JUDGMENT 1. Heard learned counsel for the parties. 2. In this writ application, 71 petitioners have assailed the common order and judgment dated 29.6.2012 of the District Teachers Employment Appellate Tribunal, Saran (hereinafter to be referred to as ‘the Tribunal’) in Appeal Case No. 60 of 2011, 95 of 2011, 94 OF 2011, 68 of 2011 and 107 of 2011, whereby and whereunder, the Tribunal has refused to issue a direction for appointment of the petitioners on the post of Prakhand Teacher. A consequential direction has also been sought from this Court for issuance of appointment letter to all the petitioners in view of their being successful candidates pursuant to the selection process undertaken for appointment to the post of Prakhand Teacher. 3. Learned counsel for the petitioners while assailing the impugned order passed by the Tribunal, has basically concentrated on the aspect that once the selection process was already completed for appointment on the post of Prakhand Teacher and the petitioners were found placed in the merit list and the panel, they could not have been denied appointment on the post of Prakhand Teacher. It has also been submitted that this Court may itself call for the counseling register for verification of the claim of the petitioners inasmuch as they cannot be penalized for the deliberate mistakes committed by the recruiting unit including its Ex-Pramukh or the Block Development Officer. 4. Learned counsel for the State on the other hand has submitted that the findings of the Tribunal to the effect that, the entire selection process being itself vitiated by fraud including tampering of the records at the instance the Ex-Pramukh in course of preparation of the merit list, by itself would disentitle the petitioners to claim their appointment on the post of Prakhand Teacher specially when the second phase of appointment on the post of Prakhand/Panchayat Teacher under the relevant decision of the State Government has already been closed on 31.12.2010 wherein all the remaining vacancies of the second phase have to be filled up by ongoing fresh process of appointment of the third phase based on new criteria in terms of Rules framed in 2012. 5. The facts, as may be noted from the pleadings in the writ application, lie in a very narrow compass. 5. The facts, as may be noted from the pleadings in the writ application, lie in a very narrow compass. According to the petitioners, the second phase of the appointment of Prakhand Teacher in Manjhi Block had commenced in the month of August, 2008 wherein after screening of the applications of the eligible candidates including the petitioners, counseling was held on 24.1.2009 but, the original certificates produced by the candidates including the petitioners could not be verified and, therefore, their appointment could not be made despite different schedule fixed by the State government on 12.7.2010 and 4.12.2010. In this regard, it has also been pointed out that the decision taken on 24.12.2010 by the Director, Primary Education of making no further appointment in the second phase, save and except in exceptional specified cases, would also not apply to the facts of the case of the petitioners because in their case, counseling had already been completed and only certificates of the candidates including the petitioners were required to be verified. 6. In the considered opinion of this Court, the Tribunal has gone into the whole issue relating to alleged selection of the petitioners and others in a very elaborate manner and its well considered judgment running into fifteen pages by itself would be sufficient to show that the whole story of selection of the candidates was vitiated by fraud. The Tribunal in this regard has found that alleged counseling register was snatched and taken away by the previous Pramukh, namely, Khaitoon Bibi. The Tribunal has also found that the alleged merit list had contained forged signature of the Block Development Officer and there were also discrepancies in the signature over counseling register and on the list of the candidates. 7. In this regard, the Tribunal has on examination of the materials on record has arrived at a specific finding that when on a complaint of Jivan Singh, Sanjeev Kumar Singh, Arti Kumar, Kumari Priyanka Singh and Muni Singh, who also alike the petitioners were applicants for the post of Prakhand Teacher, a detailed enquiry was conducted, it was found that not only Khaitoon Bibi, the Ex-Pramukh in whose period the process of selection by way of advertisement and filing of application had commenced, had not even handed over the counseling register to her successor, the present Pramukh, namely, Akhatari Begam. Infact Akhatari Begam had taken a specific plea to this effect before the officers of the Education Department that all relevant papers were not produced before her by the Block Development Officer, Manjhi and an information therefore was also given by her to the Collector of the district. 8. Such a plea of fraud committed by Khaitoon Bibi the then Pramukh, was also gone into by the Tribunal at great length. In this regard it is important to note here that when Khaitoon Bibi, Ex-Pramukh had herself appeared before the Tribunal and produced the selection list claiming that the selection had already been done in accordance with the Rule, the Tribunal on its indepth examination had found from them only that the so called proceeding book was not maintained as per the rules and the provisional merit list dated 22.1.2009 did not match with the recordings in the proceeding book. The Tribunal in this regard had also found existence of two provisional merit lists, one dated 22.1.2009 of 102 candidates and other dated 6.12.2008 of 162 candidates but drawing of either of the merit list was not confirmed from the proceedings in the proceeding book. In this regard, the Tribunal has also gone into the aspect that such proceeding register was to be maintained as prescribed and supplied by the Government but that was also not maintained and the proceedings were recorded in the plain exercise book. 9. It was in these circumstances that when the Tribunal could find no evidence of the story of preparation of provisional merit list and final merit list substantiated from the Proceedings book, inasmuch as, there were no corresponding entry of the meeting of the Selection Committee as prescribed under the Rules, it had come to a definite conclusion that the whole list produced by the Block Development Officer in the few pages of exercise book containing list of names of 161 candidates of the male/female of Scheduled Caste category, 52 of the male and female of Backward category, 53 male/female of Extremely Backward category and a separate list of 10 trained male and 83 trained female candidates was contrary to what was claimed by way of selection and preparation of the merit list by Khaitoon Bibi, the Ex-Pramukh who, as noted above, had come with a list of 102 candidates. The Tribunal infact having also found that the counseling register which had been produced by the Block Development Officer did not contain signature of all the five members of the Selection Committee but, only of the Block Education Officer and the Ex-Pramukh had eventually came to a finding that when there was no record to show all the entries of the date of receipt of the application as also holding of the first meeting only of the 30.11.2008 as against the prescribed date by the State Government in between 18.11.2008 to 27.11.2008, the absence of the publication of merit list without any date which as per the government decision had to be done by 1.12.2008, there were sufficient materials to hold that none of the prescribed procedure for selection and appointment for the Prakhand Teacher was followed. 10. In view of the above findings, there would be hardly any reason for this Court to interfere with the impugned well considered judgment of the Tribunal and issuance of the consequential direction for perpetuating the gross illegality which was committed by the selecting unit. This Court, therefore in absence of unimpeachable materials brought on record by the petitioners in this writ application which could have established the findings and the conclusion arrived by the Tribunal in the impugned judgment was based on any error of record will have no difficulty in approving the findings recorded by the Tribunal, relevant portion whereof reads as follows:- ^^fcUnq 1 ,oa 3 vf/klwpuk la[;k 7@fu0 3&02@06 va’k ds 3151 fnukad 25-08-2008 ds fu;e 6 ds varxZr f’k{kd fu;kstu gsrq ,d foHkkxh; jftLVj fuxZr fd;k x;k ftls ftyk f’k{kk v/kh{kd ds }kjk lHkh iapk;r lfefr@uxj fodkl@xzke iapk;rksa dks iath dh vkiwfrZ djuk rFkk iz[k.M ,oa iapk;r ds fy, ftyk iapk;rh jkt inkf/kdkjh rFkk uxj fuxe ds fy, eq[; dk;Zikyd inkf/kdkjh ftyk ifj”kn~ }kjk i`”Vksa dh la[;k vafdr dj vfHkizekf.kr dh xbZ gksxh& blh iath esa f’k{kd fu;kstu gsrq izkIr vkosnu i=ksa rFkk es/kk lwph fu;kstu gsrq dkmaflfyax vkfn dk C;kSjk la/kkfjr fd;k tk;sxk rFkk bdkbZ ds lfpo ds }kjk vkosnu izkfIr dh vafre frfFk dks vkosnu i=ksa dks izo`f”V ds mijkar iath dks cna dj fn;k tk,sxkA ftl ij de ls de nks lnL;ksa dk gLrk{kj gksuk vfuok;Z gSA vc ;g tkap dk fo”k; gS fd dk D;k fu;kstu bdkbZ us mijksDr fu;eksa dk ikyu djrs gq, fu;kstu dh izfdz;k laiUu dh gS \ 1. Photocopy Proceeding dk nkf[ky fd;k x;k fcuk frfFk dk lR;kiu [kSrqu chch dk gLrk{kj gS& i`”V ij 39 iUuksa dks izekf.kr iz[k.M f’k{kk inkf/kdkjh }kjk fd;k x;k gS tcfd mijksDr fu;eksa ds vuqlkj iapk;r jkt inkf/kdkjh }kjk iwjs iath ds iUuksa dks izekf.kr djus dk vf/kdkj gS tcfd nkf[ky Proceeding Register ij iapk;r jkt inkf/kdkjh }kjk dqy iuus dks izekf.kr ugha fd;k x;k vkSj uk gh ekuo lalk/ku fodkl foHkkx dk izR;sd i`”B ij eksuksxzke gS tcfd lHkh i`”Bksa ij ekuo lal/kku fodkl foHkkx fy[kk jguk vko’;d gS] tks ugha gSA 2. vkSicaf/kr lwph tks vyx ls fnukad 22-01-2009 frfFk dk ckjg iuuksa esa dzekad 01 ls 162 vH;fFkZ;ksa dh lwph nkf[ky dh xbZ gS& tcfd Proceeding Register esa ,slh dksbZ frfFk ugha gS ftlls Li”V gks fd vkSicaf/kr lwph izdkf’kr fnukad 22-01-2009 dks fd;k gS& iqu% vkSicaf/kd lwph fnukad 06-12-2008 ds frfFk dk QksVksdkWih 14 iUuksa esa vH;fFkZ;ksa dh lwph dzekad 1 ls 102 rd dk nkf[ky fd;k gS] tcfd Proceeding Register esa dksbZ ,slh frfFk fu/kZkfjr ugha gS vkSj uk gh i=kad 3376 fnukad 15-09-2008 esa ,slh dks frfFk fu/kkZfjr gSA tcfd vkSicaf/kr vH;fFkZ;ksa dh vU; lwph mUgha fuxZr jftLVj ij jguh pkfg, uk fd vyx ls A dgus dk vFkZ ;g gS fd fu/kkZfjr jftLVj ij fu;kstu dk dk;Z ugha fd;k x;k gS A mlh izdkj vH;fFkZ;ksa dh izfr{kk lwph SC dksfV 1&41 vH;fFkZ;ksa dk] ch0 lh0 dk lwph 1&36] bZ0ch0lh0 dk 1&37] ;w0 vkj0 dk 1&148 vH;fFkZ;ksa dh lwph fnukad 18-11- vyx&vyx iUuka ij ¼QksVks dkWih½ nkf[ky fd;k gS tcfd lHkh lwfp;k¡ mlh foHkkx ls fuxZr jftLVj ij gksuh pkfg, rFkk lHkh izfdz;ksa dh dkjokgh fuxZr iath esa iwjs gksuk mldh izekf.kdrk dks lkfcr djrk gS tcfd izksflfMax iath esa dqN Hkh lgh & lgh ntZ ugha gS ftlls bu lkjs lwfp;ksa dks izek.kdrkZ ij fo’okl fd;k tk, mijksDr lwph esa vafre es/kk lwph nkf[ky ugha gS A 3. dkmaflfyax iath ftldk QksVks dkWih iz[k.M f’k{kk inkf/kdkjh eka>h }kjk nkf[ky fd;k x;k gS& mldh izekf.kdrk dh tkap Hkh vko’;d gSA vf/klwpuk la[;k 7@fu0 03&02@06 va’k d 3151 fnukad 25-08-08 ds fu;e 6 ds varxZr fuxZr jftLVj ij gha lkjh fu;kstu dh izfdz;k djuk vko’;d gS ftlesa dkmaflfyax Hkh layXu gS dkmaflfyax iath dk QksVksdkWih nkf[ky iz[k.M f’k{kk inkf/kdkjh }kjk nkf[ky fd;k x;k gS tks izFke i`”B ds ns[krs gh izekf.kr gS fd oks NAVDEEP jftLVj ij vuqlwfpr tkfr@efgyk iq:"k ¼4 iUuk½ 1&161 vH;FkhZ] ch0lh0 iq:”k efgyk ¼iUuk 3½] 1&52 vH;FkhZ] bZ0ch0lh0 iq:”k efgyk&¼03 iUuk ½1&53] izf’kf{kr iq:”k 1&10 ¼5 iUuk½] izf’kf{kr efgyk 1&83 ¼5 iUuk½ lHkh NAVDEEP jftLVj ij rS;kj dj izLrqr fd;k x;k gS tks iw.kZr% fu;e fo:) rFkk voS/k gSA fu;kstu bdkbZ }kjk ekuo lalk/ku fodkl foHkkx ds fn, x, fu;eksa dk iw.kZr% mYya|u fd;k x;k gS] tks dkmaflfyax iath nkf[ky dh x;h gS mlds i`”Vksa dks izekf.kr iz[k.M f’k{kk inkf/kdkjh] iz[k.M izeq[k [kkSrqu chch dk gLrk{kj fcuk frfFk dk gS rFkk ftruk Hkh iUuk dkmaflfyax dk nkf[ky fd;k gS ml ij fdlh Hkh bdkbZ ds lnL;ksa dk gLrk{kj ugha gS cfYd vafre i`”V ij iz[k.M f’k{kk inkf/kdkjh dk gLrk{kj fcuk frfFk dk gS tks iw.kZr% fu;efo:) gS vkSj xyr gS] ftls izekf.kr iath ugha ekuk tk ldrk gSA blls Li”V gS fd fu;kstu bdkbZ ds nkSjku cgqr cM+h /kka/kyh dh xbZ gSA ¼1½ i=kad 7@fu0 03&015@08 3376 fnukad 15-09-08 ds vuqlkj izR;sd fu;kstu bdkbZ dks vkosnu fnukad 29-10-2008 ls fnukad 17-11-2008 rd izkIr dj ysuk FkkA tcfd Proceeding Register esa vkosnu izkfIr dk entry ugha gS tcfd lkjh izfdz;k fuxZr iath ij gh djuh FkhA ¼2½ es|k lwph dh rS;kjh fnukad 18-11-2008 ls fnukad 27-11-2008 rd djuh Fkh A tcfd izFke cSBd fnukad 30-11-2008 dks dh xbZ gSa A ftlesa jksLVj fcUnq ds vuqlkj in dk vkj{k.k] 7757&7842 foHkkx }kjk fn’kk funZs’k izkIr djuk] ftlesa B.Ed ;k Diploma ds vykok izkIr Certificate ds laca/k esa lkekU; rFkk ‘kkjhfjd f’k{kd ds iSuy rS;kj djuk rFkk jkf’k dh ekax dk izLrko ikfjr fd;k x;k A ¼3½ es|k lwph dk izdk’ku 01-12-2008 rd djuk Fkk ysfdu Proceeding Register esa dgha ugha ,slh frfFk fu/kkZfjr dh x;hA tcfd nwljh cSBd fnukad 29-12-2008 dks dh x;h ftlesa vkifRr ,oa nkok fujkdj.k ds fy, dh x;h tcfd vkifRr fujkdj.k gsrq fu/kkZfjr frfFk fnukad 17-12-2008 ls 22-12-2008 rd FkhA ¼4½ es|k lwph dk vafre izdk’ku fnukad 24-12-2008 fu/kkZfjr gS tcfd r`rh; cSBd fnukad 05-02-09 dks dh x;hA ftlesa vafre es|k lwph izLrqr fd;k x;k rFkk lk{kkRdkj gsrq fnukad 05-12-2010 dh frfFk fu/kkZfjr dh x;h tcfd ,slh dksbZ frfFk i=kad 3376 fnukad 15-09-2008 esa fu/kkZfjr ugha dh x;h Fkh tcfd i=kad ds var esa funsZf’kr fd;k x;k gS fd ifjofrZr le; rkfydk ds vuqlkj f’k{kd fu;kstu dh dkjokbZ dh tk,] tc dksbZ Hkh fu;kstu dh dkjokbZ fu/kkZfjr frfFk dks lEiUu ugha fd;k x;k vFkkZr~ fu;eksa dk ikyu ugha fd;k x;k A mijksDr mYysf[kr rF;ksa ,oa nkf[ky fd;k x;k dkxtkrksa ds vk/kkj ij fd, x, foospukvksa ls ;g izekf.kr gksrk gS fd fu;kstu bdkbZ ds }kjk u rks fu;kstu izfdz;k fu/kkZfjr frfFk ds varxZr fd;k gS vkSj ukgh tks documents izLrqr fd;k gS oks fuxZr jftLVj ij rS;kj ugha fd;s x;s vkSj ukgha funs’kksa dk ikyu fd;s x, gS vr% izLrqr lHkh fu;kstu lacaf/kr dkxtkr ij fo’okl ugha fd;k tk ldrk A fcUnq 2 vkosnd thou flag] latho dqekj flag] vkjrh dqekjh] dqekjh fiz;adk flag ,oa eqfu flag dh vksj ls Hksts x, i= ftlesa mUgksusa lwfpr fd;k gS fd iwoZ iz[k.M izeq[k rFkk muds lg;ksxh us cyiwoZd dkmaflfyax jftLVj Nhu fy, vkSj vktrd ugha ykSVk, gSa] blds leFkZu esa ftyk f’k{kk v/kh{kd lkj.k Jh txr ifr pkS/kjh dk i= Kkikad 810@Nijk fnukad 21-04-2009 layXu fd;k gS ftlesa iz[k.M izeq[k dks iz[k.M f’k{kk inkf/kdkjh ds i=kad 76 fnukad 14-02-2009 ds }kjk dkmaflfyax jftLVj cyiwoZd fNudj ys tkus ds fy, Li”Vhdj.k ekax dh gSA iwoZ izeq[k [kSrqu chch dk Li”Vhdj.k i=kad 16 fnukd 24-04-2009 dks ftyk f’k{kk v/kh{kd] lkj.k dks fn;k gS ftlesa muds fo:) yxk;s x;s vkjksi dk [kaMu djrs gq, Li”V djrh gS fd mUgsa dkmaflfyax ds fnu rd ,d Hkh cSBd esa mUgsa ugha cqyk;h x;h tcfd iz[k.M f’k{kk inkf/kdkjh] eka>h dks ;s Lo;a ,oa iz[k.M fodkl inkf/kdkjh us cSBd cqykus dks dgk ysfdu cSBd ugha djk;k x;kA iz[k.M f’k{kk inkf/kdkjh us [kwn vdsys fu.kZ; ysrs jgsA fnukad 24-01-2009 dks dkmaflfyax ds fnu 5 cts ds ckn Hkh yach drkjsa yxh Fkh iz[k.M f’k{kk inkf/kdkjh mlh oDr dkmaflfyax dk;Z lekIr dj dkmaflfyaax iath ds lkFk ysdj pys x, A fnukad 27-01-2009 dks os ek:fr oSu ij vk, rFkk lHkh vH;fFkZ;ksa fd lafpdk dks Nijk ys tkus dks dgk&tc ;s iz[k.M dk;kZy; esa dk;Z djus dks dgk rks gq, rSl esa vkdj xkM+h ykSVkdj pysa x,A vH;fFkZ;ksa dh lafpdk blh rjg iz[k.M dk;kZy; esa iM+h jghA ,d fnu Hkh iz[k.M eq[;ky; esa fu;kstu laca/kh dk;Z laiknu ugha fd;k x;kA iwoZ iz[k.M izeq[k ds Li”Vhdj.k fnukad 24-04-2009 nsus ds iwoZ iz[k.M f’k{kk inkf/kdkjh eka>h us i=kad 38 fnukad 24-01-2009 dks ftyk f’k{kk v/kh{kd lkj.k dks cyiwoZd izeq[k ,oa muds lg;ksfx;ksa }kjk dkmaflfyax iath] cSBd iath]vuqeksfnr iSuy fNu dj ys tkus dh lwpuk HksthA i=kad ‘kwU; fnukad 24-02-2009 dks iqu% ftyk f’k{kk v/kh{kd] lkj.k dks mDr dkxtkr ugha miyC/k djkus dh lwpuk nh] i=kad 118 fnukad 19-03-2009 iz[k.M fodkl inkf/kdkjh] eka>h dks Hkh mDr fNus x, fu;kstu lacaf/kr dkxtkr miyC/k ugha djk, tkus dh lwpuk nh x;h] i=kad 153 fnukad 08-04-2009 ds }kjk ftyk f’k{kk v/kh{kd lkj.k dks vius ij yxk;s x;s vkjksi ftlesa fu;kstu lfefr us vuqifLFkfr jgus dk [k.Mu fd;k lkFk gh iwoZ izeq[k }kjk fNudj ys x;s dkxtkrksa dks miyC/k djkus ds fy, dkjZokbZ ds fy, vuqxzg fd;k gS] i=kad 175 fnukad 23-04-2009 ftlesa iz[k.M fodkl inkf/kdkjh] dks viuk tokc muds fu;kstu dk;Zdze vuqifLFkr jgus dk vkjksi iwoZ izeq[k }kjk yxk;k gSA mlh dk li”Vhdj.k fn;k gS vkSj [k.Mu djrs gq, mDr fu;kstu ds dkxtkr miyC/k ugha djkbZ x;h rFkk mldk [k.Mu fd;k gS fd ;s lkjs dkxtkr vius ikl j[ksa gS rFkk lq>ko fn;k fd lkjs izDyu dh tkap fuxjkuh foHkkx ls djkbZ tk,A mijksDr rF;ksa ,oa i=ksa ds vknku iznku ,oa vkjksiksa ,oa izR;kjksiksa dk foospuk ls Li”V gS fd iwoZ izeq[k }kjk rFkk rRdkyhu iz[k.M f’k{kk inkf/kdkjh] }kjk fu;kstu izfdz;k esa ck/kk mRiUu fd;k x;k rFkk fu;kstu lacaf/kr lkjs dkxtkr iwoZ izeq[k ;k iz[k.M f’k{kk inkf/kdkjh ds }kjk j[k fy;k x;k ftlls fu;kstu dh izfdz;k iw.kZr% ckf/kr gqbZA ekuo lalk/ku fodkl foHkkx dks vuqjks/k fd;k tkrk gS fd lkjs lPpkbZ dh tkap fuxjkuh foHkkx ls djkbZ tk, ,oa ik, x, nks”kh inkf/kdkjh dks mfpr n.M feysA fcUnq 4 iz[k.M f’k{kk inkf/kdkjh eka>h }kjk fuxZr i=kad 386 fnukad 01-12-2011 ,oa i=kad 401 fnukad 23-12-2011 izkf/kdkj dks Hkstk gS ftlesa ;g lwfpr fd;k x;k gS fd fu;kstu dh lkjh izfdz;k iwjh gks pqdh Fkh dsoy fu;kstu i= ckaVuk ‘ks”k Fkk ysfdu ljdkj }kjk fu/kkZfjr frfFk dks fu;kstu i= forfjr ugha fd;k tk ldk] vkt ;s i= ds lkFk p;fur vH;fFkZ;ksa dh lwph nkf[ky dj jgsa gSAa i=kad 401 fnukad 23-12-2011 ds }kjk lwfpr fd;k x;k gS fd p;fur vH;fFkZ;ksa ds izek.k i=ksa dks lR;kfir djk fy;k x;k gSaA fQj ,d i= ftlesa i=kad ugha gS ukgh rkjh[k ntZ fd;k x;k gS& nkf[ky fd;k gS] ftlesa muds }kjk eka>h iz[k.M esa f’k{kdksa dh dqy fjfDr;k¡] jksLVj fcUnq ds vuqlkj vkj{k.k in] ftlds vykos ;s lwfpr fd;k x;k gS fd foHkkx }kjk fu/kkZfjr frfFk dks fu;kstu bdkbZ }kjk dk;Zokgh lekIr dj fu;kstu i= fuxZr djus gsrq p;u lwph ds vkyksd esa cSBd dh dk;Zokgh gsrq dk;Zdze iz[k.M fodkl inkf/kdkjh] dk;kZy; eka>h esa py jgh Fkh dh ekuo lalk/ku fodkl foHkkx ds i=kad 1557 fnukad 24-12-2010 ds vkyksd esa fu;kstu dk;Zdze LFkfxr dj fn;k x;kA var esa ,d i= jftLVj iksLV ls ftldk ua0 vkj0,y0 03@,e0@,0 Nijk fnukad 11-06-2012 dks izkIr gqvk gS mlesa iz[k.M f’k{kk inkf/kdkjh] eka>h us izkf/kdkj dks lwfpr fd;k gS fd mudk xyr gLrk{kj dj bl dk;kZy; esa dkxtkr izLrqr fd;k x;k gS vkSj lwfpr fd;k x;k gS fd nykyksa }kjk iSls olwyh dj jkst fnu p;fur lwph cuk;h tk jgh gS& ;g Li”V fd;k gS fd ftyk inkf/kdkjh] lkj.k ds dk;kZy; ls lwpuk fn;k x;k fd dkSu lk dkxtkr esjs ikl miyC/k gS ysfdu fnukad 23-03-2012 dks fyf[kr lwpuk fn;k gS fd fu;kstu lacaf/kr dksbZ dkxtkr muds ikl miyC/k ugha gS tcfd VksVy dkxtkr iz[k.M izeq[k }kjk tcju fNu fy;k x;k gS A ;g Hkh crk;k x;k gS fd ftl le; fu;kstu izfdz;k py jgh Fkh ml oDr eka>h iz[k.M esa Fks iz[k.M f’k{kk inkf/kdkjh ugha FksA ;gk¡ rd fd iz[k.M fodkl inkf/kdkjh tks vHkh xksikyxat lnj esa vuqeaMy inkf/kdkjh gSa] mudk Hkh xyr gLrk{kj cukdj lwph miyC/k djkbZ x;h gSA bl laca/k esa mUgksaus izfrfyfi ekuuh; eq[;ea=h] eq[; lfpo] ftyk inkf/kdkjh] lkj.k] ftyk f’k{kk inkf/kdkjh ,oa fgUnh lekpkj i=ksa dks Hkstk gSA mijksDr lkjs i=ksa dks lw{e :i ls voyksfdr djrs gq, tkap fd;k tk, rks ikrs gS fd lHkh i=ksa esa gLrk{kj djhc&djhc ,d rjg dk gS tcfd fcuk i=kad ,oa frfFk ds tks i= gS muds gLrk{kj dkQh fHkUu gS tks vU; i=ksa ds gLrk{kj ls ugha feyrk gS vxj ,d gh inkf/kdkjh] i=kad 386 fnukad 10-12-2011] 401 fnukad 23-12-2011 fuxZr djrs gSa rks ogha inkf/kdkjh i=kad 286 fnukad 02-06-2012 fuxZr dj mij ds nks i=ksa }kjk Hksts x, lwpukvksa dks tkyh gLrk{kj dj Hkstk x;k crk;k rFkk rF;ksa dks >wBk lkfcr djrk gS] vFkkZr~ mijksDr nks i=ksa ls tks rF; Li”V fd;s x;s gSa mldh dksbZ lPpkbZ ugha gSA vc Ikz’u gS fd okLro esa iwoZ iz[k.M f’k{kk inkf/kdkjh ds ikl oks lkjs dkxtkr miyC/k Fks tks vkt izkf/kdkj esa izLrqr fd,s gSa rFkk oks rF; i=kad 386 fnukad 10-12-11 ,oa 401 fnukad 23-12-2011 dks ifjyf{kr fd, gSa] muesa fdruh lPpkbZ gS \ miyC/k i=ksa ds tkap ds ckn Li”V gks ldrk gS \ izkf/kdkj ds le{k iz[k.M f’k{kk inkf/kdkjh] eka>h dk iwoZ i=kad 38 fnukad 24-01-2009 ls Li”V gksrk gS fd iwoZ iz[k.M izeaq[k }kjk dkmaflfyax iath] cSBd iath] vuqeksfnr iSuy lHkh dkxtkr muds lkFk muds lg;ksfx;ksa }kjk cyiwoZd fNu dj ys x;s i=kad fnukad 14-02-09 esa ftyk f’k{kk v/kh{kd] lkj.k dks lwfpr fd;k x;k gS fd vcrd izeq[k }kjk fu;kstu lacaf/kr dkxtkr miyC/k ugha djk, x, gS] i=kad 118 fnukad 09-03-2009 ds }kjk iz[k.M fodkl inkf/kdkjh] eka>h dks Hkh lwfpr fd;k x;k gS fd vcrd fu;kstu lacaf/kr dkxtkr iz[k.M izeq[k }kjk miyC/k ugha djk, x, ftuds dkj.k fu;kstu izfdz;k ckf/kr gSA i=kad 153 fnukad 08-04-09 ds }kjk ftyk f’k{kk v/kh{kd lkj.k dks viuh vuqifLFkfr dk Li”Vhdj.k nsrs gq, ;gk¡ Hkh mUgksausa crk;k gS fd iz[k.M izeq[k eka>h dks dkmaflfyax jftLVj miyC/k djkus gsrq vko’;d dk;ZokbZ djuk pkgsaxsa rkfd f’k{kd fu;kstu dk dk;Z le; ij lEikfnr gks lds& i=kad 173 fnukad 23-04-09 ds }kjk iz[k.M fodkl inkf/kdkjh] eka>h dks viuk Li”Vhdj.k nsrs gq, ;g [k.Mu fd;k gS fd muds ikl dkmaflfyax jftLVj j[kus dk vkjksi xyr gS rFkk vuqjks/k fd;k gS fd lkjs izDdyu dh fuxjkuh foHkkx }kjk tkap djkbZ tk,A bu lHkh i=ksa ij tks iwoZ iz[k.M f’k{kk inkf/kdkjh eka>h us gLrk{kj fd;k gS oks gLrk{kj orZeku esa tks i= izkIr gq, gS tSls i=kad 386 fnukad 10-12-2011] 401 fnukad 23-12-2011 ls vyx gS& dksbZ lekurk% dk Ikz’u ugha gS rFkk tks i= 286 fnukad 02-06-2012 Hksts x, gS oks bu nksuksa i=ksa ds gLrk{kj ls feyrs gSa vFkkZr~ lekurk gS] blls Li”V gS fd tks i= i=kad 286 fnukad 02-06-2012 vk,s gSa oks iwoZ ds i=ksa ds vk/kkj ij lPpkbZ dks Li”V dj jgk gS] muds ikl fu;kstu lacaf/kr dksbZ dkxtkr miyC/k ugha Fkk rFkk tks i= i=kad 386] 401 }kjk Hkstk x;k gS iw.kZr% lafnX/k bl vk/kkj ij Hkh gS fd fnukad 31-12-2010 dks ftyk inkf/kdkjh] lkj.k dk fu;kstu lacaf/kr vkjksi ,oa dk;ksZ dks ysdj leh{kkRed cSBd dh xbZ Fkh muesa eka>h iz[k.M ds dkWye 3 esa Li”V :i ls vfHkO;Dr fd;k x;k gS fd iwoZ iz[k.M izeq[k }kjk f’k{kd fu;kstu ls lacaf/kr lHkh vfHkys[k vkSj iaft;k¡ vius ikl j[k fy;s tkus vkSj izHkkj vc rd ugha lkSaius ds dkj.k iz[k.M esa dkmaflfyax ugha gqbZ rFkk ;g Li”V fd;k gS fd iz[k.M fodkl inkf/kdkjh ls Hkh ckj&ckj ekax fd;k ijUrq lwph izkIr ugha gqbZ vr% dksbZ fu;kstu fugha gqvk A ,slh fLFkfr esa fuxZr i=kad 386 fnukad 10-12-2011 ,oa i=kad 401 fnukad 13-12-2011 esa tks rF; Li”V fd;s gS blesa dksbZ lPpkbZ ugha yxrh gS D;ksafd izksflfMax jftLVj esa bu lkjs rF;ksa dk dgha o.kZu ugha gS vkSj uk gh dksbZ cSBd ,slh gqbZ gSA tgkW rd p;fur lwph nkf[ky djus dk iz’u gS rks ;g l?ku tkap dk Ikz’u gS D;ksafd iwoZ esa ;g vkjksi [kafMr dj pqds gS fd muds ikl fu;kstu lacaf/kr dksbZ dkxtkr ugha gS mlds vykok i=kad 286 fnukad 02-06-2012 rks iwoZ:is.k muds rF;ksa ,oa izLrqr lk{;ksa dks >wBk lkfcr dj fn;k gSA mijksDr mYysf[kr iz[k.M f’k{kk inkf/kdkjh] eka>h ds i=ksa dks leh{kkRed fjiksVZ ds fo’ys”k.k ,oa foospuk ls izekf.kr gksrk gS fd i=kad 386 fnukad 10-12-2011 rFkk i=kad 401 fnukad 23-12-11 esa tks rF; Li”V fd, gSa vFkkZr fu;kstu dh lkjh izfdz;k iwjh dj yh x;h Fkh flQZ fu;kstu i= ckaVuk Fkk p;fur vH;fFkZ;ksa dh lwph nkf[ky djrs gSa rFkk p;fur vH;fFkZ;ksa dk izek.k i=ksa dk lR;kiu djk fy;k x;k] lHkh rF;ghu gS rFkk lPpkbZ ls ijs gSa] vkSj tks documents nkf[ky dj jgsa gS oks lHkh >wBs gSaA vr% ekuo lalk/ku fodkl foHkkx ls vuqjks/k fd;k tkrk gS fd lkjs izkDdyu dh tkap foHkkxh; vf/kdkfj;ksa ;k fuxjkuh foHkkx ls djk;sa D;ksafd bu fu;kstu bdkbZ ds pyrs f’k{kd fu;kstu izfdz;k ckf/kr gqbZ gS vkSj fu;kstu iwjk ugha fd;k x;kA fcUnq 5 fu;kstu vihyh; okn la[;k 60@11 esa fyf[kr dFku vaxzsth esa ;g dgrs Li”V fd;k x;k gS fd eSa iwoZ iz[k.M izeq[k gwW vkSj mUgha ds v/;{krk esa f’k{kd fu;kstu dh iwjh gqbZ gS rFkk vafre p;fur lwph cuh rFkk lHkh p;fur vH;FkhZ dks vfH;fFkZ;ksa dk izek.k i= lR;kfir djk;k x;k mlds vykos xzsM’ku fyLV eka>h iz[k.M esa f’k{kd fu;kstu gsrq fjDr inksa dks ftyk inkf/kdkjh] lkj.k ,oa ftyk f’k{kk v/kh{kd] lkj.k }kjk izdkf’kr fd;k x;k tks vuqyXud 1 layXu fd;k gSA tgk¡ rd mijksDr i= D;k iwoZ iz[k.M izeq[k usa gh fy[kk gS \ bldk bl i= ls [k.Mu gksrk gS fd iwoZ iz[k.M izeq[k uk i=kad Mkyk vkSj uk gh frfFk vius gLrk{kj ds lkFk nh gS] tcfd fo}ku vf/koDrk Jh v:.k dqekj flag fnukad 13-04-12 dks nkf[ky fd;k& vfHkys[k ds voyksdu ls Kkr gksrk gS fd bu vf/koDrk dk odkyrukek [kSrquchch dh vksj ls nkf[ky ugha gSA blds vykos iwoZ iz[k.M izeq[k dk i=kad 16 fnukad 24-04-2009 esa iw.kZr% Li”V fd;k fd buds mij yxk;s vkjksi dh lkjs fu;kstu ds dkxtkr cyiwoZd fNudj ys x;s >wBs gSa cfYd iz[k.M f’k{kk inkf/kdkjh] eka>h us [kqn lkjs fu;kstu dk;Z Nijk esa dgha vKkr LFkku ij djrs gS vkSj oks fdlh dh fu;kstu ds cSBd esa Hkkx ugha fy;k D;ksafd mUgsa ugha cqyk;k x;k gS bu lkjs rF; ;g Li”V djrk gS fd iwoZ iz[k.M izeq[k dk fyf[kr dFku iq.kZr% lansgkRed gS! vkf[kj ,aslk dkSu dj jgk gS \ D;k blesa lPpkbZ gS \ ;g Hkh tkap dk fo”k; gS A fcUnq 6 ekuo lalk/ku fodkl foHkkx ls fuxZr i=kad 7@fu0&03&02@06 va’k d 902 fnukad 12-07-2010 fn, x, funsZ’kksa ds vuqlkj ftl fu;kstu bdkbZ us izek.k i=ksa dk lR;kiu djk fy;k gS ogk¡ fu;kstu i= forj.k dh frfFk fu/kZkfjr dh x;h gS vkSj tgk¡ ugha djk;k x;k ogk¡ vfH;fFkZ;ksa] ls ‘kiFk i= ysdj fu;kstu i= forfjr dh tk;sxhA ftlesa iz[k.M f’k{kd ds fu;kstu ds fy, fu/kkZfjr frfFk fnukad 27-07-2010 fu/kkZfjr Fkh] ijUrq eka>h iz[k.M esa fcUnq 1] 2] 3] 4] 5 ls ;g izekf.kr gksrk gS fd fu;kstu dk dksbZ Hkh izfdz;k ekuo lalk/ku foHkkx ds }kjk fn, x, funs’kkZsa rFkk vf/klwpuk la[;k 7@fu0&03&02@06 va’k d 3151 fnukad 25-08-2008 ds fu;e 6 ds varxZr ikyu ugha fd;k x;k rFkk voS/k :i ls lkjh izfØ;k,s fd;k x;k] tcfd fcUnq 2 ls izekf.kr gks pqdk gS fd iz[k.M izeq[k }kjk fu;kstu lacaf/kr lkjs dkxtkr fNudj ysdj pys x, rFkk fnukad 31-12-10 ftyk inkf/kdkjh] lkj.k ds leh{kkRed cSBd ls Li”V gS fd ml le; rd vFkkZr fn0 31-12-10 ugha ykSVs;s x, Fks vr% fu;kstu izfØ;k iw.kZ:is.k ckf/kr dj nh x;hA foHkkxh; i=kad 850 fnukad 05-07-10 ds varxZr bdkbZ funsZf”kr vof/k esa fu;kstu dk;Ziwjk ugha djrs rFkk izek.k i=ksa ds lR;kiu djus esa lg;ksx ugha djus ij muds fo:) iz’kklfud ,oa vuq’kklfud dk;Zokgh dh tk,xh] pw¡fd fu;kstu bdkbZ ds }kjk iwjh izfØ;k ckf/kr dh x;h gS blfy, tkap ds ckn nks”kh vf/kdkjh ds fo:) iz’kklfud ,oa vuq’kklfud dk;Zokgh dh vko’;drk gSA ekuo lalk/ku fodkl foHkkx ds i=kad 7@fu0&3&02@06 vad ^d^ 1475 fnukad 15-12-2010 fuxZr dh x;h tgk¡ mijksDr frfFk ds vuqlkj fu;kstu i= forfjr ugha fd;k x;k blfy, fu;kstu LFkfxr dj fn;k x;k rks ljdkj iqu% fopkj djus ij ubZ frfFk fu/kkZfjr dh x;h ftlesa iz[k.M f’k{kd fu;kstu gsrq fnukad 28-12-2010 fu/kkZfjr fd;k x;k rFkk lDr funsZ’k fn;k x;k fd mDr frfFk rd fu;kstu dh iwjh izfØ;k lEiUu djrs gq, fu;kstu i= forfjr djuk lqfuf’pr fd;k tk,A ;g Hkh funs’k fn;k x;k gS fd ml frfFk ds Ik’pkr~ fd;k x;k fu;kstu oS| ugha gksxk rFkk frfFk;ksa ds mijkar dksbZ fu;kstu ugha fd;k tk,xk vkSj f}rh; f’k{kd fu;kstu dh dk;ZokbZ lekIr ekuh tk,xhA iz[k.M eka>h f}rh; pj.k f’k{kd fu;kstu ds dk;Zokgh iqfLrdk ls dgha ifjyf{kr ugha gS fd dksbZ fu;kstu dh izfØ;k mijksDr funs’kksa ds vuqlkj viukbZ x;h vkSj uk gh fu;kstu i= fuxZr fd;k x;k& tgk¡ rd mijksDr lHkh fcUnqvksa vFkkZr~ 1] 2] 3] 4] 5 ls izekf.kr gks pqdk gS fd fu;kstu bdkbZ ds vkilh LokFkZ ds pyrs fu;kstu izfØ;k iw.kZr% ckf/kr gks x;h vkSj fdlh vfHk;fFkZ;ksa dk fu;kstu ugha gks ik;k vr% fu;kstu bdkbZ ds fo:) vuq’kklfud dk;ZokbZ djus dh vuq’kalk dh tkrh gS A fcUnq 7 fcUnq 1 ,oa 3 ds foospuk ,oa fu”d”kZ ls izekf.kr gks pqdk gS fd dk;Zokgh iqfLrdk] vkSicaf/kd vH;fFkZ;ksa dh lwph] izfr{kk lwph] dkmaflfyax iath lHkh voS/k :i ls vke uksV cqd ¼dkWih½ ij rS;kj fd;k x;k gS vFkkZr~ tks iath ekuo lalk/ku fodkl foHkkx ls fuxZr fd;k x;k mij dksbZ dk;Z ugha fd;k x;k gS lkFk ;g Hkh izekf.kr gks pqdk gS fd dkmaflfyax iath] cSBd iath] vuqeksfnr iSuy lHkh iz[k.M izeq[k }kjk cyiwoZd fNudj ysdj pys x, gS vkSj tks fnukad 31-12-2010 rd ykSVk;sa ugha x, gSA tgkW ij iwjh&dh&iwjh izfØ;k fu;e fo:) rFkk voS/k :i ls fu;kstu dh izfØ;k lwphc) fd;k x;k gS] ogk¡ ij p;fur lwph dh oS|rk dh dksbZ izek.k ugha gSA D;ksafd p;fur lwph dkmaflfyax ds ckn rS;kj fd;k tkrk gS tcfd dkmaflfyax iath gh voS/k :i ls rS;kj fd;k x;k gks rks p;fur lwph Lor% voS/k gks tkrk gS vr% iwjh fu;kstu izfØ;k fu;kstu bdkbZ ds }kjk LokFkZr% vlaoS/kkfud :i ls iwjk fd;k x;k gS vr% vkSicaf/kd es|k lwph] izfr{kk lwph] vafre es|k lwph p;fur vH;fFkZ;ksa dh lwph dh dksbZ oS/;rk ugha gSA tgk¡ rd izek.k i=ksa ds lR;kiu dk iz’u gS \ fcUnq 4 ds foospuk ,oa fo’ys”k.k ls izekf.kr gks pqdk gS fd iz[k.M f’k{kk inkf/kdkjh] eka>h dk fuxZr i=kad 386 fnukad 10-12-2011 ,oa i=kad 401 fnukad 23-12-2011 iw.kZr% lnsgkRed gS ftlij fo’okl ugha fd;k tk ldrk gSA vfo’okl djus dk ,d vkSj eq[; dkj.k gS fd iz[k.M f’k{kk inkf/kdkjh eka>h Lo;a vdsys fu;kstu dk;Z ugha dj ldrs cfYd muds lkFk 4 lnL; vkSj gksrs gSa muds lkFk cSBd ds ckn lkjk fu.kZ; ysus dh izfØ;k gS tks izksflfMax iath esa ntZ jgrk gSA ,slk dqN Hkh fu.kZ; ntZ ugha gS vkSj uk gha oks izksflfMax jftLVj gS tks ekuo lalk/ku fodkl foHkkx ds }kjk fuxZr fd;k x;k gSA okn dh ,d vkosfndk vkjrh dqekjh }kjk jftLVj iksLV ftldk uacj 427 ¼vkj0,y0 Nijk vkj0,e0,l ¼841301½dkmaVj ua01½ vks0ih0 dksM 01 fnukad 21-06-2012 ds ek/;e ls ;g fy[krs gq, Hkstk gS fd vcrd nl rjg dk p;fur vH;fFkZ;ksa dh lwph fu;kstu bdkbZ ds gLrk{kj dks miyC/k djk;k x;k gS] rFkk le;≤ ij gVk;k x;k gS lHkh iSuy esa varj vk,sxkA dkmaflfyax iath gS& mls layXu djrs gq, bl vk’; dk Hkstk fd tks dkmaflfyax iath iz[k.M f’k{kk izlkj inkf/kdkjh }kjk nkf[ky fd;k x;k gS mlij ftu vH;fFkZ;ksa dk gLrk{kj gS ewy esa fd, x, vH;fFkZ;ksa ds gLrk{kj fofHkUu gS] esy ugha [kkrs gSA blds vykos p;fur vH;fFkZ;ksa dh lwph Hksth gS oks bl fy, fd tks iz[k.M f’k{kk inkf/kdkjh] eka>h }kjk nkf[ky p;fur lwph ls fdruk fHkUu gS vkSj fdrus u, uke tksM+s fn, x, gSA bu lkjh rF;ksa ds tkap ds fy, Hkstk x;k gS A Hksts x, dkmaflfyax iath 5 vyx&vyx dksfV ds Hksts x, gSa] ftuesa Øe’k% 11] 4] 4] 4] 39] 10 iUuksa dk laxzg gS ftlij vH;fFkZ;ksa dk gLrk{kj gS rFkk izR;sd i`”V ij ftyk iapk;rh jkt inkf/kdkjh ds eqgj ds lkFk gLrk{kj ,oa frfFk Hkh gS bu ij tks dkmaflfyax esa mifLFkr vfH;FkhZ ds gLrk{kj gSa os gLrk{kj iz[k.M f’k{kk inkf/kdkjh ds }kjk nkf[ky dkmaflfyax iath ij fd, x, u, gLrk{kjksa ls ugha feyrsa gSa ysfdu ;s Hksts x, dkmaflfyax iaft;k¡ fcuk lR;kfir rFkk fcuk izekf.kdrk ds Hksts x, gS bl fy, budk vk/kkj fu.kZ; ds fy, ugha cuk;k tk ldrk gSA blh izdkj p;fur vH;fFkZ;ksa dh lwph esa ;w0vkj0 ds 1 ls 20 vH;fFkZ;ks dk fyLV 7] ;w0vkj0,Q0 esa 1&23] ,l0lh0,Q0 dk 1&8 bZ0ch0 lh0,Q0 dk 1&8] ,l0lh0 dk 1&7] ch0lh0,Q0 dk 1&8] ch0lh0 dk 1&5] bZ0ch0lh0 dk 1&8 vH;fFkZ;ksa dk pkj [k.M esa Hksts gSaA iwjs dk voyksdu ls Kkr gksrk gS fd nks vyx&vyx fyLV gSa& ftlesa ;w0vkj0,Q0 flfj;y 1&12 ,oa 12&23 ukeksa esa dqN uke cnys gq, gSa& ;w0vkj0 esa 1&12 ds Øe esa lwph esa vH;fFkZ;ksa dk uke cnyk gqvk gS] ,l0lh0,Q0 1&18 ds Øe esa dqN vH;fFkZ;ksa dk uk cnyk gS& ,l0lh0 1&7 Øe esa 1 uke cnys gq, gSa] ch0lh0,Q0 1&8 Øe esa 2 uke cnys gq, gSa ch0lh0 1&5 ds Øe esa pkj uke cnys gq, gSaA bZ0ch0lh0 ds 1&8 Øe esa 3 uke cnys gq, gSaA tc nksuksa fyLV dk xkSj fd;k tkrk gS rks ik;k tkrk gS fd iz[k.M f’k{kk inkf/kdkjh gLrk{kj fHkUu&fHkUu gS vFkkZr~ oks O;fDr ugha gS tks fyLV iwoZ esa rS;kj fd;k x;k Fkk D;ksafd nwljs fyLV esa iz[k.M fodkl inkf/kdkjh ds gLrk{kj ugha gSa pw¡fd bu lkjs fyLV ,oa dkmaflfyax jftLVj lR;kfir ugha gS] vr% U;k;laxr rdZ ;k fu.kZ; ysuk fof/kiw.kZ ugha gS] flQZ bruk dgk tkrk ldrk gS fd dkQh ek=k esa /kak/kyh gqbZ gSA fcUnq 8 mijksDr fcUnqvksa vFkkZr~ 1] 2] 3] 4] 5] 6] 7 ds fu”d”kZ ls izekf.kr gS fd fu;kstu bdkbZ ds vius LokFkZ ds dkj.k iwjh izfØ;k vo:) gq;h rFkk nkf[ky fd;k x;k lacaf/kr dkxtkr ftlesa dkmaflfyax iath] vkSicaf/kd lwph] izfr{kk lwph] izksflfMax iath] p;fur lwph fu;kstu bdkbZ ds }kjk nkf[ky fd;k x;k lHkh izfØ;k ekuo lalk/ku fodkl foHkkx ds }kjk fuxZr iath ij ugha dj Private iqfLrdk NAVDEEP COPY ij fd;k x;k tks iw.kZr% voS/k gSA i=kad 386 fnukad 10-12-2011 ,oa i=kad 401 fnukad 23-12-2011 dksbZ lkFkZdrk ugha gS] vr% izek.k i=ksa dh lR;kiu dh lR;rk dk dksbZ Ikz’u ugha gSA ;g rdZ iw.kZ fu”d”kZr vkrk gS fd fu;kstu bdkbZ esa iwoZ iz[k.M f’k{kk inkf/kdkjh] eka>h] ,oa iwoZ iz[k.M izeq[k iw.kZr% nks”kh gS ftuds dkj.k f’k{kd fu;kstu izfØ;k iwjh ugha gks ik;h rFkk fdlh vH;fFkZ;ksa dk fu;kstu ugha gks ik;kA pw¡fd bl iwjs izDdyu esa vkosfnr vH;fFkZ;ksa dk dksbZ nks”k ugha gS] muds Hkfo”; ds lkFk mijksDr fu;kstu bdkbZ ds lnL; ¼ftuds fo:) mij mYysf[kr fd;k gS½ us [ksyk gS vr% foHkkxh; i=kad 850 fnukad 05-07-2010 ds varxZr fu;kstu bdkbZ ds fo:) iz’kklfud ,oa vu’kklfud dk;Zokgh dh tk, blds vykos i=kad 7@fu0 03&02@08 va’k d 207 fnukad 21-02-2011 ds varxZr izko/kku 2 ftlesa izkf/kdkj ¼vxj tkap ds Øe esa ikrs gS fd fdlh fo’ks”k fu;kstu bdkbZ ds O;fDr vFkok inkf/kdkjh ds }kjk ljdkj ds funsZ’kksa dk ugha ekurs gq, tku cw> dj f}rh; pj.k f’k{kd fu;kstu dh izfØ;k dk ikyu ugha fd;k x;k gS ;k vlQy fd;k x;k gS rks ,sls dfeZ;ksa inkf/kdkfj;ksa ds laca/k esa viuk izfrosnu ftyk ds foHkkxh; inkf/kdkjh dks nsaxs½ blls lacaf/kr nks”kh O;fDr ds fo:) vko’;d dkjokbZ dh tk,A bUgha nks izko/kkuksa dsa varxZr ekuo lalk/ku fodkl foHkkx ls vuqjks/k gS fd iwjs izDdyu dh tkap fuxjkuh foHkkx ls djkdj nks”kh O;fDr@inkf/kdkjh ds fo:) dkjZokbZ dh tk,A D;ksfd fu;kstu bdkbZ ds LokFkZo’k 87 vH;fFkZ;ksa dk Hkfo”; lekIr gks x;k gSA vr% mijksDr lHkh fcUnqvksa izkIr fu”d”kZ dks eÌsutj j[krs gq, mijksDr lHkh vkosndksa dk vkosnu ,d lkFk vLohd`r fd;k tkrk gS rFkk oknksa dk fu”iknu fd;k tkrk gS A *** (underlining for emphasis) 11. Having regard to the aforementioned findings, it would vitiate the entire process of selection in keeping with the provisions laid down under Rule 9 of the Bihar Panchayat Teacher Appointment Rule, 2006, this Court cannot direct the authorities to now complete the process of selection specially when the second phase for appointment of the Teachers has already been closed and the vacancies have been carried forward for a fresh appointment to be undertaken in the third phase. To that extent, this Court would find support from the letter of the Director, Primary Education dated 24.12.2010 wherein the case of the petitioners cannot be brought under the exception specially when there was a large scale bungling in the process of even preparation of provisional merit list and the final merit list. 12. The overemphasized submission of the learned counsel for the petitioners that they cannot be faulted on account of the bungling committed by the officials, its answer is not only found in the Full Bench judgment of this Court in the case of Bijoy Kumar Bharti & Ors. Vs. State of Bihar & Ors. reported in 1983 PLJR 667 but also in the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Krishna Yadav Vs. State of Haryana reported in (1994) 4 SCC 165 wherein while setting aside the selection and appointment of 96 Tax Inspectors found to be tainted on account of interpolation, forgery and fictitious award of marks whose records of selection also had been destroyed by the Public Service Commission, it was held as follows:- “It is highly regrettable that that the holders of public offices both big and small have forgotten that the offices entrusted to them are sacred trusts. Such offices are meant for use and not abuse. From a Minister to a menial everyone has been dishonest to gain undue advantages. The whole examination and the interview have turned out to be farcical exhibiting base character of those who have been responsible for this sordid episode. It shocks out conscience to come across such a systematic fraud. It is somewhat surprising the High Court should have taken the path of least resistance stating, in view of the destruction of records, that it was helpless. It should have helped itself. Law is not that powerless.” 13. Thus, this Court does not find any merit in this application and the same is accordingly dismissed. 14. It is somewhat surprising the High Court should have taken the path of least resistance stating, in view of the destruction of records, that it was helpless. It should have helped itself. Law is not that powerless.” 13. Thus, this Court does not find any merit in this application and the same is accordingly dismissed. 14. Before parting with, this Court having regard to the findings against Khaitoon Bibi, a former Pramukh and the then Block Education Extension Officer, would direct that the Principal Secretary, Education Department should himself examine into all the aspects relating to interpolation and manufacturing of the records relating to selection of the petitioners for the post of Prakhand Teacher in Manjhi block and take appropriate steps for initiating disciplinary action against the erring government officials including the then Block Education Officer, Manjhi in the light of the findings of the Tribunal. A criminal case should also be lodged against all concerned including Khaitoon Bibi, Ex-Pramukh, the then Bolck Education Officer, Manjhi which should be investigated by vigilance department of the State Government. The Principal Secretary Education Department having initiated both disciplinary and criminal proceedings will submit his action taken report to this Court within a period of six months from the date of receipt of this order. 15. Let a copy of this order be sent to the Principal Secretary of Education Department for its strict compliance by all concerned.