. I.Ibopishak Singh S/O L. Tomba Singh 1799 2.50 -do- Of Mayang Imphal. 126. L. Tompishak Singh S/O L. Khoudan 1124 2.46 -do- Of M.I. 127. I. Ibokpishak Singh Singh S/O L.Tomba of-do- 616 1.56 -do- 128. I.Megha Singh S/O I. Ibokpishak Singh of -do- 159 1.36 -do- 129. H.Inaobi Singh S/O H. Punsi Singh 1945 2.50 -do- Of Isok. 130. A. Ibomcha Singh S/O A. Tona Singh 353 2.50 -do- Of Ishok. 131. A.Tomcha Singh S/O A. Tona Singh 642 2.50-do- Of Ishok. 132 (a) H. Yaiskul Singh S/O H. Chaoba 824 2.50-do- Singh of Ishok. (b) H. Ibochatombi Singh S/O H.- do- 133. N.Yaima Singh S/O (L) Chaobhal Singh 192 2.50-do- Of Shamurou. 134. L.Gandhar Singh S/O (L) Lala Singh of M.I. 1824 2.50 -do- 135 (a) L. Yaima Singh S/O (L) Kanhai 236 2.50 -do- Singh of M.I. (b) A.Nipamacha Singh S/O (L) Kanhai Singh -do- 35 0.71-do- 136. (a) Abdulhei Mia S/O Jalan Mia of Bengul. 1.43-do- (b) L.Yaima Singh S/O L. Kanhai Singh of Konchak. 137 (a) N.Parijat Singh S/O(L) N. Lamphel 509 2. 26 -do- (b) L. Yaima Singh S/O (L) Kanhai Singh of -do- 3.26 -do- (c) 5 others. 5.52 -do- 138. Th. Iboyaima Singh Singh S/O (L) Aber Singh 1359 2.50 -do- Of Singjamei Thokchom Leikai. 139. Meisnam Momochou Singh S/O M.Birachandra 317/462 2.48 -do- Singh of Kwakeithel Ningthem Kol. 140. M.Momocha S/O M. Biranchandra -do- 317/463 2.48-do- 141. M.Roson Singh S/O (L) Thamoijap S of -do- 317/464 2.48-do- 142. M.Yaima Singh S/O(L) Thamoijao of -do- 317/4650 2.48-do- 143. P.Yaima Singh S/O (L) P. Chaoba Singh 317/466 2.48-do- Khangampalli Pankha Nambul Mapal. 144. W. Tombi Devi W/O Amubi Singh of 317/467 Kwakeithel Leimakhujam Leikai. 145. S. Khoibam Muhindro Singh S/O S. Dhono 317/468 Of Keishampat Leimajam Leikai. 146. T. Kala S/O late Gulap Singh of -do- 317/469 147. K. Koirang S/O (L) Kalla Singh of 317/470 Kwakeithel Thokchom Leikai 148. N.(N) Manglembi Devi W/O Birol S. 317/471 Of Thoubal Wangma Taba. 149. A. Bapu Singh S/O A. Birendro 317/472 Of thoubal Akoijam Leikai. 150. L.Boramani Sharma S/O (L) Lalbapu 317/473 Singh Sagolbal Sayang Road Thiyam Leikai. 151. L. Amarjit Sharma S/O Boramani -do- 317/474 152. L. Radha Devi W/O(L) Baramani -do- 317/475 153. L.(N) Dhanumati Devi D/O(L) Lalabapu 317/476 Singh -do- 154.
149. A. Bapu Singh S/O A. Birendro 317/472 Of thoubal Akoijam Leikai. 150. L.Boramani Sharma S/O (L) Lalbapu 317/473 Singh Sagolbal Sayang Road Thiyam Leikai. 151. L. Amarjit Sharma S/O Boramani -do- 317/474 152. L. Radha Devi W/O(L) Baramani -do- 317/475 153. L.(N) Dhanumati Devi D/O(L) Lalabapu 317/476 Singh -do- 154. H.Ibotombi Singh S/O Late H. 317/477 Ibochaoba of Kwakeithel Akham L. 155. H.(O) Ibecha Devi W/O H. Ibotombi Singh -do- 317/478 156. H.Arunkumar S/O H. Ibetombi Singh of-do- 317/479 157. H.Jantakumar S/O H. Ibotombi Singh of -do- 317/480 158. M.Kunjabihari Singh S/O M. Gouramadhop 317/481 Singh of Kwakeithel Laishram L. 159. M.(O) Prembala Devi H/S M.Kunjabihari 317/493 Singh of -do- 160. M. Pinky Devi D/O M.Kunjabihari Singh -do- 317/494 161. M. Sonia Devi D/O M.Kunjabihari Singh -do- 317/495 162. Y. Shamungou Singh S/O Y. Gouro 317/496 Singh of Kakwa Lamdoibung. 163. Y.(O) Anita Devi -do- 317/497 164. Kh.Sayantakumar Singh S/O (L) Kh. 317/498 Biramangol Singh of Singjamei Chongtham L. 165. Kh.(O) Ibechaobi Devi H/O Kh. Jayantakumar 317/499 Singh of -do- 166. L. Shyamjai S/O (L) Naran Singh of 317/500 Chingamakha Liwa. 167. L.(O) Brojeshori Devi H/O L. Syamjai Singh-do- 317/501 168. E.Ibohal Singh S/O(L) E.Lokhon Singh 317/502 Of Elangbam Leikai. 169. E (O) Thanbaltombi H/O E. Ibohal Singh 317/503 Of Elangbam Leikai. 170. E. (N) Pramodini D/O E. Ibohal Singh of-do- 317/505 171. E. Ratan Singh S/O E. Ibohal Singh of 317/505 Elangbam Leikai. 172. E. Inao Singh S/O E. Ibohal Singh -do- 317/506 173. E. Toto Singh S/O -do- 317/507 174. E. Romi Singh S/O -do- 317/508 175. E.Nanao Singh S/O -do- 317/509 176. E. Ibungo Singh S/O -do 317/510 177. E. Ibungo Singh S/O (L) Lokhon -do- 317/511 178. L. Bilashini Devi H/O E. Ibobi -do- 317/512 179. E.Babo Singh S/O E. Ibobi -do- 317/513 180. E.Ournima Devi D/O E.Ibobi -do- 317/514 181. E.Bhorot Singh S/O(L) Priyokumar -do- 317/515 182. E.Sanajaoba Singh S/O E. Shyamsundar 317/516 Singh -do- 183. E. Vibhek S/O E. Bijoy Singh -do- 317/517 184. R.K. Dinesh Singh S/O R.K. Biren Singh 317/518 Lairikkyengbam Leikai. 185. M.Gyanandra S/O Ibohal Singh of 317/519 Khangompat Pankhong. 186. M. Biren Singh S/O M. Ibohal Singh -do- 317/520 187. Ph. Kulachandra Sharma S/O (L) Bihari 317/521 Of Malom Turiyaima Awang L. 188. Ph.Dhanachandra S/O Ph. Kullachandra 317/522 Sharma -do- 189. K. Tombi Sharma S/O (L) Gopal Sharma 317/523 Of Tera. 190.
185. M.Gyanandra S/O Ibohal Singh of 317/519 Khangompat Pankhong. 186. M. Biren Singh S/O M. Ibohal Singh -do- 317/520 187. Ph. Kulachandra Sharma S/O (L) Bihari 317/521 Of Malom Turiyaima Awang L. 188. Ph.Dhanachandra S/O Ph. Kullachandra 317/522 Sharma -do- 189. K. Tombi Sharma S/O (L) Gopal Sharma 317/523 Of Tera. 190. K. Ibempishak Devi H/O K. Tombi -do- 317/524 191. K. Dilipkumar S/O K. Tombi -do- 317/525 192. K. Ranjit Sharma S/O K. Tombi 317/526 193. K.Khelendra Sharma S/O K. Tombi -do- 317/527 194. K. Ratikanta S/O K. Tombi -do 317/528 195. K.Brajamuhon Sharma S/O K. Gopal 317/529 196. K. Gokulchand Sharma S/O K. Brajamuhon 317/530 Of -do- 197. K.Brajachand Sharma S/O K. Brajamuhon 317/531 Sharma of -do- 198. K.Atombapu Sharma S/O K. Brajamuhon 317/532 199. K.Prenchand S/O K. Brajamuhon Sharma 317/533 200. L. Sanajaobi Devi D/O(L) Tomba of 317/534 Konjeng Leikai. 201. M.Birchandra S/O M. Haobi Singh -do- 317/535 202. M.Ibotombi S/O M. Haobi Singh -do- 317/536 203. L.Inao Singh S/O L. Tomba of 317/537 Singjamei Leikai. 204. L.Shyamkanhai S/O L. Tomba of -do- 317/538 205. L.Ruhinikumar S/O L. Tomba -do- 317/539 206. L.Modhu S/O L. Tomba -do- 317/540 207. L.Nilakanta S/O L >Tomba -do- 317/541 208. Y.Tomba S/O (L) Y. Mera of Haobam M. 317/542 209. K.Kesho S/O K. Kakar Singh of 317/543 Nungomthongjao. 210. K.Lukhoi Singh S/O K. Kesho -do- 317/544 211. Kh.Sugeshore S/O Ibemcha Singh -do- 317/545 212. Shattarjit Khumancha S/O Jugeshor 317/546 213. M. Bir S/O Yaima 317/547 214. Y.Budichandra S/O Y. Bhorot 317/548 of Nignom Leirak 215. P.Nungshi D/O(L) Brajabidhu of 317/549 Kwakeithel Thokchom Leikai. 216. W. Tomba S/O W.Nodia -do- 317/550 217. E. Mangi Singh S/O E. Kunjabi 317/551 218. W. Rajamani S/O (L) Gopal 317/552 219. E. Koknang S/O E. Gokulchand of 317/553 Yangdong. 220. W. Yaiskul S/O (L) Angou of Khangpokpi. 317/554 221. W. Ibomcha S/O Khamba -do- 317/555 222. E.(N) Matei S/O(L) E.Yaima Singh of-do- 317/556 223. E.Ibotombi Meitei S/O (L) E. Yaima -do- 317/557 224. W. Pishakton S/O Thambou -do- 317/558 225. W.Shyamjai S/O(L) Anganghal 317/559 of Langmeidong 226. W. Ibobi S/O (L) Gouramani 317/560 of Khangpokpi 227. E. Jugai S/O Konjao of -do- 317/561 228. Y. Guneshor S/O Y. Iboton 317/562. of Langmeidong 229. E.Brojen S/O Ningthemjao 317/563 of Khangpokpi 230. E.Chandani D/O E. Ningthrmjao -do- 317/564 231. E.Nurjil S/O Prijokumar Singh of 317/565 Elangbam Leikai. 232. E.Keredani D/O(L) Yaimabi Devi -do- 317/566 233.
W. Ibobi S/O (L) Gouramani 317/560 of Khangpokpi 227. E. Jugai S/O Konjao of -do- 317/561 228. Y. Guneshor S/O Y. Iboton 317/562. of Langmeidong 229. E.Brojen S/O Ningthemjao 317/563 of Khangpokpi 230. E.Chandani D/O E. Ningthrmjao -do- 317/564 231. E.Nurjil S/O Prijokumar Singh of 317/565 Elangbam Leikai. 232. E.Keredani D/O(L) Yaimabi Devi -do- 317/566 233. L.Sanahanbi D/O(L) Ibobi Singh 317/567 234. A.Biran S/O A. Biren Singh 317/568 of Keishamthong. 235. A. Birendra S/O A. Bhubon Singh -do- 317/569 236. E.Manigopal S/O Parijat of Khangpokpi 317/570 237. E.Eshingchaoba S/O E. Manigopal of -do- 317/571 238. E.Lukhoi S/O Parijat of -do- 317/572 239. Y.Haramani S/O Mani of Langmeidong 1136/17256 240. M.Birushundra S/O (L) Yaima Singh of 270/116 Kwakeithel Ningthemkhol Imphal. 241. M.Birachandra S/O (L) Yaima Singh of -do- 271/116 242. M.Birachandra -do- 274/1168 243. -do- 281/116 244. L.Tomba Singh S/O(L) Kanhai of 275/116 Singjamei Thokchom Leikai. 245. L.Tomba 276/116 246. -do- 280/116 247. -do- 1447/116 248. S.Indu of Kwakeithel -do- 34/109 249. -do- 34/111 250. -do- 34/113 251. -do- 34/110 252. Kh. Amusna Singh 253. Th.Bhorotchandra Singh 471 21.87 acres 254. Kh. Jugeshor Singh Moirang 255. H. Ibotombi Singh. 256. Kh.Babu Singh 257. Ksh.Sumanta Singh 258. L. Kanan Devi 259. Kh.Bhik Toriya Devi 260. Ph.Gouradas Sharma 270. K.Raghumani Singh Mangang 746 21.87 acres 271. K. Ibungosana Mangang. 272. K. Himalai. 273. K. Binokumari Leika. 274. L. Mangangsana Mangang. 275. L. Darandro Mangang 276. Ch. Sur Khabanganba 277. Ch. Bino Leima 278. H. Ibohal Singh. 3. The fertile paddy fields of the petitioner association, the particulars of which are given above, can no longer be used for agricultural purposes as a result of the commission of the Loktak Hydro Electric Project. In spite of repeated request from the side of the members of the petitioner association not only to the authority of the Loktak Hydro Electric Project but also to the concerned authority of the Govt of Manipur for payment of compensation for causing damage to the paddy fields of the petitioner's members mentioned above of the commission on the Loktak Hydro Electric Project, no action was taken up either from the authority of the Loktak Hydro Electric Project or from the competent authority of the Govt. of Manipur. 4.
of Manipur. 4. Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that in the year 1992, when matters for payment of compensation to the land owners of the affected area on the Commission of the Loktak Hydro Electric Project was the issue of the public,by way of eye wash or in order to cool down the public hue and cry, constituted a House Committee of the Manipur Legislative Assembly to examine the amount of compensation for the affected areas. The committee in its sitting held on 08.12.1992 had directed the Commissioner (Revenue) to the Govt of Manipur vide letter No. 2/5/92-LA/CHC (Comp) dated 22.12.1992 to submit the following informations:- (i) Total area affected by the Loktak Project; (ii) Land available for settlement in Loktak Areas before 1964-65 and Lands granted settlement in the area after 1964-65. (iii) District-wise details of the lands affected by the project and lands covered by Loktak Water. (iv) Total patta lands affected by the Loktak Project in the Districts of Thoubal, Bishnupur and Imphal. (v) Acutal land covered under the agreement between the State Govt. and Project authority for the project. 5. Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that because of the expiry term of the members of the House Committee and also because of changed of Ministry, the House Committee constituted to examine the amount of compensation for the affected areas could not complete the inquiry. As a result of the above the problem, the members of petitioner association had been suffering as their fertile paddy fields mentioned above had been rendered useless on the commission of Loktak Hydro Electric Project. Having no alternative the petitioner association filed this writ petition. Orders of this Court in the present writ petition show that sufficient opportunity have been granted to the respondents to file counter their affidavit- in-opposition but till date no affidavit-in-opposition on behalf of the respondents has been filed. In the absence of the affidavit in-opposition of the respondents, this court can not pass final order directing the respondents to pay exact amount of compensation to the members of the petitioner association in respect of their fertile paddy fields mentioned above. An inquiry will be required to find out the areas of the petitioner association's paddy fields mentioned above which had been rendered useless on the commission of the Loktak Hydro Electric Project. 6.
An inquiry will be required to find out the areas of the petitioner association's paddy fields mentioned above which had been rendered useless on the commission of the Loktak Hydro Electric Project. 6. In the above factual context, this writ petition is disposed of at this stage with a direction to the respondents to held an inquiry as to find out exact areas of the members of the petitioner association's paddy fields mentioned above which had been rendered useless on the commission of the Loktak Hydro Electric Project. On making such an inquiry, if it is found that the said whole area or part of the fertile paddy fields mentioned above of the petitioner association had been rendered useless on the commission of the Loktak Hydro Electric Project, the respondents are to fix a reasonable compensation for the damage caused to the fertile paddy fields of the members of the petitioner association and to pay to the concerned members of the petitioner association. The whole exercise should be completed within a period of six months from the date of receipt of this order. 7. With the above observations and direction, this writ petition is disposed of.