Research › Browse › Judgment

Supreme Court of India · body

2019 DIGILAW 610 (SC)

Subrata Bhattacharya v. Securities And Exchange Board Of India

2019-02-12

D.Y.CHANDRACHUD, HEMANT GUPTA

body2019
ORDER 1. In pursuance of the previous order of this Court dated 8 January 2019, a report has been received from the three Member Committee chaired by Hon'ble Mr Justice R M Lodha, former Chief Justice of India. The Committee has indicated that immediately after the previous order of this Court, it held a meeting on 16 January 2019 to explore the option of engaging Asset Reconstruction Companies (ARCs) for the sale of the properties of PACL Ltd. 2. On 17 January 2019, some of the members of the Committee met with the representatives of four of the largest ARCs, based on the value of the assets acquired. During the course of the meeting, it transpired that in view of the provision of Section 10(2) of the Securitisation & Reconstruction of Financial Assets & Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (the SARFAESI Act), the prior approval of the Reserve Bank of India may be necessitated to undertake the task proposed to be assigned. Accordingly, communications were addressed to the RBI on 21 January 2019 and 29 January 2019. Following this, on 5 February 2019, RBI has stated that it is agreeable in principle to the Justice Lodha Committee engaging ARCs for the disposal of the assets of PACL Ltd. subject to the condition that they do not take the assets on their books and do not incur pecuniary liabilities. Accordingly, it has been stated that necessary permission under Section 10(2) will be communicated to the ARCs based on the submission of the Committee to this Court and the directions thereon. 3. The Committee has placed the relevant facts before the Court in its Report. The Committee has also indicated that it has considered alternative modalities for the sale of properties of PACL Ltd., including the option of engaging Resolution Professionals for the purpose of assisting it. The Committee is also looking into the possibility of involving other banks/NBFCs/financial institutions etc. and of engaging property consultants with international credentials. However, it has been indicated that these alternative modalities would require a further and detailed consideration. 4. In the above background, we authorise the Justice Lodha Committee to proceed further along the lines that the Committee has indicated in its Report dated 8 February 2019 submitted before this Court. 5. and of engaging property consultants with international credentials. However, it has been indicated that these alternative modalities would require a further and detailed consideration. 4. In the above background, we authorise the Justice Lodha Committee to proceed further along the lines that the Committee has indicated in its Report dated 8 February 2019 submitted before this Court. 5. Apart from proceeding to finalise the modalities for engaging the services of ARCs for disposal of the assets of PACL Ltd., the Committee is at liberty to explore other alternatives as well. 6. The Committee may submit a further report to this Court three months from today. In the event that any further directions of this Court are necessitated within the above period, the Committee would be at liberty to place a Report before this court through the learned counsel appearing on behalf of SEBI. 7. Sebi is permitted to place the Report of the Justice Lodha Committee dated 8 February 2019 on its website. 8. I.A. No. 65030/2017- Mr. P.S. Patwalia, learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the applicant seeks the permission of the Court to withdraw the I.A. seeking refund of moneys so as to enable the applicant to file an appropriate I.A. seeking alternative prayers. The I.A. is accordingly, dismissed as withdrawn. 9. I.A. No. 105085/2018 - Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the applicant seeks the permission of the Court to withdraw the I.A. seeking refund of moneys so as to enable the applicant to file an appropriate I.A. seeking alternative prayers. The I.A. is accordingly, dismissed as withdrawn. 10. I.A. No. 38646/2018- The present I.A. has become infructuous and is accordingly, dismissed as such. 11. I.A. No. 26147/2018, I.A. No. 75361/2017 and I.A. No. 101649/2017 List these I.As. next week.