JUDGMENT Kurian Joseph, The petitioner is aggrieved since his dispute has not been referred to by the Labour Commissioner for adjudication before the Industrial Tribunal/Labour Court. It is seen from the impugned order that the Labour Commissioner has considered the demand and the report on conciliation. It has been found that the petitioner staked the claim only after 14 years of his disengagement. Therefore, the reference has been declined in light of the decision of this Court in M.C. Paonta Sahib vs. State of Himachal Pradesh. We find that recently a Full Bench of this Court has also taken the same view in Liaq Ram vs. State of H.P., decided on 6.1.2011. The issued is, thus, covered against the petitioner. The petition stands dismissed accordingly.