Research › Search › Judgment

Calcutta High Court · body

2010 DIGILAW 359 (CAL)

Rita Ghosh v. United India Insurance Company Ltd.

2010-04-06

B.BHATTACHARYA, PRASENJIT MANDAL

body2010
JUDGMENT: Bhaskar Bhattacharya, Prasenjit Mandal, JJ. 1. WE propose to hear out the appeal itself by treating it as on day's list. 2. THIS appeal is at the instance of claimant in a proceedings under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act and is directed against an award dated 29 th November, 2005 passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Additional District Judge, P Court, Paschim Medinipur thereby disposing off the said proceeding by awarding a sum of Rs. 3,53,012.00, out of which a sum of Rs. 25,000.00 had already been received in an earlier proceeding under Section 140 of the Act. Therefore, in this proceeding under Section 166 of the Act, the Insurance Company was directed to deposit the balance amount of Rs. 3,28,012.00 as compensation within a month from the date of the award with further direction that in default, the amount should carry interest at the rate of 7% per annum. 3. BEING dissatisfied, the claimant has come up with the present appeal. 4. THERE is no dispute as regards the death of the victim in an accident and it has been further established from evidence on record that the death occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of the driver of the offending vehicle. It has also been established that the United India Insurance Company Limited is the insurer of the said vehicle. The only dispute raised in this appeal is as regards the amount of compensation awarded by the learned Tribunal. 5. IT appears that the victim was an employee of West Bangal State Electricity Board at the relevant point of time and was aged 51 years and he could have completed further nine years of service. The gross income of the victim has been found to be Rs. 7,066.00, but the learned Tribunal below while assessing the amount of compensation decided to calculate the same on the basis of the net income of Rs. 4,471 .00. 6. MR. Banik, learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the appellant, contends that the learned Tribunal below should have simply deducted a sum of Rs. 45.00 out of Rs. 7,066.00 as professional tax and other deductions were for contribution of the victim towards the general provident fund and thus, that amount was the savings of the victim. Mr. Chakaraborty, learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the Insurance Company, does not dispute the aforesaid submission of Mr. Banik. 45.00 out of Rs. 7,066.00 as professional tax and other deductions were for contribution of the victim towards the general provident fund and thus, that amount was the savings of the victim. Mr. Chakaraborty, learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the Insurance Company, does not dispute the aforesaid submission of Mr. Banik. 7. WE, therefore, modify the award impugned by reassessing the same on the basis of the monthly income of Rs. 7,000.00 as round figure with the multiplier of 9 as 9 years of service was still left and on that basis, by applying the Second Schedule of the Act, the amount will come to Rs. 5,04,000.00. 8. WE, thus, set aside the award impugned and enhance the same to Rs. 5,O4,000.00 out of which a sum of Rs. 25,000.00 having already been paid in an earlier proceeding under Section 140 of the Act. The Insurance Company is directed to pay the balance amount of Rs. 4,79,000.00 with interest at the rate of 8% per annum from the date of filing of the application till actual deposit of the amount within a month from today before the learned Tribunal below. It is needless to mention that running of interest will stop from the date of deposit of the amount by the Insurance Company. With the aforesaid observation, the appeal is, thus, disposed off. 9. IN view of disposal of the appeal itself, the connected application has become infructous and the same is disposed off accordingly. 10. XEROX certified copies of this order, if applied for, be given to the learned counsel appearing for the parties within a week from the date of filing of the application.