Research › Search › Judgment

Patna High Court · body

2011 DIGILAW 546 (PAT)

Girija Dusadh v. State Of Bihar

2011-04-05

ANJANA PRAKASH

body2011
JUDGEMENT Anjana Prakash, J. 1. The Appellant has been convicted under Sections 307, 326 and 323 Indian Penal Code and sentenced to Rl for 7 years, 3 years and 1 year respectively by the First Additional Sessions Judge, Bhabhua in S.Tr. No. 489 of 1990/95 of 1992 by a judgment dated, 7th August, 1994. 2. The case of the prosecution is that on 4th October, 1989 while the father of the Informant was going to tend to her cattle the Accused persons assaulted her with a small "Danda". 3. The prosecution examined four witnesses in support of the prosecution case out of whom PW. 1 is the hearsay whereas PW. 2 is formal, PW. 3 is the Informant whereas PW. 4 is the Doctor who examined the injured and found two bruises on the person of the injured. Incidentally, the two witnesses who intervened and were also injured in the transaction were not examined during trial. 4. It appears that even though the occurrence has taken place on 4th October, 1989 report of the same was made much later on 5th October, 1989 at 4.15 P.M. and the prosecution has not offered any explanation for the delay. Further even though the case of the prosecution was that the injured was assaulted twice by lathi only one injury was found on her person. I also find that independent witnesses have not been examined during trial who were part of the prosecution case and in absence of the same it is difficult for this Court to hold that the prosecution has proved its case beyond all reasonable doubt. 5. In view of the discussion mentioned above, the appeal is allowed and the judgment dated, 17th August, 1994 passed in S. Tr. No. 489 of 1990/95 of 1992 by the First Additional Sessions Judge, Bhabhua is set aside. The Appellant is discharge of the liability of his bail bond.