Basant Kaur v. Financial Commissioner (Appeals) Punjab
2013-05-26
K.KANNAN
body2013
DigiLaw.ai
JUDGMENT Mr. K. Kannan J. (Oral) - The writ petition challenges the order passed by the Financial Commissioner rejecting the plea of the petitioner for making the allotment to make good the deficiency of the extent which was allottable to him under the Displaced Persons Compensation and Rehabilitation Act and Rules. The claim by the petitioner was on the basis that he was a displaced person from the place now in Pakistan and he had held about 70 kanals of land as a tenant at the place now in Pakistan. He had entered upon property of 42 kanals 17 marlas and made an application of 25.01.1961 for making of an allotment and for transfer of property of such an extent. He had been allotted 30 kanals 6 marlas of land. This was more or less equivalent to a value of Rs.13,367/-. His plea was that the property allottable to the balance of amount namely of Rs.1633/- was to be also issued to him. The prayer was taken up by the authority on 22.02.1973 and the order passed that the value of the extent of property allottable shall be with reference to the value as on the date in the year 1973. This order of the Financial Commissioner is in challenge before this Court. 2. The petitioner would rely on the instructions issued by the Government on 07.07.1981 that sets out under Chapter V-A under the Rules of 1955 that the fixation of market price by the rate prevailing in the year 1960-61 had been modified and in future while disposing of such cases, the market price prevailing on the date of making application should be charged. The contention is that this application was made in the year 1961 itself and that shall be the valuation which must be considered and it cannot be on the date when the order was passed by the Financial Commissioner. This point has also been illustrated from a decision in C.W.P. No.3805 of 1976 titled “Shri Sohinder Singh (deceased) through LRs. Vs. Union of India and others” decided by this Court on 29.03.1983 that in respect of pending applications since the year 1961, he shall be charged at the market price prevailing at that time only.
This point has also been illustrated from a decision in C.W.P. No.3805 of 1976 titled “Shri Sohinder Singh (deceased) through LRs. Vs. Union of India and others” decided by this Court on 29.03.1983 that in respect of pending applications since the year 1961, he shall be charged at the market price prevailing at that time only. I find the petitioner’s claim to be well founded and the extent of property allottable for Rs.1633/- as on the date of his application namely 25.01.1961 alone shall be given. The extent of property shall be properly priced with reference to the said valuation and transfer may be made in accordance with relevant provisions of the Act and Rules. 3. The writ petition is allowed on the above terms. The entire exercise shall be completed by the State within a period of three months from the date of receipt of copy of this order. ---------0.B.S.0------------ —————————