Research › Search › Judgment

Allahabad High Court · body

2014 DIGILAW 1429 (ALL)

TARAMATI DEVI v. STATE OF U. P.

2014-05-02

RAJAN ROY, TARUN AGARWALA

body2014
JUDGMENT Hon’ble Rajan Roy, J.—This writ petition was filed originally for the following reliefs: “(i) Issue a writ order or direction in the nature of mandamus directing the respondents to conduct a thorough and proper investigation into the disappearance of petitioner’s husband Shri Sakaldeep Singh from the custody of police hospital, Kanpur; (ii) Issue a writ order or direction in the nature of mandamus directing the respondents to award compensation for the loss caused to the petitioner due to illegal, arbitrary and callus action of the respondents resulting into disappearance of the petitioner’s husband Shri Sakaldeep Singh from the Police Hospital Kanpur; (iii) Issue a writ order or direction in the nature of mandamus directing the respondents to consider the petitioner for appointment on suitable post in the police department;” 2. It was dismissed by this Court on the ground of unexplained laches vide judgement and order dated 4th March, 2009, which was set aside in appeal and the matter was remitted to this Court by the Supreme Court vide its judgement and order dated 5th April, 2010 passed in Civil Appeal No. 2996 of 2010, the relevant extracts of which are quoted herein-below: 5. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record. In our view, the High Court committed serious error by refusing to order investigation into disappearance of the appellant’s husband. It appears that the Division Bench of the High Court was unduly influenced by the fact that the appellant’s husband had been dismissed from service vide order dated 12th July, 2004 and she had approached the Court after a time gap of about five years. While doing so, the Division Bench ignored that the prayer made by the appellant was, in substance, for issue of writ in the nature of habeas corpus. In our view, in a case like the present one, the High Court should not have non-suited the appellant only on the ground of delay by overlooking the fact that she had knocked the doors of administrative authorities and political Head of the State. 6. For the reason stated above, the appeal is allowed. The impugned order is set aside and the matter is remitted to the High Court for deciding the writ petition afresh. 7. 6. For the reason stated above, the appeal is allowed. The impugned order is set aside and the matter is remitted to the High Court for deciding the writ petition afresh. 7. We also direct the Director General of Police of the State of Uttar Pradesh to depute an officer not below the rank of Deputy Inspector General of Police to make an investigation into the disappearance of the appellant’s husband Shri Sakaldeep Singh from Police Hospital, Kanpur. The report of the investigation be submitted to the High Court within a period of three and half months. 8. The High Court is requested to consider the matter in the light of the report of the Deputy Inspector General of Police and pass appropriate order in accordance with law.” 3. After remand from the Supreme Court, petitioner amended the writ petition twice and added following reliefs: “(ia) Issue a writ or order or direction in the nature of Certiorari quashing the order of dismissal of petitioner’s husband Shri Sakaldeep Singh (Annexure 7 to the writ petition) and to direct the respondents to provide the petitioner the arrears of pay, pension, gratuity, provident fund, leave-encashment and other retirement benefits of her husband and to grant and pay to the petitioner the pension of her husband as according to law as well as to provide the employment on compassionate ground to the son of petitioner Santan Kumar Singh in U.P.Police. (iiia) Issue a writ of Habeas Corpus directing the respondents to produce Shri Sakaldeep Singh an undischarged serious patient missing from Police Medico custody before this Hon’ble Court. In case he is heeled, to disclose the name of offenders who are involved in his murder and to register criminal case against the offenders, for proper investigation and for punishing the offenders according to law.” 4. Pursuant to the aforesaid direction of the Supreme Court, the Director General of Police, U.P., deputed Deputy Inspector General, P.A.C., Kanpur to investigate into the matter of disappearance of the petitioner’s husband namely Shri Sakaldeep Singh. The investigation was conducted and report was submitted on 3rd August, 2010, which has been brought on record as Annexure 3 to the affidavit filed by Smt. Hem Lata Singh, Deputy Superintendent of Police, Kanpur Nagar. 5. The investigation was conducted and report was submitted on 3rd August, 2010, which has been brought on record as Annexure 3 to the affidavit filed by Smt. Hem Lata Singh, Deputy Superintendent of Police, Kanpur Nagar. 5. Thereafter on 17th September, 2012, this Court took cognizance of the said report of the Deputy Inspector General dated 3rd August, 2010 and passed an order, relevant extracts of which, are quoted below: “Learned Standing Counsel has not been able to inform as what steps have been taken by the Inspector General of Police (Lok Shikayat) on the aforesaid recommendations. Learned Standing Counsel is allowed ten days time to obtain instructions as to from which Investigation Branch the investigation has been directed to be completed. Learned Standing Counsel may obtain instruction and inform the Court as to what action has been taken on the aforesaid recommendations. After obtaining information from Inspector General of Police (Lok Shikayat), instructions be also obtained from the Director General of Police, U.P. who has been directed by the Apex Court on 5.4.2010 for carrying out the investigation within three and half months which time has already been lapsed. A copy of this order may be given to the learned Standing Counsel for communication to the authorities concerned.” 6. Then, the learned Standing Counsel brought to the notice of this Court on 4th October, 2012 that an order had already been passed by the Director General of Police (Lok Shikayat) on 25th September, 2012, for getting impartial investigation completed in the supervision of Deputy Inspector General of Police/S.S.P. Kanpur Nagar and on 29th September, 2012, the S.S.P. (City) had constituted a Committee of seven police officials to carry on the investigation in Case Crime No. 349 of 2012 under Section 364 IPC. Thereafter, this Court directed the Deputy Inspector General of Police, Kanpur Nagar to take appropriate steps so that the investigation may be completed and appropriate report may also be brought on record. 7. Thereafter, this Court directed the Deputy Inspector General of Police, Kanpur Nagar to take appropriate steps so that the investigation may be completed and appropriate report may also be brought on record. 7. Accordingly, the investigation was completed and final report dated 3rd December, 2012 was submitted, the relevant extracts of which are quoted here in below: “Jheku th] fuosnu gS fd eqdnek mijksDr fnukad 4@6@10 dks ntZ xqe’kqnxh dk0 1846 uk0 iq0 ldynhi flag ds vk/kkj ij fnukad 26@9@12 dks cgokys jiV la[;k 34 ij èkkjk 364 vkbZ0 ih0 lh0 esa rjehe dj foospuk eq> mifujh{kd ds lqiqnZ dh x;h foospuk ds e/; ladfyr lk{; o Mh0lh0vkj0ch0 ls ryk’k x’rh fuxZr djkus] ldynhi flag dh gqfy;k dk iEiysV Niokdj fofHkUu lkoZtfud LFkyksa o dkUl0 ldynhi flag ds x‘g tuin xkao rFkk jsyos LVs’kuksa esa pLik djkus rFkk vkdk’kok.kh dsUnz ls izlkj.k djkus fofHkUu lekpkj i=ksa es izdk’ku iwoZ esa o orZeku esa djkus rFkk iqfyl v/kh{kd ,l0lh0vkj0ch0 dh csclkbM esa miyC/k o”kZ 2004 ds ckn ds vKkr ‘koksa esa ls dkUl0 ldynhi flag dh gqfy;k dk dksbZ ‘ko u gksus o vU; reke ;qfDr;qDr iz;kl djus ds ckn Hkh vkj{kh ldynhi flag dk dksbZ irk ugha py ldk gS k izdj.k dkQh iqjkuk 2004 dk gS k foospuk lss iwoZ HkwriwoZ vkj{kkh 1846 uk0iq0 ldynhi flag dk irk yxkus dk gj laHko iz;kl iqfyl egkfujh{kd (yks0 f’k0) eq[;ky; iqfyl egkfuns’kd m0iz0 ds i= la[;k Mh0th0&nl&109@2010 fnukad 3@5@2010 ds vuqikyu esa Jh vHk; dqekj izlkn Mh0vkbZ0th0 ih0,0lh0 dkuiqj vuqHkkx] dkuiqj }kjk viuh izf”kr fjiksVZ i= la[;k ih0,0lh0&d0s@,l0&,0&ch0&21@2010@9456 fnukad 3@8@10 ds ek/;e ls Hkh fd;k tk pqdk gS ijUrq iqoZ dkUl0 la[;k 1846 lh0ih0 ldynhi flga ds thfor@e‘r gksus dk Li”V lk{; ugha fey ldk Fkk k ,slh fLFkfr esa foospuk tkjh j[kuk cslq/k gS A vr% ryk’k xqe’kqnk vkj{kh (HkwriwoZ) ldynhi flag tkjh j[krs gq, foospuk }kjk ,Q0vkj0 ua0 306@12 lekIr dh tkrh gS A vuqjksèk gS fd ,Q0 vkj0 Lohd‘r djus dh d‘ik dh tk;s A” 8. Against the aforesaid final report, no protest petition was filed, the Special C.J.M. Kanpur Nagar took cognizance of the same and 7th February, 2014 was the date fixed for consideration thereof, as is apparent from the affidavit of Sri Netrapal Singh, Circle Officer, Kotwali, Kanpur Nagar dated 23rd January, 2014. 9. Against the aforesaid final report, no protest petition was filed, the Special C.J.M. Kanpur Nagar took cognizance of the same and 7th February, 2014 was the date fixed for consideration thereof, as is apparent from the affidavit of Sri Netrapal Singh, Circle Officer, Kotwali, Kanpur Nagar dated 23rd January, 2014. 9. Now adverting to the facts of the case, it appears that petitioner’s husband Shri Sakaldeep Singh was posted as constable in civil police at Kanpur Nagar, in the year 2001. On the occasion of Shri Krishna Janmashtmi, he was asked to report for duty at Mathura, but he fell down and became unconscious on 10th August, 2001, therefore, did not report for duty at Mathura and took medical treatment at L.L.R. Hospital, Kanpur. However, he joined duty in November, 2003. Therefore, for his long absence from duty w.e.f. 5th September, 2001 to 11th November, 2003, a charge-sheet was issued to him on 1st December, 2003. On 6th December, 2003, he again fell ill and was admitted in Police Hospital, Police Lines, Kanpur. On 15th December, 2003 he submitted reply to aforesaid charge-sheet. On 11th February, 2004, he disappeared from the Police Hospital and returned back to the hospital on 13th February, 2004 and informed that he had gone to Ursala Hospital for treatment. Thereafter, on 15th February, 2004, he again disappeared from the Police Hospital, Police Lines, Kanpur and did not come back. 10. The contention of the petitioner is that her husband was suffering from mental diseases, therefore, it was for the staff of the Police Hospital as well as the police personnel to take care of him but they acted irresponsibly. Neither they took proper care of him nor made any effort to trace him out. She alleged foul play in disappearance of her husband and suspected that he might have been killed. 11. However, pursuant to the aforesaid charge-sheet, disciplinary proceedings were conducted against Shri Sakaldeep Singh, husband of the petitioner and ultimately he was dismissed from service on 12th July, 2004. 11-A. We have heard learned counsel for the petitioner as well as the learned Standing Counsel and carefully perused the report submitted by the Deputy Inspector General, P.A.C., Kanpur dated 3rd August, 2010. The Apex Court has required this Court to consider the matter in the light of the report of the Deputy Inspector General, P.A.C., Kanpur. 12. 11-A. We have heard learned counsel for the petitioner as well as the learned Standing Counsel and carefully perused the report submitted by the Deputy Inspector General, P.A.C., Kanpur dated 3rd August, 2010. The Apex Court has required this Court to consider the matter in the light of the report of the Deputy Inspector General, P.A.C., Kanpur. 12. From the report it appears that a deep investigation was conducted in the matter. Petitioner’s husband Shri Sakaldeep Singh, was searched at all known places where he used to visit and necessary enquiries were made from all his close relatives and acquaintances etc. Relevant witnesses were examined and oral as well as documentary evidences were collected. 13. The report reveals that during the service period of Shri Sakaldeep Singh, the petitioner and her son did not reside with him. The petitioner used to reside at her original place of residence in Bihar whereas Shri Sakaldeep Singh used to reside at different places of his postings. The petitioner and her son rarely used to visit to him and that too only to collect money. In fact, the statement of the witnesses, who are close associates of Shri Sakaldeep Singh, shows that they were aware of only two instances when the son of the petitioner had come to him, firstly to take money from him and thereafter in the year 2007 to know his whereabouts i.e. about 3 or 4 years after his disappearance. 14. The report also reveals that Shri Sakaldeep Singh had developed illicit relations with one Smt. Anita w/o Sri Ram Chandra r/o Rajkiya Unnayan Basti Bithoor road Colony, P.S. Kalyanpur, District Kanpur Nagar, as is evident from her statement which is part of the report at sl. No. 20. The said fact is also borne out from the statement of Dayanand Rai son of Sri Harihar Rai, permanent r/o Hans Nagar P.S. Haldi, district Ballia, temporary r/o LIG 113, Indira Nagar P.S. Kalyanpur, district Kanpur, a close friend of Sri Sakaldeep Singh. 15. The report also reveals that Sri Sakaldeep Singh used to drink heavily and in the drunken state, he used to indulge in unruly behaviour in public. He was frustrated and greatly disturbed because of his family problems, specially for the reason that the money given by him to his son for the purpose of marriage of his daughter, was misappropriated by his son. He was frustrated and greatly disturbed because of his family problems, specially for the reason that the money given by him to his son for the purpose of marriage of his daughter, was misappropriated by his son. His service record was full of adverse materials as detailed in the report. 16. The report also indicates that the petitioner was repeatedly requested to provide photographs of Sri Sakaldeep Singh, which would facilitate in tracing him out, but no cooperation was extended nor any photograph was provided. Despite non-cooperation, the officials made all possible efforts to investigate the matter and trace out Sri Sakaldeep Singh, but with no success. 17. The report also reveals that after his disappearance on 11th February, 2004 from the Police Hospital Police Lines, Kanpur, Sri Sakaldeep Singh was seen in public in a drunken state on 3rd/4th March, 2004 begging for money from the passers-by and a news report in this regard was published in the daily news paper Dainik Jagaran, which has also been taken note of in the investigation report. The said fact has also been corroborated by several witnesses. This fact clearly goes to show that the disappearance of Sri Sakaldeep Singh from the Police Hospital on 11th February, 2004 was not the result of any foul play on the part of the hospital staff or the police personnels and that he was alive even after 11th February, 2004. This fact is also corroborated by the statement of aforesaid Smt. Anita w/o Sri Ram Chandra, who also stated that Sri Sakaldeep Singh visited her place in very good condition in September, 2004. Therefore, the story of any foul play is not acceptable. 18. It has also come in the report that the villagers have stated that if Sri Sakaldeep Singh had died, then his family members would have certainly performed his last rituals in the village but the same was not done. Therefore, the possibility of Sri Sakaldeep Singh being alive, cannot be ruled out and it may also be possible that the petitioner is deliberately concealing existence Sri Sakaldeep Singh with a view to procure compassionate appointment of her son. 19. Therefore, the possibility of Sri Sakaldeep Singh being alive, cannot be ruled out and it may also be possible that the petitioner is deliberately concealing existence Sri Sakaldeep Singh with a view to procure compassionate appointment of her son. 19. The report also reveals that the belongings of Sri Sakaldeep Singh have been handed over to Sri Santanu Kumar Singh son of Sri Sakaldeep Singh and the documentary proof in this regard contains the signatures of Santanu Kumar Singh, Sri Chandra Shekhar Panda & other persons. Therefore, the allegations of the petitioner in this regard are false. 20. The report also reveals that extensive publication regarding disappearance of Sri Sakaldeep Singh was made in the news papers, though without photograph, and several teams were constituted to find out his whereabouts, but without any success. 21. The Investigator has also found on the basis of oral and documentary evidence collected during the course of investigation that Sri Sakaldeep Singh was admitted to Police Hospital, Police Line Kanpur for the ailment of Asthama, Fever and Lungs Infection. 22. 21. The Investigator has also found on the basis of oral and documentary evidence collected during the course of investigation that Sri Sakaldeep Singh was admitted to Police Hospital, Police Line Kanpur for the ailment of Asthama, Fever and Lungs Infection. 22. 21. The Investigator has also found on the basis of oral and documentary evidence collected during the course of investigation that Sri Sakaldeep Singh was admitted to Police Hospital, Police Line Kanpur for the ailment of Asthama, Fever and Lungs Infection. 22. Relevant extracts of the report dated 3rd August, 2010 are quoted herein-below: “10& fjiksVZ &fujh{kd izKku cfy;k vkj{kh ‘kdynhi flag iq= Jh Lo0 jkèkkd‘”.k flag xzke fi;jkSVk Fkkuk jsorh tuin cfy;k dk ewy fuoklh gSA vkj{kh mijksDr lxk ikap HkkbZ gSA lcls cMk jkt fd’kksj flag ftuds nks yMds dze’k% cPpk mQZ uUn yky o r?ku l;u gS tks orZeku esa xzke o Fkkuk fugkjh ftyk nqedk dfVgkj fcgkj esa jgrs gS ogka ij muds ikl lSdMks ch?kk tehu] O;olk; rFkk dslj vkfn gS nwljs HkkbZ dk uke dqaoj pUnznhi flag gS buds nks yMds yYyu rFkk txujk;u gSA ;g xzke fijjkSVk rFkk efugkjh nksuks txg jgrs gSaA rhljs HkkbZ dk uke dqynhi flag Fkk ftudh ‘kknh ughas gqbZ FkhA pkSFks HkkbZ mijksDr ldynhi flga gS tks iqfyl foHkkx esa vkj{kh in ij lsokjr Fks buds nks yMds Øe’k% gjsUnz flag rFkk lUru flag gS ;g yksx Hkh efugkjh esa jgrs gSA ikapos HkkbZ dSyk’k flag Fks tks ih,lh esa vkj{kh in ij lsokjr Fks buds pkj yMdh Fkh pkjks dh ‘kknh gks pqdh gSA dSyk’k flag dk Ms< ekg iwoZ LoxZokl gks pqdk gS ftudk nkg laLdkj o rsjgh efugkjh esa gh lEiUu gqbZ gS ftlesa xzko fi;jkSVk ds dqN yksx ‘kkfey gksus ds fy, x;s FksA vk0 ldynhi flag Hkh”k.k ‘kjkc ihus dk vknh gS rFkk bldk pfjf=d iru Hkh gks pqdk FkkA vkl iMksl rFkk bldh HkkHkh Jherh y[kirh nsoh iRuh pUnznhi flag us ncs rkSj ij izdV fd;k fd dkuiqj esa dksbZ vkSjr j[ks FksA ?kj dk vkuk tkuk ugha jgrk Fkk o”kZ esa ,d nks ekg ckj vkrs FksA b/kj 08 o”kksZ ls xkao esa ugha vk;k gSA yksxksa dk dguk gS fd dgha xk;c gks x;k gSA bldh e‘R;q ds fo”k; esa iwjs xkao oklh iqf”V ugha dj jgs gSA xzke okfl;ksa dk ekuuk gS fd ;fn mldh e‘R;q gks x;h gksrh rks bldk fdz;kdeZ ifjokj ds yksxksa }kjk fd;k x;k gksrkA bldk yMdk lUru flag blds LFkku ij ukSdjh ysuk pkgrk gSA yqd fNi ds efugkjh rFkk dkuiqj esa jguk lEHkkouk ls ijs ugha gks ldrkA ;g rF; lR; gS fd vHkh e‘R;q ugha gqbZ bldh iqf”V xzkekoklh rFkk ikl iMksl ds yksxksa }kjk ugha gks ik jgh gS%& 18& c;ku Jh n;k jke jk; iq= Lo0 Jh gfjgj jk; fuoklh xzke gluxj ih0 ,l0 gYnh tuin cfy;k gky fuokl ,y0 vkbZ0 th0 113 bUnzk uxj ih0 ,l0 dY;kuiqj mez djhc 48 o”kZ ugha gks ldrkA ;g rF; lR; gS fd vHkh e‘R;q ugha gqbZ bldh iqf”V xzkekoklh rFkk ikl iMksl ds yksxksa }kjk ugha gks ik jgh gS%& 18& c;ku Jh n;k jke jk; iq= Lo0 Jh gfjgj jk; fuoklh xzke gluxj ih0 ,l0 gYnh tuin cfy;k gky fuokl ,y0 vkbZ0 th0 113 bUnzk uxj ih0 ,l0 dY;kuiqj mez djhc 48 o”kZ eks0 ua0 &945142512 & c;ku fd;k fd eS dkuiqj dpgjh esa odyr djrk gwaA vkj{kh ldynhi flag dks bUnzk uxj pkSdh esa rSukrh ds le; ls tkurk gwaA ldynhi flag ewyr% cfy;k ds jgus okys Fks fdlh dkj.k vf/kd tku igpku gks x;h FkhA ldynhi flag bUnzk uxj pkSdh Fkkuk dY;kuiqj ds ckn vU; Fkkuksa pkSfd;ksa esa Hkh rSukr jgs ijUrq esjk dgha dksbZ vkuk tkuk ugha gksrk FkkA dgha vkrs tkrs feyrs o gky pky ysrs nsrs jgrs Fks o”kZ 2001 esa vxLr ekg esa dpgjh ls vius ?kj tk jgs Fks rks jkoriqj LVs’ku ds ikl HkhM tek Fkh tgka ewfNZr voLFkk esa ,d flikgh iMk gksus dh ckr irk pyh dks eSus ns[kk fd og ldynhi flag FksA ;g ns[kdj o tkudj eSus gky pky fy;k o izkFkfed mipkj djkdj tkus fn;kA dgka x;s eq>s ugha ekywe chp chp esa og esjs ?kj vk tkrs Fks yxHkx nks ekg esa dkQh ryk’k o chekj voLFkk esa fn[kk;h iMrs Fks vkSj dqN iSlksa dh lgk;rk ekax jgs Fks eS ;Fkk lEHko mudh enn Hkh djrk FkkA ;g dze cjkcj pyrk jgrk Fkk eSus :Ik;k lkS ls T;knk dHkh ugh fn;kA vius osru ds iSlksa dk og D;k djrs Fks eq>s ughas ekywe A ukSdjh ls xSj gkftj jguk mudh vknr Fkh tSlk fd muds lkFkh o lg;ksfx;ksa ls irk pyrk Fkk ;g ckr 2001 ls 2003 ds e/; dh gS blh chp esa lqcks/k xqIrk uke ds ,d dks;ys ds O;kikjh ls ldynhi us esjk ifjp; djk;kA ;g dgrs gq, fd ;g xqIrkth vius iwokZapy ds gS rFkk esjs vR;ar [kkl gS rFkk bUgksaus Hkh esjh cgqr enn dh gS budk tks Hkh dke iMs vki budh enn dj nhft;sxkA blds ckn ge nksuks yksx vkil esa feyrs tqyrs jgrs Fks A fnlEcj ekg 2003 esa lqcks/k xqIrk ds lkFk chekjh gkyr esa esjs ?kj vk;s rks mudh gkyr ns[kdj eSus lqcks/k xqIrk us vkj0 vkbZ0 Jh txnh’k flag ls eqykdkr dh o muls lkjh ckr crk;k rks vkj0 vkbZ0 lkgc us ldynhi dh chekjh dks ns[krs gq, dj nhft;sxkA blds ckn ge nksuks yksx vkil esa feyrs tqyrs jgrs Fks A fnlEcj ekg 2003 esa lqcks/k xqIrk ds lkFk chekjh gkyr esa esjs ?kj vk;s rks mudh gkyr ns[kdj eSus lqcks/k xqIrk us vkj0 vkbZ0 Jh txnh’k flag ls eqykdkr dh o muls lkjh ckr crk;k rks vkj0 vkbZ0 lkgc us ldynhi dh chekjh dks ns[krs gq, iqfyl vLirky esa HkrhZ djk;k rFkk nok vkfn dh A leqfpr O;oLFkk gsrq lEcfU/kr dks funsZ’k Hkh fn,A blds ckn eSa o xqIrkth ldynhi dh cjkcj ns[kjs[k gsrq vLirky tkrs jgrs FksA ,d fnu vLirky ds LVkQ ulZ ¼fM;wVh ulZ½ o vU; HkrhZ ejhtksa us eq>s crk;k fd vki ftl ejht dh ns[kjs[k djus vkrs gS mlls vkidk D;k lEca/k gSA esjs }kjk ;g crkus ij fd esjk dksbZ fj’rk ugh ekuork o xkao {ks= gksus ds dkj.k eS budh ns[kjs[k djrk gwa ‘kk;n og yksx eq>s dqN crkuk pkgrs FksA esjs iwaNus ij D;k dksbZ ckr gS ]\ rks mu yksxks us crk;k fd ;g ejht jkr esa fcLrj ls mBdj pksjh fNis ‘kjkc ihdj nsj jkf= esa ykSVrk gS rFkk lcdks Hkyk cqjk dgrk gSA euk djus ij xkyh xykSt djrk gS vki bls le>k;sA esjs iwNus ij ldynhi dqN mRrj ugh nsrk FkkA fnukad 12&2&2004 dks eSa vLirky x;k rks ‘kke dks ldynhi ugha feys rks eSus MkDVj ls iwNk rks MkDVj us dgk fd mudk jkst dk dke gS fd ;s pys tkrs gS vkSj okil vk tkrs gSA vki fpUrk u djs rks eSa pyk x;k FkkA vxys fnu okil vk x;k Fkk rks eSa ‘kke dks vLirky x;k vkSj feyk rks iwaNk fd dgka pys tkrs gks rks mlus eq>s dksbZ mRrj ugha fn;kA ,slh fLFkfr vkrh Fkh fd tc Hkh og dksbZ xyrh djrk Fkk rks iwNus ij pqIih lk/k ysrk Fkk vkSj dksbZ tokc ugha nsrk Fkk rFkk eSa Hkh mldk fygkt ns[kdj vf/kd xgjkbZ esa ugha tkrk Fkk mlds ckn eSa fnukad 15&2&2004 dks iqfyl vLirky x;k rks ldynhi fQj vLirky esa ugh feyk rks eSusa MkDVjks ls iwNk fd ldynhi dgka gS rks MkDVjksa us dgk fd vkt fQj fcuk crk;s og vLirky ls xk;c gks x;k gSA bl ij eSa vLirky ls okil vk;k vkSj vius lzksrks ls yxkrkj tkudkjh o ryk’k djrk jgk rks fnukad 4&3&2004 dks nsSfud tkxj.k v[ckj esa Hkh[k ekax dj ‘kjkc ih jgk flikgh ‘khf”kZd ij esjh fuxkg iMh rks ldynhi dk uke i<+dj dgka gS rks MkDVjksa us dgk fd vkt fQj fcuk crk;s og vLirky ls xk;c gks x;k gSA bl ij eSa vLirky ls okil vk;k vkSj vius lzksrks ls yxkrkj tkudkjh o ryk’k djrk jgk rks fnukad 4&3&2004 dks nsSfud tkxj.k v[ckj esa Hkh[k ekax dj ‘kjkc ih jgk flikgh ‘khf”kZd ij esjh fuxkg iMh rks ldynhi dk uke i<+dj eSa vk’p;Z pfdr jg x;k vkSj fQj v[ckj dh [kcj ds fglkc ls flfoy ykbu iqfyl] iqfyl ykbu o dpgjh ds vklikl ds eqgYyksa vkfn esa eSa o lqcksèk xqIrk us dkQh ryk’k o iwaNrkaN dh ijUrq dgha irk ugha pyk mlds ckn ls ge yksx vkt rd Hkh ldynhi flag dk <wa<us dk Á;kl djrs jgrs gSA 19& c;ku Jh lqcks/k dqekj xqIrk iq= Jh jkepUnz xqIrk fuoklh 127@144 ;w0 Cykd fujkyk uxj ih0 ,l0 fdnobZ uxj] dkuiqj uxj mez djhc 38 o”kZ eks0 ua0& 9336236048] 8005188504 c;ku fd;k fd eSa tjhc pkSdh Fkkuk {ks= ‘kh’kkem esa dks;ys dk O;kikj djrk gwaA blh O;kikj esa dbZ O;kikfj;ksa ls iSls dk ysu nsu pyrk jgrk gSA ,d O;kikjh tks Fkkuk XokyVksyh {ks= esa jgrk Fkk vkSj mldk uke xksih d‘”.k lkgw Fkk ls dqN :i;s dk ysunsu Fkk tks nsus esa vkukdkuh djrk Fkk rFkk /kedh vkfn Hkh fn;k djrk rks eSaus Fkkuk XokyVksyh esa f’kdk;r dh Fkh mlh f’kdk;r dh iSjoh vkfn esa vkj{kh Jh ldynhi flag ls esjs eqykdkr gks x;h vkSj èkhjs /khjs nksLrh o vkuk tkuk gks x;kA XokyVksyh ds ckn budk LFkkukUrj.k Fkkuk Qtyxat gks x;k tgka ls mUgsa pkSdh n’kZuiqjok Hkst fn;k x;k FkkA utnhd fu;qDr gks tkus ds dkj.k utnhdh vkSj c< x;h rFkk esjk Hkh pkSdh ij vf/kd vkuk tkuk gks x;kA ml le; Jh ,0 ,u0 HkV~V muds pkSdh bapktZ Fks izk;% izfrfnu gh gekjh mudh eqykdkr gksrh FkhA dHkh rks vk tkrs FksA gekjs ?kj dHkh ge mudh pkSdh tk tks Fkkus ds vanj gh cuh gS pys tkrs FksA Jh f=iqjkjh ik.Ms; Hkh mlh pkSdh ij flikgh Fks tks vc lc balisDVj gS ml le; Jh oh0 ,l0 xkfoZ;ky balisDVj Qtyxat Fks mlh chp fdlh ckr dks ysdj ldynhi nnnw ls balisDVj lkgc ukjkt gks x;s rks mudk LFkkukUrj.k cjkZ pkSdh djk fn;k Fkk mlds rhu pkj ekg ckn iqu% mudk LFkkukUrj.k Qtyxat gks x;k FkkA lEHkork Qtyxat ls gh mudh fM;wVh eFkqjk yx x;h ml fM;wVh gsrq pys tkus ds ckn djhcs <kbZ o”kZ rd xk;c jgk dgha balisDVj Qtyxat Fks mlh chp fdlh ckr dks ysdj ldynhi nnnw ls balisDVj lkgc ukjkt gks x;s rks mudk LFkkukUrj.k cjkZ pkSdh djk fn;k Fkk mlds rhu pkj ekg ckn iqu% mudk LFkkukUrj.k Qtyxat gks x;k FkkA lEHkork Qtyxat ls gh mudh fM;wVh eFkqjk yx x;h ml fM;wVh gsrq pys tkus ds ckn djhcs <kbZ o”kZ rd xk;c jgk dgha dksbZ irk ugha pyk eSaus dbZ ckj <wa<us dk Hkh Á;kl fd;k dkQh le; rd irk djrk jgk rks fQj Fkkus tkdj irk fd;k rks Fkkus okys us crk;k fd nnnw ?kj x;s Fks ogha [kRe gks x;s eSa yxHkx fujk’k gks x;k Fkk djhc <kbZ o”kZ rd u feyus ds ckn vpkud lqcg&lqcg esjs ?kj vk;s rks ns[kdj cgqr vkpfEHkr gks x;k vkSj cSBkdj xk;c jgus dh ckr iwNk rks mUgksaus crk;k fd esjk fnekx fjVuZ gks x;k irk ugha fdlh us dqN f[kyk fn;k FkkA eS b/kj m/kj ?kwe jgk Fkk fd ,d eksVj lkbfdy okys us eq>s Vddj ekj nh Fkh ftlesa esjs iSj esa cgqr pksV vk x;h Fkh rks uokcxat esa tkxs’oj efaUnj ds ckckth us esjk bykt djok;k Fkk] djhc 3&4 ekg bykt gqvk mlds ckn eS b/kj m/kj ?kwerk jgk eq>s dqN ;kn ugha vk jgk Fkk fd csuk>kcj o ikl vpkud jk; lkgc eq>s feys vkSj vius lkFk ?kj ys x;s eSa ogha ls rqEgkjs ikl vk;k gwa eSus muls chrs le; dk gkypky iwNk iwjh tkudkjh ds ckn fiNys bykt vkfn dk esfMdy fudyok;k x;k vkSj iqu% iqfyl ykbUl esa vken gks x;hA vken gksus ds rqjUr ckn mudh rch;r vf/kd [kjkc gks x;h rks vkj0 vkbZ lkgc Hkh iqfyl vLirky esa mUgsa HkrhZ djk fn;k ogha mudk bykt pyrk jgk eS chp chp esa muls feydj gkypky ysrk jgk djhc nks ekg ds ckn ,d fnu tc eSa vLirky x;k rks ogka ij irk pyk fd ldynhi fcuk fdlh dks lwpuk fn, csM ls ogha pys x;s fQj ge o jk; lkgc us dkQh ryk’k fd;k dkuiqj ds lHkh lEHkkfor LFkkuksa ij <wa<k ijUrq dgha irk ugha pykA djhc 6&7 ekg ckn esjs ikl ldynhi dk yM+dk lru flag o mudh iRuh vk;h Fkh rks eSaus mUgsa Hkh iqfyl vLirky ls fcuk crk;s xk;c gks tkus dh ckr crk;k Fkk vkSj rc ls ysdj vktrd eq>s muds ckjs esa dksbZ tkudkjh ugh fey ldh djhch gksus ds ukrs eSaus Hkh vius Lrj ls dkQh <wa<us dk Á;kl fd;k ysfdu dksbZ ekg ckn esjs ikl ldynhi dk yM+dk lru flag o mudh iRuh vk;h Fkh rks eSaus mUgsa Hkh iqfyl vLirky ls fcuk crk;s xk;c gks tkus dh ckr crk;k Fkk vkSj rc ls ysdj vktrd eq>s muds ckjs esa dksbZ tkudkjh ugh fey ldh djhch gksus ds ukrs eSaus Hkh vius Lrj ls dkQh <wa<us dk Á;kl fd;k ysfdu dksbZ lQyrk ugha feyhA iz’u& Kkr gqvk fd ldynhi flag dks ikxyiu dh chekjh Fkh vkidh tkudkjh ds eqrkfcd ;g ikxyiu dh chekjh dc ls Fkh\ mRrj& mUgsa ikxyiu dh dksbZ chekjh ugha Fkh ijUrq og cgqr Vsa’ku esa jgrs FksA o”kZ 1998&99 esa ldynhi nnnw us viuh yMdh ehuk dh ‘kknh r; dh Fkh ‘kknh dh rS;kjh ds nkSjku eq>ls ckrphr esa dgrs Fks fd Q.M ls :Ik;k fudkydj rqEgs ns jgk gwaA tkrs le; ysrk vkmaxk rks eSusa bruk igys fudkyus ls euk fd;k vkSj tkrs le; fudky ysus dh ckr dh rks dqN fnu ckn vpkud mudk yMdk luru flag vk x;k rks mUgksaus ;g :i;k djhc 85]000@& fudkydj ns fn;k vkSj dgk fd ;s :Ik;s ys tkdj yMdk okyksa ds ?kj igqapk vkuk mlds ckn fryd dh frfFk ds 2&4 fnu igys ?kj igqapk rks yMds okys ‘kknh euk djus yxs vkSj r; ‘kqnk :i;s u igqapkus dh ckr dgh rks nksuks i{kks esa fookn gks x;k vkSj Fkkus esa eqdnek rd Hkh gks x;k ijUrq xkao okyksa o fj’rsnkjksa ds lg;ksx ls le>kSrk gks x;k vkSj nwljh txg ‘kknh r; dj nh blh chp xkao okyks ds lg;ksx ls nnnw dks irk pyk fd ‘kknh ds fy, Hksts x;s :Ik;ksa dks mudk yMdk luru tqa, esa gkj x;k A bl ij ?kj ij coky gqvk gksxk nwljh txg ‘kknh r; djus ds ckn nnnw dkuiqj vk;s vkSj eq>s lkjh ckr crk;s rks mudh lgk;rk o ruko dks ns[krs gq, eSaus 20]000@&:i;s Hkh fn, Fks A ‘kknh djds tc dkuiqj okil vk;ss Fks rks rks og cgqr Vsa’ku esa jgus yxs FksA iz’u &o”kZ 2001 esa eFkqjk fM;wVh esa ls xSj gkftj Fks rks fdrus fnuksa rd vkils ugha feys \ vkSj okil vk;s Fks rks D;k crk;s Fks\ mRrj & tc eFkqjk fM;wVh x;s Fks rc ‘kk;n Qtyxat esa gh rSukr Fks tc dkQh fnuksa rd okil ugha vk;s Fks rks vR;ar djhch lEcaèk gksus ds ukrs eSaus [kkst [kcj ysuh ‘kq: dh vkSj Fkkuk Qtyxat x;k rks lHkh flikfg;ksa us crk;k fd nnnw ?kj x;s vkils ugha feys \ vkSj okil vk;s Fks rks D;k crk;s Fks\ mRrj & tc eFkqjk fM;wVh x;s Fks rc ‘kk;n Qtyxat esa gh rSukr Fks tc dkQh fnuksa rd okil ugha vk;s Fks rks vR;ar djhch lEcaèk gksus ds ukrs eSaus [kkst [kcj ysuh ‘kq: dh vkSj Fkkuk Qtyxat x;k rks lHkh flikfg;ksa us crk;k fd nnnw ?kj x;s Fks vkSj ogha mudh e‘R;q gks x;h rks ,d ckj rks eq>s fo’okl ugha gqvk ijUrq dbZ yksxksa ds dgus ij eSa fo’okl dj fy;k FkkA djhc <kbZ o”kZ rd xk;c jgk FkkA mlds ckn vpkud ,d fnu lqcg lkr cts esjs ?kj vk x;s rks eSus lkjk gkypky iwNk FkkA bl <kbZ o”kZ ds e/; esjs lkeus dHkh ugha vk;s FksA iz’u& yMdh dh ‘kknh ls iwoZ mudk yMdk luru dkuiqj vkids ikl vk;k Fkk mlds ckn ldynhi dks ryk’k djus mlds ifjokj okys dc vk;s Fks\ mRrj& o”kZ 2004 esa xk;c gks tkus ds ckn nnnw dks ryk’kus mudk yMdk luru flag o”kZ 2007 esa igyh ckj esjs ikl vk;k FkkA mlds ckn ;g igys esjs ikl dHkh ugha vk;k FkkA igyh ckj iSls ysus vk;k Fkk vkSj nwljh ckj o”kZ 2007 esa ryk’kus vk;k FkkA iz’u& vkt fnukad 12&7&2010 dks vkidks o”kZ 2004 ls vc rd dkuiqj uxj dh ykokfj’k yk’kksa dh QksVks lh0Mh0 ds tfj, fn[kk;k x;k buesa dksbZ QksVks ldynhi flag dh ;k mlls feyrh tqyrh gS\ mRrj& vkius tks QksVksxzkQ eq>s fn[kk;k gS buesa ldynhi flag dh dksbZ QksVks ugha gSA 20& c;ku Jherh vfurk iRuh jkepUnz fuoklh jktdh; mUu;u cLrh fcBwj jksM dkyksuh ih0 ,l0 dY;kuiqj tuin dkuiqj uxj mez djhc 42 o”kZ%& c;ku fd;k fd eSaus ldynhi flag flikgh dks vPNh rjg tkurh igpkurh gwaA tc og bUnzkuxj pkSdh Fkkuk dY;kuiqj esa rSukr Fkk rks gekjs eqgYys esa vkrk FkkA vDlj gekjh eqykdkr gks tkrh FkhA /khjs /khjs gekjk lEca/k mlls gks x;k FkkA esjs ikl tc vkrk Fkk rks og cMs vPNs ls jgrk Fkk vkSj tc eqgYys esa tkrk Fkk rks ‘kjkc ihdj csdkj gks tkrk FkkA og ‘kjkc ihus dk vknh Fkh] igys ls gh cgqr ‘kjkc ihrk Fkk vkSj dbZ dbZ fnuksa rd fM;wVh ij ugha tkrk Fkk] ‘kjkc ihdj iMk jgrk FkkA dbZ ckj rks mlus vius onhZ vkSj twrs rd csp nsrk FkkA tc v.Mjoh;j cfu;ku igudj u’ks esa lMd ij dgha iMk gksrk Fkk rks yksx eq>ls dgrs Fks fd rqEgkjk ldynhi ogak ij iMk dk vknh Fkh] igys ls gh cgqr ‘kjkc ihrk Fkk vkSj dbZ dbZ fnuksa rd fM;wVh ij ugha tkrk Fkk] ‘kjkc ihdj iMk jgrk FkkA dbZ ckj rks mlus vius onhZ vkSj twrs rd csp nsrk FkkA tc v.Mjoh;j cfu;ku igudj u’ks esa lMd ij dgha iMk gksrk Fkk rks yksx eq>ls dgrs Fks fd rqEgkjk ldynhi ogak ij iMk gS rks eSa tkdj mlls VSEiksa es cSBkdj Hkst nsrh FkhA tc fcuk u’kk ds nqckjk vkrk Fkk rks eSa iwNrh Fkh rks dqN ugha cksyrk Fkk tc rd bUnzkuxj esa Fkk rks gj nwljs jkst ;k jkst gh esjs ikl vk tkrk Fkk vkSj ?kj esa gh lEca/k cuk ysrk Fkk vkSj pyk tkrk FkkA ml le; lHkh tkurs Fks vkSj eSa Hkh [kqys vke mldh cudj jgrh FkhA tc Qtyxat esa Fkk rks og eq>s cqyk;k Fkk vkSj eS Qtyxt x;h Hkh mlds vykok tc Hkh vkrk Fkk ?kj ij gh vkrk FkkA Qtyxat ds ckn rks og cgqr de vk;k gSA eS lqurh Fkh fd iqfyl ykbu esa vkt feyk Fkk eqyfte <ks jgk FkkA ‘kjkc bl dnj ihrk Fkk fd dbZ ckj Hkh[k ekaxrs ns[kk x;k Fkk ,d ckj iqfyl ykbu ds lkeus Hkh[k ekax jgk Fkk ftldh [kcj v[ckj esa fudyh Fkh rks yksxks us eq>ls crk;k FkkA ;gka Hkh vkl&ikl dbZ ckj Hkh[k ekaxrs ns[kk x;k Fkk D;ksafd tc onhZ twrs csp nsrk Fkk iSlk ugha gksrk Fkk vkSj ihus ds fy, bUnzkuxj jksM ij iSls ekax ysrk Fkk rks 10&20 ik tkrk Fkk rks cLrh esa vkdj nk: ih tkrk FkkA iqfyl ykbu esa eS Fkk rks esjs ikl vkuk can dj fn;k ,d ckj eSa chekj gks x;h Fkh rks gkyr vfèkd [kjkc gks tkus ds dkj.k 20 flrEcj 2004 dks eq>s esjs HkkbZ us rqylh vLirky esa HkrhZ djk;k vkSj ikap fnu HkrhZ jgh Fkh 25 rkjh[k dks fMLpktZ gksdj tc ?kj vk;h rks nwljs fnu ;k rhljs fnu 26 ;k 27 rkjh[k gks jgh gksxh ldynhi esjs ?kj vk;k onhZ igus Fkk vPNh lkQ lqFkjh vkSj ‘kjhj ls Hkh Bhd Bkd FkkA ?kj ij cSBk Fkk eSa pkjikbZ ij ysVh Fkh rks mlus dgk Fkk fd vUuks rqe rks fcBqj tkus dh rS;kjh dj jgh gks eSa dqN tokc ugha ns ik;h] FkksM+h nsj cSBk jgk vkSj esjh ek¡ ls ckrphr djrs jgs vkSj nok vkfn Bhd ls djkus o ns[kHkky djus dh dgdj pys x;s Fks vkSj mlds ckn Bkd FkkA ?kj ij cSBk Fkk eSa pkjikbZ ij ysVh Fkh rks mlus dgk Fkk fd vUuks rqe rks fcBqj tkus dh rS;kjh dj jgh gks eSa dqN tokc ugha ns ik;h] FkksM+h nsj cSBk jgk vkSj esjh ek¡ ls ckrphr djrs jgs vkSj nok vkfn Bhd ls djkus o ns[kHkky djus dh dgdj pys x;s Fks vkSj mlds ckn ls vktrd esjs ?kj ugha vk;sA irk ugha esjh chekjh lqudj vk;k Fkk ;k vpkud vk x;k Fkk] bldh dksbZ ppkZ ugha fd;k Fkk tc bunzkuxj esa Fkk rks mldk yM+dk luru vkrk Fkk vkSj osru ysdj pyk tkrk Fkk mldh chch Hkh dHkh&dHkh vkrh Fkh vkSj iSlk ysdj os yksx Hkh pys tkrs Fks og ifjokj dks xkyh xykSt djrk FkkA ?kj cgqr de tkrk Fkk 5&6 lky gks x;s esjs il vc ugha vkrk gSA tks cksyk ogha fy[kk i<+dj lqudj gLrk{kj cukrh gw¡A 21& c;ku Jherh ‘;kek nsoh iRuh Jh f’koujk;u Hkkrw fuoklh jktdh; mUu;u cLrh fcBqj jksM U;w dkyksuh Fkkuk dY;kuiqj dkuiqj uxj mez djhc 40 o”kZ%& c;ku fd;k fd esjh “kknh o”kZ 1984 esa gqbZ FkhA ‘kknh ds dqN lky ckn eSaus ldynhi flag flikgh dks ns[kk FkkA og gekjh cLrh esa vkrk Fkk vkSj ‘kjkc ihdj cLrh esa ?kwerk jgrk FkkA mlds cLrh dk cPpk cPpk tkurk Fkk A lHkh mls nnnw dgrs Fks mldk O;ogkj cgqr vPNk Fkk cLrh dk dksbZ vkneh Fkkus esa idMk tkrk Fkk rks og cgqr enn djrk Fkk A fdlh dks dHkh ijs’kku ugha djrk Fkk dsoy ‘kjkc ihus ds ckn yksxks ls jksVh vkfn ekaxrk Fkk vkSj mldk O;ogkj vPNk gksus ds dkj.k dksbZ euk ugha djrk FkkA esjs ifjokj dh uun vuhrk ls mldk lEca/k Fkk vkSj mlds ?kj vf/kd jgrk Fkk] ckdh iwjh cLrh esa lHkh dks vPNh utj ls ns[krk FkkA fdlh vU; dks xyr fu;r ls ugha ns[krk Fkk oSls cjkcj gekjh cLrh esa vkrk Fkk ijUrq b/kj dqN o”kksZ ls ugha vk;kA tgka rd eq>s ;kn gS fd flrEcj 2004 es esjh lxh cgu ftldk uke vuhrk gS dk nsgkUr gqvk Fkk] mlds 5&6 fnu ckn esjh uun vuhrk chekj gks x;h vkSj gkyr xaHkhj gksus ds dkj.k rqylh vLirky esa HkrhZ djk;k x;k Fkk 5 fnu ckn vuhrk fMLpktZ gksdj ?kj vk;h Fkh] mlh ds vkl ikl o”kZ 2004 flrEcj esa gh ldynhi vk;k Fkk vuhrk ds ?kj x;k Fkk vkSj dqN gh nsj :dk Fkk onhZ igus Fkk] ‘kjhj ls mlds 5&6 fnu ckn esjh uun vuhrk chekj gks x;h vkSj gkyr xaHkhj gksus ds dkj.k rqylh vLirky esa HkrhZ djk;k x;k Fkk 5 fnu ckn vuhrk fMLpktZ gksdj ?kj vk;h Fkh] mlh ds vkl ikl o”kZ 2004 flrEcj esa gh ldynhi vk;k Fkk vuhrk ds ?kj x;k Fkk vkSj dqN gh nsj :dk Fkk onhZ igus Fkk] ‘kjhj ls Bhd Bkd Fkk vkSj ‘kjkc ugha fi, FkkA vuhrk ds ?kj ls fudyk vkSj pyk x;k Fkk mlds ckn ls eSaus ldynhi dks dHkh ugha ns[kk A ml vkf[kjh fnu og fcYdqy Qzs’k ewM esa Fkk A tks cksyk ogha fy[kkA i<+dj gLrk{kj cukrh gw¡A 3& iqfyl vLirky esa fpfdRld }kjk iqfyl ykbu dks izsf”kr lwpuk%& fnukad 12&2&2004 dks iqfyl ykbu vLirky }kjk izfrlkj fujh{kd iqfyl ykbu dks ;g lwpuk nh x;h fd vkj{kh ldynhi flag fnukad 11&3&2004 dks le; 5-00 cts fcuk fdlh lwpuk ds vuqifLFkr gSA fjiksVZ vko’;d dk;Zokgh gsrq izsf”kr gSA iqu% fnukad 15&2&2004 dks iqfyl ykbu vLirky }kjk izfrlkj fujh{kd] iqfyl ykbu dks ;g fyf[kr lwpuk nh x;h Fkh fd vkj{kh ldynhi flag fnukad 16&2&2004 dks vius pkjikbZ ls fcuk fdlh lwpuk ds vuqifLFkr gSA 4& iqfyl ykbu ds jkstukepkvke& iqfyl ykbu ds jkstukepkvke esa jiV uEcj 41 le; 13&10 cts fnukad 12&2&2004 dks vkj{kh ldynhi flag ds iqfyl ykbu ls fnukad 11&2&2004 le; 5 cts fcuk fdlh lwpuk ds vuqifLFkr ds lEca/k esa rLdjk vafdr fd;k gS rFkk ;g fVIi.kh dh x;h gS fd ckn okilh Li”Vhdj.k ysdj lEcfU/kr dks izsf”kr fd;k tk;sxkA fnukad 14&2&2004 dks jiV la[;k 54 le; 15&35 cts ij jkstukepkvke esa ;g vafdr gS fd vkj{kh ldynhi flag ftldh vuqifLFkr ds lEca/k esa fnukad 12&2&2004 dks jiV la[;k 41 le; 13&10 cts ij rLdjk vafdr fd;k x;k gS fd vkj{kh fnukad 12&2&2004 ds lka;dky 5 cts ls iqfyl ykbu vLirky ls vuqifLFkr py jgk gS og vkt fnukad 14&2&2004 dks iqfyl vLirky esa u’ks dh gkyr esa csM ij mifLFkr gS A izfrlkj fujh{kd }kjk vkdLekr iqfyl vLirky igqpus ij vkj{kh ldynhi flag ‘kjkc fi, gq, feyk ftl ij bl vkj{kh dks MkDVjh ijh{k.k djkus gsrq ;w0 ,p0 ,e0 vLirky Hkstk tkuk vafdr gSA MkDVjh ijh{k.k fjiksVZ e; udy jiV izfrlkj fujh{kd dks vko’;d dk;Zokgh gsrq izsf”kr dh x;hA iqu% iqfyl ykbu ds jkstukepk vke esa fnukad 15&2&2004 dks jiV uEcj 16 le; 9&10 cts ij vkj{kh ldynhi flag ds fnukad 14&2&2004 dks iqfyl vLirky ls le; 18 cts ls xSj dks MkDVjh ijh{k.k djkus gsrq ;w0 ,p0 ,e0 vLirky Hkstk tkuk vafdr gSA MkDVjh ijh{k.k fjiksVZ e; udy jiV izfrlkj fujh{kd dks vko’;d dk;Zokgh gsrq izsf”kr dh x;hA iqu% iqfyl ykbu ds jkstukepk vke esa fnukad 15&2&2004 dks jiV uEcj 16 le; 9&10 cts ij vkj{kh ldynhi flag ds fnukad 14&2&2004 dks iqfyl vLirky ls le; 18 cts ls xSj gkftj gksus ds lEca/k esa rLdjk jiV xSj gkftjh vafdr gSA 5& ;w0 ,p0 ,e0 vLirky] dkuiqj uxj dh esfMdy ijh{k.k fjiksVZ& bl fjiksVZ esa ;g vafdr gS fd vkj{kh uk0iq0 1846 ldynhi flag] mez 58 o”kZ] iq= jk/kkd‘‘.k flag] fuoklh fjtoZ iqfyl ykbu] Fkkuk dksrokyh dkuiqj uxj] fnukad 14&2&2004 dks le; 2&50 ih0 ,e0 ij eq[; vkj{kh ih½ 217 lh0 ih0 fo|klkxj ,oa vkj{kh 341 ,0 ih0 jmn~hnu }kjk esfMdy ijh{k.k gsrq yk;k x;kA esfMdy ijh{k.k dj fjiksVZ esa Mk0 Jh izdk’k flag }kjk ;g vafdr fd;k x;k gS fd The above person has consumed alcohol and is intoxicated at present time. 6& fnukad 16&2&2004 dks izfrlkj fujh{kd iqfyl ykbal }kjk dkuiqj uxj ds leLr Fkkuk izHkkjh@Fkkuk/;{kksa dks vkj0Vh0 lans’k & fnukad 16&2&2004 dks izfrlkj fujh{kd iqfyl ykbal dkuiqj uxj }kjk viuh vkj0Vh 0 lans’k la[;k vkj0 vkbZ@2004 fnukad 16&2&2004 }kjk vkj{kh ldynhi flag ds iqfyl ykbal vLirky ls fnfukad 15&2&2004 dks vuqifLFkr gksus ds lEca/k esa tuin ds lHkh Fkkuk izHkkjh@Fkkuk/;{kks dks lwpuk izsf”kr dh x;h rFkk muls ;g vuqjks/k fd;k x;k fd bl vkj{kh dks vius vius Fkkuk {ks=ksa es ryk’k djds iqfyl ykbal dks voxr djkus dk d”V djsa A bl vkj0Vh0 lans’k dh izfr iz/kku fyfid dks bl vk’k; ls Hksth x;h gS fd vkj{kh ds ewy fuokl ls Hkh tkudkjh@lwpuk izkIr djuk lqfuf’pr djsaA 7& nSfud tkxj.k lekpkji= esa fnukad 4 ekpZ 2004 dks Hkh[k ekax dj ‘kjkc ih jgk flikgh ‘khf”kZd ls izdkf’kr lekpkj& nSfud tkxj.k lekpkj i= ds dkuiqj laLdj.k esa fnukad 4 ekpZ] 2004 dks mi ‘kh”kZd ls Nih ,d [kcj ds lEca/k esa dqN lw=ksa }kjk voxr djk;s tkus ij mDr [kcj dh izekf.kr Nk;k izfr nSfud tkxj.k dk;Zky; dkuiqj uxj ls izkIr dh x;h bl lekpkj i= esa of.kZr ‘kh”kZd ds vUrxZr Nih [kcj esa vafdr gS fd iqfyl vLirky ,oa iqfyl ykbau esa ‘kjkc ihus ij dk;Zokgh gqbZ rks vkj{kh ldynhi flag iqfyl ykbu ds lkeus Hkh[k ekaxdj ‘kjkc ihus yxkA vkj0 vkbZ0 us euk fd;k rks cksyk tks dk;Zokgh djuh gS djrs jguk bldh fjiksVZ mUgksus mPpf/kdkfj;ksa dks Hksth gSA vkj0 vkbZ0 txnh’k flag ds vuqlkj mUgksaus ldynhi flag dks ‘kjki ihrs idMk vkSj MkDVjh ds fy, vLirky HkstkA MkDVjh es a’kjkc fudyus ij dk;Zokgh ds fy, fy[kkA blds ckn ldynhi flag xk;c gks x;k nks rhu fnu ckn irk pyk fd og iqfyl ykbal ds lkeus nqdkunkjks ls Hkh[k ekax dj ‘kjkc ih jgk gSA lEiknd nSfud tkxj.k dkuiqj uxj ls mDr [kcj ladfyr djus okys rRdkyhu laoknnkrk dk uke iw.kZ irk rFkk muls lEidZ gsrq eksckbZy uEcj Kkr djus ds fy, bl dk;Zky; ds i= la[;k ih0 ,0 lh0@ds0 ,l0 ,xksch& 21@2010@ 89112 fnukad 25 twu] 2010 ds ek/;e ls vuqjks/k fd;k x;kA nSfud tkxj.k lekpkji= dkuiqj ds i=la0 ‘kwU; fnukad 26&6&2010 ds }kjk ;g voxr djk;k x;k gS fd lanfHkr lekpkj fnukad 4 ekpZ 2004 dks nSfud tkxj.k dkuiqj laLdj.k esa izdkf’kr vo’; gqvk Fkk ijUrq 6 o”kZ ckn ;g tkudkjh ns ikuk fd mijksDr lekpkj fdlds }kjk ladfyr fd;k x;k Fkk vlEHko gS D;ksafd bruk iqjkuk ek/;e ls vuqjks/k fd;k x;kA nSfud tkxj.k lekpkji= dkuiqj ds i=la0 ‘kwU; fnukad 26&6&2010 ds }kjk ;g voxr djk;k x;k gS fd lanfHkr lekpkj fnukad 4 ekpZ 2004 dks nSfud tkxj.k dkuiqj laLdj.k esa izdkf’kr vo’; gqvk Fkk ijUrq 6 o”kZ ckn ;g tkudkjh ns ikuk fd mijksDr lekpkj fdlds }kjk ladfyr fd;k x;k Fkk vlEHko gS D;ksafd bruk iqjkuk fjdkMZ j[kikuk gekjs fy, lEHko ugha gSA 8& eq[; fpfdRlkf/kdkjh dkuiqj uxj ls iqfyl vLirky] iqfyl ykbau dkuiqj uxj esa rRle; fu;qDr jgs fpfdRld o LVkQ dh ;ksX;rk ,oa vLirky esa miyC/k lqfo/kkvksa dh tkudkjh lEca/kh i=& bl dk;Zky; ds i= la[;k ih0,lh@ds,l@,lhch&21@2010@8921 fnukad 22 twu] 2010 }kjk eq[; fpfdRlkfèkdkjh dkuiqj uxj ls fnukad 15&2&2004 ls xqelqnk vkj{kh ldynhi flag ds lEca/k esa tkap ds dze esa izdk’k esa vk;s vkjksiksa ds vyksd esa fuEufyf[kr 2 fcUnqvksa ij vk[;k izsf”kr djus dk vuqjks/k fd;k x;k& 1& D;k dkuiqj iqfyl ykbau vLirky esa miyC/k lqfo/kk bl Lrj dh gS fd blesa ekuo vaxks ;Fkk vka[k] xqnkZ] fdMuh tSls egRoiw.kZ vax fudky dj lqjf{kr j[kk tk ldsA rkfd mldk mi;ksx vU;= fd;k tk ldsA 2& D;k iqfyl ykbu dkuiqj esa rRle; fu;qfDRk fpfdRld ,oa lgorhZ dehZ bl rjg ds vkijs’ku djus ds fy, izf’kf{kr FksA eq[; fpfdRlkf/kdkjh dkuiqj uxj ds i= la[;k eq0fp0 v0 @ds,l@,lhch&21 @2010@4153 fnukad 24 twu] 2010 }kjk ;g voxr djk;k x;k fd iqfyl vLirky iqfyl ykbu dkuiqj uxj esa vkijs’ku d{k dh lqfoèkk miyC/k ugha gS rRle; Mk0 vkuUn oekZ iqfyl fpfdRlky; dkuiqj uxj esa fpfdRlk v/kh{kd ds in ij dk;Zjr Fks ftudh ‘kSf{kd ;ksX;rk ek= ,e0ch0ch0,l Fkh buds ikl fdlh izdkj dh fo’ks”k ;ksX;rk ugha FkhA 9& Jherh rkjkerh nsoh ,oa Jh lUru dqekj dks xqe’kqnk vkj{kh ldynhi flag dk QksVksxzkQ miyC/k djkus rFkk vkj{kh dk lkeu igpkuus@izkIr gsrq izfrlkj fujh{kd dkuiqj ls lEidZ gsrq i=& bl dk;Zky; ds pkj fofHkUu i=ksa la[;k ih,lh@ds,l@lh,0 &21 @2010 @@8926 8927]8928 ,oa 8929 fnukad 22 twu 2010 }kjk dze’k% Jherh rkjkorh nsoh iRuh Jh ldynhi flag ,oa Jh lUru dqekj iq= Jh ldynhi flag dks vkj{kh ldynhi flag ds iSr‘d xkao fi;jkSVk tuin cfy;k ,oa orZeku irk xzke efugkjh ftyk dfVgkj fcgkj ij Hkstdj ;g vuqjks/k fd;k x;k fd fnukad 6&6&2010 dks tuin cfy;k mRrj izns’k ds irs ij esjs }kjk vkids c;ku vfHkfyf[kr djk;s FksA esjs }kjk rRle; Hkh ;g vuqjks/k fd;k x;k Fkk fd ;fn ldynhi flag dk dksbZ QksVks miyCèk gks rks mldh izfr eq>s miyC/k djk xkao fi;jkSVk tuin cfy;k ,oa orZeku irk xzke efugkjh ftyk dfVgkj fcgkj ij Hkstdj ;g vuqjks/k fd;k x;k fd fnukad 6&6&2010 dks tuin cfy;k mRrj izns’k ds irs ij esjs }kjk vkids c;ku vfHkfyf[kr djk;s FksA esjs }kjk rRle; Hkh ;g vuqjks/k fd;k x;k Fkk fd ;fn ldynhi flag dk dksbZ QksVks miyCèk gks rks mldh izfr eq>s miyC/k djk ns rkfd bldk izdk’ku O;kid :Ik ls djkdj Jh ldynhi flag dh [kkst dh tk lds ijUrq vki }kjk Jh ldynhi flag dk dksbZ QksVks xzkQ RkRle; miyCèk ugha gksuk crk;k x;k Fkk bu fuxZr i=ksa ds ek/;e ls Jherh rkjkerh nsoh ,oa muds iq= Jh lUru dqekj ls vkj{kh ldynhi flag dk QksVks miyC/k djkus dk iqu% vuqjks/k fd;k x;kA blds vfrfjDr fuxZr i=ksa esa mUgsa ;g Hkh voxr djk;k x;k fd iqfyl ykbu dkuiqj uxj esa vusd vkjf{k;ksa dk leku tSls ckDl pkjikbZ bR;kfn j[kk gqvk gSA ;g leku mu vkjf{k;ksa dk tks yEcs le; ls xSj gkftj gS vFkok ftUgksus yEcs ls viuk leku cSjdks esa ;wa gh NksM j[kk gSA vki leku dh f’kuk[r gsrq ‘kh?kz izfrlkj fujh{kd dkuiqj ls lEidZ dj bu lekuksa es ls vkj{kh Jh ldynhi flag dk leku igpkudj mls izkIr djsaA ;g Hkh vuqjks/k fd;k x;k gS fd lEHko gS fd miyC/k leku esa vkj{kh ldynhi flag dk QksVks xzkQ gks dks v/kksgLrk{kjh dks miyC/k djkus dk d”V djsaA bl i= dh izfr iqfyl egk mi fujh{kd@ofj”B iqfyl v/kh{kd dkuiqj uxj dks bl vk’k; ls i‘‘Bkafdr dh x;h fd ;g izdj.k esa izfrlkj fujh{kd dks vius Lrj ls funsZf’kr djsa rkfd xqe’kqnk vkj{kh ldynhi flag ds ifjokj okyksa }kjk leku igpku djus esa dksbZ dfBukbZ u gksA Jherh rkjkerh nsoh }kjk xzke efugkjh ftyk dfVgkj fcgkj ds irs ij bl dk;Zky; ds mijksDr fuxZr i= la[;k ih,lh@ds,l@,lhch&21 @2010@8927 ,oa 8929 fnukad 22&6&2010 izkIr dj ikorh ij vius gLrk{kj cuk;s x;s blds vfrfjDr vU; nks i= rkehydrkZ fo’ks”kokgd ds }kjk vkj{kh ldynhi flag ds iS=‘d xkao fi;jkSVk tuin cfy;k dss irs ij tkus ij Jh jketh dqaoj xzke fi;jkSVk cfy;k }kjk fnukad 26&6&10 dks fyf[kr rgjhj nh x;h gS fd vkj{kh Hk‘xqukFk ;kno 37oh okfguh ih,lh dkuiqj uxj ls xzke fi;jkSVk Fkkuk jsmrh cfy;k vk;sA Jh lUru dqekj flag iq= ldynhi flag o Jherh rkjkerh nsoh iRuh ldynhi flag fuoklh fi;jkSVk Fkkuk jsorh cfy;k bl le; ?kj ij ekStwn ugha gSA fcgkj izkar ds tuin dfVgkj xzke efugkjh esa gSA Jherh rkjkerh 26&6&10 dks fyf[kr rgjhj nh x;h gS fd vkj{kh Hk‘xqukFk ;kno 37oh okfguh ih,lh dkuiqj uxj ls xzke fi;jkSVk Fkkuk jsmrh cfy;k vk;sA Jh lUru dqekj flag iq= ldynhi flag o Jherh rkjkerh nsoh iRuh ldynhi flag fuoklh fi;jkSVk Fkkuk jsorh cfy;k bl le; ?kj ij ekStwn ugha gSA fcgkj izkar ds tuin dfVgkj xzke efugkjh esa gSA Jherh rkjkerh nsoh ,oa Jh lUru dqekj flag ds uke ls fuxZr i= fnukafdr 22&6&10 ewy :i esa okgd }kjk bl dk;Zky; esa okil fd;k x;kA ——————————————————— 33& HkwriwoZ vkj{kh 1843 uk0 iq0 ldynhi flag dh pfj= iaftdk%& fnukad 6&6&1965 dks Jh ldynhi flag iq= Jh jk/kk d‘‘.k xzke fi;jkSVk] ftyk cfy;k dks vkj{kh ds in ij tuin vktex< esa HkrhZ fd;k x;k FkkA lsok vfHkys[kksa ds vuqlkj] budh tUefrfFk 10&10&1986 ,oa ‘kSf{kd ;ksX;rk gkbZ Ldwy gSA bl vkj{kh dh pfj= iakftdk esa okf”kZd xksiuh; eUrC; ,oa bUgsa lsok ds nkSjku iznRr n.M dk fooj.k fuEuor gS& okf”kZd xksiuh; eUrC;%& o”kZ 1984 esa ,d {kqnz n.M feyk fo’oluh; lw=ksa ls Kkr gqvk fd vlekftd rFoksa ls lkaBxkaB j[krk gSA fuxjkuh j[kus dh vko’;Drk gSA dk;Z ,oa vkpj.k larks”ktud lR; fu”Bk izekf.krA o”kZ 1985 ‘kjkc ihus ,oa nqO;Zogkj dh f’kdk;rsA fuxjkuh dh vko’;drk A dk;Z ,oa vkpj.k larks”ktud lR;fu”Bk izekf.krA o”kZ 1986& 1987 o vU; dbZ o”kksZ esa dk;Z ,oa vkpj.k larks”ktud vafdr gS o”kZ 1993 esa fM;wVh ls vuqifLFkr jgus rFkk dk;Z esa :fp ugh ysus ds rF; vafdr gS dk;Z ,oa vkpj.k larks”ktud lR; fu”Bk izekf.krA 1999 vkj{kh xSj gkftj gksus dk vknh gS1 dk;Z ,oa vkpj.k larks”ktud lR;fu”Bk izekf.krA o‘gn n.M dqy nks 1& vkns’k la[;k ih,Q 24@83 fnukad 17&9&83 fnukad 22&1&83 dks pkSdh thvkjih jkeckx esa rSukrh ds nkSjku eq[; vkj{kh dqanu ds lkFk nqO;Zogkj ,oa xkyh xykSt fd;s tkus ds mijkUr lEiUu foHkkxh; dk;Zokgh ds mijkUr orZeku osrueku ls 2 o”kZ ds fy, LVst 2 osru o‘f} ij izR;kofrZr fd;k x;kA 2& vkns’k la[;k ih,Q 20@2003 fnukad 12&7&2004 fnukad 5&9& 2001 ls 11 &11&2003 rd dqy 818 fnol fcuk vodk’k ,oa vuqefr ds vukfèkd‘r :Ik ls vuqifLFkr jgus ds dkj.k foHkkxh; dk;Zokgh ds i’pkr vkjksi izekf.kr gksus ij lsok ls in;qr fM’kfel fd;k x;kA y?kqn.M dqy pkj& 1& vkns’k la[;k na0 1215@98 fnukad 30&1&99 fnukad 19&6&98 ls 44 fnol vuqifLFkr jgus ds vkjksi esa ifjfuUnk dk n.M iznku fd;kA 2& vkns’k la[;k n.M 611@99 fnukad 21&2&2000 fnukad 7&3&1998 ls ikap fnol 4&12&98 ls 111 fnol fnukad 4&4&98 ls ds dkj.k foHkkxh; dk;Zokgh ds i’pkr vkjksi izekf.kr gksus ij lsok ls in;qr fM’kfel fd;k x;kA y?kqn.M dqy pkj& 1& vkns’k la[;k na0 1215@98 fnukad 30&1&99 fnukad 19&6&98 ls 44 fnol vuqifLFkr jgus ds vkjksi esa ifjfuUnk dk n.M iznku fd;kA 2& vkns’k la[;k n.M 611@99 fnukad 21&2&2000 fnukad 7&3&1998 ls ikap fnol 4&12&98 ls 111 fnol fnukad 4&4&98 ls 11 ,oa fnukad 2&5&99 ls 13 fnol dqy 140 fnol vukfèkd‘r :i ls vuqifLFkr jgus ij nks”kh ikrs gq, ifjfuUnk ds n.M ls nf.Mr fd;k x;kA 3& vkns’k la[;k n0&50@97 fnukad 5&5&97 fnukad 1&7&96 ls 9 fnol vukf/kd‘r :i ls vuqifLFkr jgus ds dkj.k ifjfuUnk dk n.M iznku fd;k x;kA 4& vkns’k la[;k &n&1210@93 fnukad 6&1&2005 fnukad 5&993 ls 9 fnol vukf/kd‘r :i ls vuqifLFkr jgus ds vkjksi esa ifjfuUnk dk n.M iznku fd;k x;kA {kqnz n.M&dqy 23& dqy &15 {kqnz n.M vukf/kd‘r :i ls vuqifLFkr jgus ds vkjksi esa nf.Mr fd;k x;kA dqy 03 {kqnz n.M fM;wVh ds nkSjku jksrs gq, ik;s tkus ds dkj.k vkjksi esa nf.Mr fd;k x;kA dqy&01 Nqnz n.M&fMwVh ij pksjh djus ds vkjksi esa nf.Mr fd;k x;kA dqy 01 Nqnz n.M& fu/kkZfjr onhZ u /kkj.k djus ds vkjksi esa nf.Mr fd;k x;kA dqy 01 Nqnz n.M fM;wVh ij ‘kjkc dk lsou djus ds vkjksi esa nf.Mr fd;k x;kA dqy 01 Nqnz n.M &lgdehZksa ds lkFk nqO;Zogkj djus ds vkjksi esa nf.Mr fd;k x;kA dqy 01 Nqnz n.M &pk ds Bsys okys dks iSlk u nsus o ekaxus ij nQk 34 esa pyku djus dh /kedh nsus ds vkjksi esa nf.Mr fd;k x;kA fuyacu 1& vkns’k la[;k ua0&44@98 fnukad 2&5&98 }kjk fnukad 7&5&98 ls uxj fu;a=.k d{k ls fcuk vuqefr@vodk’k ds vukf/kd‘r :i ls vuqikfLFkr jgus ds vkjksi esa fuyfEcr fd;k x;kA vkns’k la[;k ua0&4498@n&1215@98 fnukad 1&8&98 }kjk rkRdkfyd izHkko ls cgky fd;k x;k A fuyEcu vof/k ds vo’ks”k osru ,oa HkRrksa ds lEca/k esa vkns’k foHkkxh; dk;Zokgh ds iw.kZ fuLrkj.k ds i’pkr fd;s tk;sxsaA 2& vkns’k la[;k ua-m &758@99 fnukad 12 Qjojh 1999 }kjk fnukad 4&12&98 ls vukf/kd‘re :i ls vuqifLFkr jgus ds vkjski esa fuyfEcr fd;kx;kA 3& vkns’k la[;k ua0&755@99 fnukad 21 tqykbZ] 1999 }kjk RkkRdkfyd izHkko ls izpfyr foHkkxh; dk;Zokgh ij izfrdwy izHkko Mkys fcuk cgky fd;k x;kA izkjafHkd tkap es nks”kh ik;s tkus ij ifjfuUnk ys[k o fcuk osru vodk’k Lohd‘r fd;k x;kA fuyEc vof/k esa tks osru HkRrs vkfn ik pqds gS ogh ns; gS mlds vykok vU; dksbZ ns; esa fuyfEcr fd;kx;kA 3& vkns’k la[;k ua0&755@99 fnukad 21 tqykbZ] 1999 }kjk RkkRdkfyd izHkko ls izpfyr foHkkxh; dk;Zokgh ij izfrdwy izHkko Mkys fcuk cgky fd;k x;kA izkjafHkd tkap es nks”kh ik;s tkus ij ifjfuUnk ys[k o fcuk osru vodk’k Lohd‘r fd;k x;kA fuyEc vof/k esa tks osru HkRrs vkfn ik pqds gS ogh ns; gS mlds vykok vU; dksbZ ns; ugh gSA budh fuyEcu vof/k buds osru o‘f} izeks’ku vodk’k esa ‘kqekj dh tk;sxhA 4& mRrj izns’k ds leLr iqfyl mi egfujh{kd@ofj”B iqfyl ofj”B iqfyl vèkh{kd@iqfyl v/kh{kd@izHkkjh tuin dks QSDl }kjk vkj{kh dh xqe’kqnxh ds lEca/k esa lwpuk& bl dk;kZy; ds i= la[;k ih,lh@ds,l@,lhch &21@2010@8767 fnukad 14 twu] 2010 }kjk izns’k ds leLr iqfyl mi&egkfujh{kd@ofj”B iqfyl vèkh{kd@iqfyl v/kh{kd@izHkkjh tuin dks QSDl ds }kjk vkj{kh ldynhi flag iq= jkèkkd‘‘.k ds fnukad 15&2&2004 ls iqfyl vLirky dkuiqj uxj ls xqe’kqnk gksus dh lwpuk nh xbZA bl lEca/k esa mUgs vkj{kh dk gqfy;k izsf”kr fd;k x;k rFkk muls vis{kk dh x;h fd bl vkj{kh ds lEca/k esa vius vf/kdkj {ks= ds Fkkuks ls tkudkjh dj ys fd fnukad 15&2&2004 ds i’pkr 01 ekg ds chp dksbZ ykokfj’k yk’k muds vfèkdkj {ks= esa rks ugha ik;h x;h gS ;fn fdlh Fkkuk {ks+= esa ,slh dksbZ ykokfj’k yk’k ik;h x;h gS ftlds lEca/k esa ;g lEHkkouk gks fd og ykokfj’k yk’k xqe gq, HkwriwoZ vkj{kh ldynhi flag dh gks ldrh gSrks d‘i;k vèkksgLrk{kjh dks 15 fnol ds vanj lwfpr djus dk d”V djsaA bl lwpuk ds vkyksd esa vc rd fofHkUu tuinks ls izkIr lHkh lwpuk;sa ‘kwU; gSA fdlh tuin }kjk vkj{kh ldynhi flag ds lEca/k esa dksbZ tkudkjh ugha nh x;h gSA 5& tuin dkuiqj uxj esa Qjojh 2004 ls vc rd ik;s x;s ykokfj’k yk’kksa ds QksVksxzkQ izkIr dj igpku djkuk& bl dk;kZy; ds i= la[;k ih,lh@ds,l@,lhch &21@2010@8801 fnukad 16 twu 2010 }kjk iqfyl mi egkfujh{kd@ofj”B iqfyl v/kh{kd] dkuiqj uxj ls Qjojh 2004 ls vc rd ik;s x;s ykokfj’k yk’kksa ds QksVksxzkQ miyC/k djk;s tkus dk vuqjks/k fd;k x;kA iqfyl mi egkfujh{kd@ofj”B iqfyl vèkh{kd] dkuiqj uxj ds i= la[;k ,l0Vh0 &vkj 295@MhvkbZth& ,l,lih fnukad 11&7&2010 }kjk Qjojh 2004 ls tkap dh frfFk rd ykokfj’k yk’kks dh QksVks dh lhMh v/kksgLrk{kjh dks miyC/k djk;h x;hA tuin dkuiqj uxj ds izHkkjh QhYM ;wfuV }kjk fy, x;s bu ykokfj’k yk’kks ads QksVks xzkQ dks vkj{kh ldynhi ds utnhdh jgs Jh n;k uan jk;] Jh lqcks/k xqIrk rFkk vkj{kh ldynhi flag ds lkFk fu;qDr jgs izHkkjh pkSdh fnukad 11&7&2010 }kjk Qjojh 2004 ls tkap dh frfFk rd ykokfj’k yk’kks dh QksVks dh lhMh v/kksgLrk{kjh dks miyC/k djk;h x;hA tuin dkuiqj uxj ds izHkkjh QhYM ;wfuV }kjk fy, x;s bu ykokfj’k yk’kks ads QksVks xzkQ dks vkj{kh ldynhi ds utnhdh jgs Jh n;k uan jk;] Jh lqcks/k xqIrk rFkk vkj{kh ldynhi flag ds lkFk fu;qDr jgs izHkkjh pkSdh Jh ds0 ,u0 HkV~V ,oa vU; iqfyl dfeZ;ksa tks vkj{kh ldynhi flag dks igpkurs Fks dks fn[kk;k x;kA fdlh ds }kjk ykokfj’k yk’kks ds QksVks dh igpku vkj{kh ldynhi flag ds :i esa ugh dh x;hA fu”d”kZ& tkap ds e/; fyfic} fd;s x;s ekSf[kd lk{;ksa ,oa ,d= fd;s x;s vfHkys[kh; lk{;ksa dh leh{kk ls ;g Li”V gS fd bl izdj.k esa vkj{kh ldynhi flag dh xqe’kqnxh ds lEca/k esa buds ifjokjh tuks }kjk yxk;s x;s leLr vkjksi fujk/kkj ,oa vizekf.kr gSA izdj.k esa ;g vo’; ik;k tkrk gS fd vkj{kh ladynhi flag ekg flrEcj 2004 ds var ls vius fdlh utnhdh ls ugha feyk gS u gh mldks fdlh ds }kjk ns[kk x;k gSA vkj{kh dh e‘R;q vFkok thfor gksus dk Hkh dksbZ izek.k tkap ds e/; ugha feyk gSA vkj{kh ldynhi ds ifjtuks }kjk vkj{kh dh xqe’kqnxh ds lEca/k esa vkj{kh dh gR;k iqfyl ykbu ds vanj mldh fdMuh ,oa vkar O;kikj gSA fudkyus rFkk mlds leku ds ykyp esa dj fn, tkus tSls xEHkhj vkjksi yxk;s x;s gSA mYys[kuh; gS fd vkj{kh ds fnukad 15&2&2004 ls iqfyl ykbu ls xk;c gksus ds rhu o”kZ ds ckn o”kZ 2007 vizSy esa mudh iRuh Jherh rkjkerh nsoh }kjk ekuuh; eq[; ea=h m0 iz0 ‘kklu y[kum dks lEcksf/kr izkFkZuki= esa Hkh bl izdkj ds xEHkhj vkjksi ugh yxk;s x;s FksA Li”V :i ls vkj{kh ds lkFk fdlh izdkj ds ?kVuk gksus dh dksbZ va’kdk ifjtuks dks ugh FkhA vkj{kh ds ifjtuks }kjk rRle; vius izkFkZuki= }kjk eq[; :i ls vkj{h dks <wa<us vkj{kh ds inP;qr fd;s tkus ds vkns’k dks fujLr fd;s tkus ifjokj dks isa’ku ,oa vU; ns;dks dk Hkqxrku djus rFkk vkj{kh ds iq= lUru dqekj flag dks iqfyl foHkkx esa ukSdjh fn, tkus dh ekax dh x;hA dkykUrj esa o”kksZ ckn vkj{kh ds ifjtuksa }kjk ekuuh; U;k;ky;ksa esa nk;j fofHkUu fjV ;kfpdkvksa rFkk vius ÁkFkZuki=ksa ds ek/;e ls vkj{kh ds eqe’kqnxh ds lEca/k esa iqfyl vLirky dkuiqj uxj ds MkDVj ,oa LVkQ ,oa iqfyl foHkkx ds vfèkdkjhx.k fofHkUu xEHkhj vkjksi yxk;s tkus yxsA xkao ls ;g lHkh vkjksi foHkkx esa ukSdjh fn, tkus dh ekax dh x;hA dkykUrj esa o”kksZ ckn vkj{kh ds ifjtuksa }kjk ekuuh; U;k;ky;ksa esa nk;j fofHkUu fjV ;kfpdkvksa rFkk vius ÁkFkZuki=ksa ds ek/;e ls vkj{kh ds eqe’kqnxh ds lEca/k esa iqfyl vLirky dkuiqj uxj ds MkDVj ,oa LVkQ ,oa iqfyl foHkkx ds vfèkdkjhx.k fofHkUu xEHkhj vkjksi yxk;s tkus yxsA xkao ls ;g lHkh vkjksi Áekf.kr ugha ik;s tkrs gSaA Li”Vr% ;s lHkh vkjksi vcks/k vkQVj FkkV gS] ftldk mn~ns’; iqfyl foHkkx ij ncko cukrk gSA ;gka ;g Hkh mYys[kuh; gS fd iqfyl ykbu fLFkfr iqfyl vLirky ls vkj{kh ldynhi flag ds fnukad 15&2&2004 dks xk;c gksus ds iwoZ Hkh vkj{kh yEch yEch vofèk rd vukf/kd‘r :i ls vuqifLFkr@xk;c jgrk FkkA viuh iwjh lsok vof/k esa ;g vkj{kh dqy 20 ckj blh izdkj ls vius rSukrh LFky ls yEch vokf/k;ksa ds fy, xk;c jgk gSA o”kZ 2001 esa Hkh vkj{kh ldynhi flag }kjk Jh d‘‘.k tUeksRlo fM;wVh tuin eFkqjk ls fnukad 16&8&2001 ls 818 fnol vukf/kd‘r :i ls vuqikfLFkr jgdj fnukad 11&11&2008 dks viuh okilh iqfyl ykbu esa djk;h Fkh blds rqjUr ckn ;g vkj{kh iqfyl vLirky esa bykt ds fy, HkrhZ gqvk vkSj iqu% fnukad 15&2&2004 dks xk;c gks x;kA mYys[kuh; gS fd Jhd‘‘.k tUeksRlo fM;wVh tuin eFkqjk ls 818 fnol vukf/kd‘r :i ls xk;c gksus ds nkSjku Hkh rRle; vkj{kh ldynhi flag ds thfor jgus ds ckotwn vkj{kh ds iq= Jh laru dqekj flag }kjk vkj{kh ds fo:} vukf/kd‘r :i ls vuqifLFkr jgus ds lEca/k esa izpfyr foHkkxh; dk;Zokgh ds nkSjku ihBklhu vf/kdkjh dks i= Hkstdj ;g ekax dh x;h Fkh fd lEHkor% muds firk ds lkFk dksbZ gknlk gks x;k x;k gSA muds ifjokj dks isa’ku nh tk, ,oa mudks iqfyl foHkkx esa ukSdjh nh tk,A ihBklhu vfèkdkjh }kjk Jh lUru dqekj flag dk i= izkIr gksus ij vkj{kh ldynhi flag ds fo:} izpfyr foHkkxh; dk;Zokgh dks LFkfxr djus vkj{kh ds lEca/k esa tkudkjh djus ij ;g ik;k x;k fd vkj{kh ldynhi flag thfor gS QyLo:i muds }kjk foHkkxh; dk;Zokgh iqu% izkjEHk dh x;hA vkj{kh ldynhi flag foHkkxh; dk;Zokgh ds nkSjku ihBklhu vf/kdkjh dks fn, x;s Li”Vhdj.k esa ;g vafdr fd;k x;k fd og dkuiqj uxj esa gh Fkk vkSj viuk bykt ,y,yvkj vLirky dkuiqj uxj esa okg; jksxh ds :i esa djk jgk FkkA Li”V :i ls bu rF;ksa ls ;g izekf.kr gksrk gS fd ;k rks vkj{kh dks vius ifjokj ds lEca/k lekU; ugha Fkk mlds }kjk vius chekjh dh vf/kdkjh dks fn, x;s Li”Vhdj.k esa ;g vafdr fd;k x;k fd og dkuiqj uxj esa gh Fkk vkSj viuk bykt ,y,yvkj vLirky dkuiqj uxj esa okg; jksxh ds :i esa djk jgk FkkA Li”V :i ls bu rF;ksa ls ;g izekf.kr gksrk gS fd ;k rks vkj{kh dks vius ifjokj ds lEca/k lekU; ugha Fkk mlds }kjk vius chekjh dh lwpuk ,oa vius irs rd dh tkudkjh vius ifjokjksa dks nsuk mfpr ugha le>k x;k vkSj ifjokjtuksa }kjk Hkh muds dq’kyrk ds lEca/k esa tkudkjh djus dk dksbZ iz;kl ugha fd;k x;k vFkok vkj{kh ds iq= Jh lUru dqekj flag }kjk firk ds lEca/k esa xyr lwpuk nsdj iqfyl foHkkx esa e‘rd vkfJr ds :i esa ukSdjh izkIr djus dk iz;kl fd;k tk jgk FkkA orZeku izdj.k esa tkap ls ;g fofnr gksrk gS fd vkj{kh ldynhi flag Hka;dj :i ls ‘kjkc ihus dk vknh Fkk vkSj ‘kjkc ihdj cgqèkk u’ks esa cslqn b/kj m/kj iMk jgrk Fkk lEHko gS fd blds lkFk dksbZ ?kVuk ‘kjkc ds u’ks esa gksus ds dkj.k gks x;h gks vFkok ;g LosPNk ls vius ifjokj ls nwj dgha jg jgk gks ,oa iwoZ dh Hkkafr viuk vrk irk ,oa viuh dq’kyrk bR;kfn dh lwpuk LosPNk ls vius ifjtuks dks ugha ns jgk gks A tkap ls nksuks gh frfFk;ksa ds lEca/k esa dksbZ Li”V ,oa izekf.kr tkudkjh ugh gks ldhA vkj{kh ds thfor vFkok e‘R;q gksus ds lEca/k esa fcuk fdlh Bksl lk{; ds orZeku esa dqN Hkh dguk lEHko ugha gSA tkap ds e/; vkj{kh ldynhi flag dks <wa<us dh leLr ;qfDr&;qDr Á;kl fd;s x;s ijUrq dksbZ lkFkZd ifj.kke lkeus ugha vk;kA vkj{kh dks <wa<us ds fy, ryk’k x’rh tuin dkuiqj uxj ds ekè;e ls fuxZr djk;h x;hA ftldh Áfrfyfi lhekorhZ tuinksa ,oa vU; egRoiw.kZ tuinksa tgka vkj{kh ds gksus dh lEHkkouk gks ldrh Fkh esa Hkh Hkstk x;k v/kksgLrk{kjh }kjk mŸkj Áns’k ds leLr iqfyl mi&egkfujh{kd@ofj”B iqfyl v/kh{kd@iqfyl v/kh{kd@ÁHkkjh tuin ds QSDl ds ek/;e ls vkj{kh ldynhi flag ds xqe’kqnk gksus ds lEca/k esa tkudkjh nh x;h rFkk vkj{kh ds feyus tqyus gqfy;k dh dksbZ ykokfj’k yk’k muds tuin esa ik;h x;h gks rks mlds lEca/k esa tkudkjh nsus dh vis{kk dh x;hA blds vfrfjDr tuin dkuiqj uxj esa o”kZ 2004 Qjojh ls vc rd ik;h x;h ykokfj’k yk’kksa ds QksVksxzkQ ds igpku vkj{kh ldynhi flag dks igpkuus okys O;fDr;ksa ls djk;h x;hA iqfyl v/kh{kd] jkT; vfHkys[k C;wjks mŸkj Áns’k y[kuÅ es gqfy;k dh dksbZ ykokfj’k yk’k muds tuin esa ik;h x;h gks rks mlds lEca/k esa tkudkjh nsus dh vis{kk dh x;hA blds vfrfjDr tuin dkuiqj uxj esa o”kZ 2004 Qjojh ls vc rd ik;h x;h ykokfj’k yk’kksa ds QksVksxzkQ ds igpku vkj{kh ldynhi flag dks igpkuus okys O;fDr;ksa ls djk;h x;hA iqfyl v/kh{kd] jkT; vfHkys[k C;wjks mŸkj Áns’k y[kuÅ es aekè;e ls vkj{kh dh xqe’kqnxh ds lEca/k esa lwpuk mŸkj Áns’k iqfyl dh csclkbM ij fnyok;h x;hA vkj{kh ldynhi flag dh xqe’kqnxh ds lEca/k esa b’rsgkj iksLVj tuin dkuiqj uxj ds leLr Fkkuksa ds lwpukiV ,oa Fkkuk {ks= ds egRoiw.kZ lkoZtfud LFkyksa ij yxok;s x;s ;g b’rsgkj iksLVj thvkih ,oa vkih,Q dkuiqj lsUVªy dks O;kid Ápkj Álkj gsrq Hksts x;s ;g b’rsgkj iksLVj tuin dkuiqj uxj ds Mhlhvkjch ds ek/;e ls vU; tuinksa dks Hkh O;kid Ápkj Álkj gsrq Hksts x;s vkdk’kok.kh ds ek/;e ls Hkh vkj{kh dh xqelqnxh ds lEca/k esa Áeq[kr% ls Álkj.k djk;k x;kA blds vfrfjDr vkj{kh dh xqelqnxh ds lEca/k esa lekpkj i= nSfud tkxj.k ds mŸkj Áns’k ds leLr laLdj.kksa ,oa vej mtkyk ds dkuiqj uxj ds laLrdj.k esa vkj{kh dhxqe’kqnxh dh lwpuk Ádkf’kr djk;h x;hA ;gka ;g Hkh mYys[kuh; gS fd vkj{kh dks <wa<us ds Øe esa vkj{kh ds ifjtuksa }kjk visf{kr lg;ksx ugha fn;k x;kA vkj{kh ds ifjtuksa ls ekSf[kd ,oa fyf[kr :i ls vuqjks/k fd;k x;k fd ;fn muds ikl vkj{kh dk QksVksxzkQ gks rks QksVksxzkQ dh ,d Áfr v/kksgLrk{kjh dks miyC/k djkus dk d”V djsa rkfd bldk lekpkj i=ksa ,oa nwjn’kZu ds ek/;e ls O;kikd Ápkj Álkj gsrq Álkj.k djk;k tk lds ijUrq vkj{kh ds ifjtuksa }kjk vkj{kh dk QksVksxzkQ v/kksgLrk{kjh dks miyC/k ugha djk;k x;kA ÁR;sd ckj ;g dgk x;k fd iqfyl foHkkx ds ikl tks QksVksxzkQ miyC/k gS mlh dk Á;ksx bu dk;Z gsrq djsaA tkap ds Øe esa ljdkjh vfHkys[kksa ,oa fofHkUu cSadksa ls Hkh vkj{kh ldynhi flag dk QksVksxzkQ ÁkIr djus dk Á;kl vlQy jgk QyLo:i vkj{kh dh xqelqnxh ds lEca/k esa Ádk’ku fcuk vkj{kh ds QksVksxzkQ ds ek= mldh gqfy;k ds vk/kkj ij djkuk iM+kA blds vfrfjDr vkj{kh ds xqe’kqnxh ds lEca/k esa b’rsgkj iksLVj Hkh vkj{kh ds QksVksxzkQ ds fcuk cuok;s x;sA QksVksxzkQ dh vuqmiyC/krk ds QyLo:i vkj{kh dh xqe’kqnxh ds lEca/k esa nwjn’kZu ds ek/;e ls Hkh lwpuk dk Álkj.k ugha djk;k tk ldkA mijksDr ifjfLFkfr ckotwn vkj{kh dks <wa<us gsrq tkap ds e/; v/kksgLrk{kjh ds Lrj ls lHkh lEHko Á;kl fd;s x;s ijUrq vfrfjDr vkj{kh ds xqe’kqnxh ds lEca/k esa b’rsgkj iksLVj Hkh vkj{kh ds QksVksxzkQ ds fcuk cuok;s x;sA QksVksxzkQ dh vuqmiyC/krk ds QyLo:i vkj{kh dh xqe’kqnxh ds lEca/k esa nwjn’kZu ds ek/;e ls Hkh lwpuk dk Álkj.k ugha djk;k tk ldkA mijksDr ifjfLFkfr ckotwn vkj{kh dks <wa<us gsrq tkap ds e/; v/kksgLrk{kjh ds Lrj ls lHkh lEHko Á;kl fd;s x;s ijUrq vHkh rd bldk dksbZ lkFkZd ifj.kke lkeus ugha vk;k gSA vkj{kh ds thfor vFkok e‘R;q gksus ds lEca/k esa orZeku esa miyC/k lk{;ksa ds vk/kkj ij dqN Hkh dguk lEHko ugha gSA laLrqfr& 1& izdj.k esa iqfyl vLirky ds MkDVj ,oa LvkQ rFkk iqfyl foHkkx ds vf/kdkfj;ksa deZpkfj;ksa ij yxk;s x;s vkjksi izekf.kr ugha ik;s x;sA bl izdj.k esa fdlh vfèkdkjh@deZpkjh dk dksbZ nks”k ugha ik;k tkrk gS QyLo:i fdlh ds Hkh fo:} fdlh izdkj dh n.MkRed dk;Zokgh fd;s tkus dh laLrqfr ugha dh tkrh gSA 2&vkj{kh ldynhi flag ekg flrEcj 2004 ds var ls dgha thfor vFkok e‘r ugha fn[kk;h iMk gS vkSj u gh mlds lEca/k esa dksbZ izekf.kr tkudkjh tkap ds e/; ;qfDr ;qDr iz;kl ds ckotwn izkIr gks ldk gSA bl izdj.k esa tuin dkuiqj uxj ds Fkkuk dksrokyh esa jiV la[;k 51 le; 15&45 fnukad 4&6&2010 }kjk vkj{kh ldynhi flag dh xqe’kqnxh ntZ dj ftyk iqfyl }kjk Hkh tkap dh dk;Zokgh LorU= :i ls dh tk jgh gSA ;|fi vèkksgLrk{kjh }kjk vkj{kh ds lEca/k esa lgh fLFkfr dh tkudkjh gsrq izR;sd lEHko iz;kl fd;s x;s gS rFkkfi izdj.k esa vkj{kh ds xk;c gksus ds lEcaèk esa ntZ xqe’kqnxh dks ;Fkkif{r vfHk;ksx esa rjehe djkdj bldh foospuk fdlh fo’ks”kK bdkbZ ls djk;s tkus dh laLrqfr dh tkrh gSA vk[;k voyksdukFkZ izsf”kr gSA” 23. On over all consideration of the facts and circumstances of the case, we express our full satisfaction on the investigation conducted and the report submitted on 3rd August, 2010 by Deputy Inspector General, P.A.C., Kanpur pursuant to the order of the Apex Court. 24. In so far as the investigation done and the final report submitted on 3rd December, 2012, by a Committee of seven police officials under the supervision of Deputy Inspector General of Police, in Case Crime No. 349 of 2012, pursuant to the order of this Court dated 17th September, 2012, is concerned, since the same is pending consideration before the Court of Special C.J.M. Kanpur Nagar, we do not express any opinion thereon, rather make it clear that the concerned Court will not be influenced in any manner by any of the observations made in this judgement, herein-before or herein-after and shall take final decision in the matter independently as per law. 25. From the reports, we find that all the efforts made by the police, were made subsequent to the directions of the Apex Court as well as this Court except the R.T. Message sent by R.I. Police Lines on 16th February, 2004. Thus, the police is responsible for its negligence in not taking proper action immediately after disappearance of Sri Sakaldeep Singh on 11th February, 2004 and thereafter till the investigation was initiated by the Deputy Inspector General under the orders of the Supreme Court and to this extent the complaint of the petitioner seems to be justified. Therefore, it is directed that the Director General of Police shall take appropriate action against the erring police officials in accordance with law expeditiously. 26. However, as discussed above, there is no foul play in his disappearance. As per testimony of the witnesses referred in the report Sri Sakaldeep Singh used to disappear and turn up after some time. His conduct was also not good, neither as a police personnel nor as a person. Accordingly, we do not deem it fit to order any further investigation in the matter. 27. In view of the discussions made above, we do not find any valid reason to pursue this matter any further. His conduct was also not good, neither as a police personnel nor as a person. Accordingly, we do not deem it fit to order any further investigation in the matter. 27. In view of the discussions made above, we do not find any valid reason to pursue this matter any further. In stead, as a period of more than 7 years has lapsed since the disappearance of Sri Sakaldeep Singh, it would be appropriate for the petitioner to approach the competent Court of civil jurisdiction to seek appropriate declaration in respect of her husband Sri Sakaldeep Singh and for other consequential reliefs to which, she may be entitled under law. But no further direction is required to be issued by this Court in the matter of disappearance of Sri Sakaldeep Singh. 28. Now the fact remains that by means of the amendments incorporated in the writ petition after remand of the matter from the Apex Court, the petitioner has also sought quashing of the dismissal order and has also claimed several service benefits inclusive of retiral benefits as well as compassionate appointment of her son, who is not even a party to the writ petition. 29. Therefore, in so far as the challenge made by the petitioner to the dismissal order of Sri Sakaldeep Singh is concerned, though the same has been passed ex parte, the concerned authorities cannot be faulted for the same, as they made all necessary efforts to serve notices and the charge-sheet upon Sri Singh, but on account of his non-availability and continued absence, they were left with no option except to proceed ex parte. Moreover, considering the conduct of Sri Sakaldeep Singh as mentioned in the dismissal order as also his past conduct, we are of the view that in spite of the disciplinary proceedings being ex parte, the dismissal order cannot be held to be bad in law, specially, the police force being a disciplined force and such unauthorised absence being uncondonable. 30. Consequently, in the facts and circumstances of this case, we do not find any reason or justification to interfere in the impugned order of dismissal, under Article 226 of the Constitution of India and therefore, no direction for post retiral benefits or compassionate appointment, as prayed for, can be issued. 31. 30. Consequently, in the facts and circumstances of this case, we do not find any reason or justification to interfere in the impugned order of dismissal, under Article 226 of the Constitution of India and therefore, no direction for post retiral benefits or compassionate appointment, as prayed for, can be issued. 31. However, in case Sri Sakaldeep Singh was entitled under any law to get any benefit or dues during the period he was in service, the same may be considered by the authority concerned and paid to the petitioner or such other person, who may be entitled to get the same, as per the provisions of law. 32. Accordingly, this writ petition is disposed of.