JUDGMENT : Mansoor Ahmad Mir, Chief Justice (Oral) Subject matter of this writ petition is order dated 16.4.2015 (Annexure P8) made by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Chandigarh (Circuit Bench at Shimla) in O.A No. 063/000135/2014, whereby the Original Application filed by the petitioner came to be dismissed, for short “the impugned judgment”, on the grounds in the memo of the writ petition. 2. Respondents have filed the reply. The petitioner has filed the rejoinder. 3. It is apt to record herein that the petitioner has annexed the medical certificate Annexure P12 with the rejoinder which does disclose that the petitioner is mentally alert and physically fit, and can earn his livelihood. Only on this basis, the writ petition can be dismissed for the reason that the Original Application was dismissed on the ground that the petitioner was not indigent. It is apt to reproduce para 5 of the impugned judgment herein. “5.A conjunctive perusal of the pleadings of the parties would disclose that the authorities have carried out consideration of case of the applicant with reference to the weightage point system to assess the comparative indigent conditions of the families and against the limited number of vacancies only most deserving cases were approved for such appointment. It is not disputed that the points are allocated on the basis of various criteria viz. the number of wholly dependent family members of the deceased, unmarried daughter, remaining service of the ex-official, financial aspects of the family based on the amount of family pension, terminal benefits etc. In this case, the applicant was not found to be not in indigent condition by the Committee. In view of a transparent criteria, having been followed by the respondents in choosing the best deserving candidates out of many claimants, we do not find any fault with the process carried out by respondents in declaring the applicant as ineligible for appointment on compassionate grounds as he has not been able to make a mark as compared to other cases. “4. In the given circumstances, no interference is required. The writ petition is dismissed alongwith pending applications, if any.