Narendra Son Of Patiram Kurre v. State Of Chhattisgarh Through Secretary, Health And Family Welfare Department
2021-08-12
GOUTAM BHADURI
body2021
DigiLaw.ai
ORDER : 1. Heard. 2. All these matters have come up for hearing for the reason that the special mention was made on account of the fact that fresh notification has been issued by the University, whereby the off-line examination for B.Sc. Nursing, M.Sc. Nursing and Post Basic B.Sc. Nursing, is scheduled to be held from 16th of August, 2021. 3. On the earlier occasion when the examination was scheduled to be held from 6th & 10th of July, 2021 the challenge was made that the centers have been made in clusters and at that point of time since the Covid infection was at its peak, as such, without the permission of the Government off-line examination should not be held. This Court after hearing the issue on 02.07.2021 observed that since the pandemic period and lock-down was not completely relaxed and the State Government has issued a circular dated 21.04.2021, which purports that after obtaining permission from the State, the off-line examination can be held by the University and as the permission was not existing, as such this Court had deferred the examination which was scheduled to be held from 06.07.2021 & 10.07.2021. Subsequently, again a request was made by the petitioners that a general promotion be granted. This Court on 22.07.2021 had passed the following orders:- “Having considered the demand of the petitioners students that they should be promoted without taking the examination appears to be unreasonable. The work to be discharged by the petitioners is of nursing looms into view. The collective enthusiasm by the students cannot be accepted. Solving certain problem requires multi-prolonged approach and any order of like nature and directing the respondent to give general promotion to the students would amount to encroach upon academic turf by this Court and would be contrary to general expectation of society. The works the petitioners are required to discharge are directly related to individual ailing one as such if they are passed out by general promotion without any examination the scale of devastation may be horrifying in future. The demand, as appears, is not bonafide as the students only want that they should be promoted without taking the examination and that too, in the course of Nursing. Therefore, the prayer of the petitioners that general promotion should be granted is completely unjustified and illogical which cannot be acceded, hence such prayer is rejected.” 4.
The demand, as appears, is not bonafide as the students only want that they should be promoted without taking the examination and that too, in the course of Nursing. Therefore, the prayer of the petitioners that general promotion should be granted is completely unjustified and illogical which cannot be acceded, hence such prayer is rejected.” 4. Now the new schedule since has been issued it is contended that the petitioners are not hesitant to take the off-line examinations, however, the examination centers wherein cluster of colleges are made to one center may not be conducted and individual colleges may be directed to conduct the examination to avoid the probability of covid infection and large congregation. 5. The University has recently placed the notifications issued by the State on 26.07.2021.
5. The University has recently placed the notifications issued by the State on 26.07.2021. Since the notification and correspondence dated 26 th of July, 2021, would be relevant as such reproduced hereinbelow:- ^^NRrhlx<+ 'kklu mPp f'k{kk foHkkx ea=ky; egkunh Hkou] uok jk;iqj vVy uxj] & &0 & & %% vkns'k %% u;k jk;iqj vVy uxj fnukad 26@07@2021 Øekad ,Q 3&90@2020@38&1 jkT; 'kklu ,rn~}kjk] Áns'k esa mPp f'k{kk foHkkx ds v/khu lapkfyr leLr jktdh;@futh fo'ofo|ky;ksa ,oa 'kkldh;@futh egkfo|ky;ksa esa fnukad 02-08- 2021 ls fuEukuqlkj HkkSfrd :i ls f'k{k.k dk;Z ÁkjaHk djus dh vuqefr Ánku dh tkrh gS%& ¼1½ mijksDr f'k{k.k laLFkkuksa esa iksLV xzsT;q,V d{kk;sa 02 vxLr] 2021 ls vkQykbZu eksM esa ÁkjaHk dh tk,a rFkk vaMj xzsT;q,V d{kk;sa 15 fnu ds ckn pj.kc) :i ls ÁkjaHk dh tk,aA ¼2½ ;g d{kk;as mUgh ftyksa esa ÁkjaHk dh tk,a ftuesa dksjksuk dh ikftfVfoVh nj 7 fnuksa rd 1 Áfr'kr ls de gksA ¼3½ fo|kfFkZ;ksa dks d{kkvksa esa 1 fnol ds varj ij cqyk;k tk,] vFkkZr Áfrfnu dsoy vk/kh la[;k esa gh fo|kFkhZ cqyk;s tk,aA ¼4½ fdlh Hkh fo|kFkhZ dks ;fn lnhZ] [kkWlh] cq[kkj vkfn gks rks mls d{kk esa ugha cSBk;k tk,A ¼5½ vkWuykbZu d{kk;sa ;Fkkor lapkfyr dh tkrh jgsxhA ¼6½ fdlh Hkh fo|kFkhZ ds fy;s mifLFkfr vfuok;Z ugha gksxhA ¼7½ dsUnz ljdkj rFkk jkT; ljdkj }kjk le;≤ ij tkjh dksjksuk laØe.k ls cpko ds funsZ'kksa dk iw.kZr% ikyu lqfuf'pr fd;k tk,A ¼8½ lHkh f'k{k.k laLFkkvksa ds dejksa dh lkQ&lQkbZ Bhd Ádkj ls dh tk,A Nrrhlx<+ ds jkT;iky ds uke ls rFkk vns'kkuqlkj ¼,-vkj- [kku½ voj lfpo N-x- 'kklu] mPp f'k{kk foHkkx^^ 2nd Communication:- ^^dk;kZy; vk;qDr mPp f'k{kk CykWd&3] f}rh; ,oa r`rh; ry] bUnzkorh Hkou] uok jk;iqj] vVy uxj ¼N-x-½ ¼Qksu&0771&2636413 QSDl & 0771&2263412½ (E mail-highereducation.cg@gmail.com Website- www.highereducation.cg.gov.in) Øekad 1719@341@vkmf'k@leUo;@2021 uok jk;iqj vVy uxj] fnukad 26-07-2021 Áfr] 1- dqylfpo] leLr jktdh;@futh fo'ofo|ky; ¼N-x-½ 2- Ákpk;Z leLr 'kkldh;@futh egkfo|ky; Nrrhlx<+ fo"k;%& Áns'k es mPp f'k{kk foHkkx ds v/khu lapkfyr leLr jktdh;@futh fo'ofky; ,oa 'kkldh;@futh egkfo|ky;ksa esa HkkSfrd :i ls f'k{k.k dk;Z ÁkjaHk djus dh vuqefrA lanHkZ%& N-x-'kklu] mPp f'k{kk foHkkx dk vkns'k Øekad ,Q3&90@2020@38&1 fnukad 26-07-2021 mijksDr fo"k;karxZr lanfHkZr i= vkns'k ds }kjk Áns'k esa mPp f'k{kk foHkkx ds v/khu lapkfyr leLr jktdh;@futh fo'ofo|ky; ,oa 'kkldh;@futh egkfo|ky;ksa esa fnukad 02-08-2021 ls HkkSfrd :i ls f'k{k.k dk;Z ÁkjaHk djus dh vuqefr Ánku dh x;h gSA d`i;k lanfHkZr vkns'k esa fn;s x;s funsZ'kkuqlkj dk;Zokgh lqfuf'pr djus dk d"V djsaA layXu %& mDrkuqlkj ¼vk;qDr] mPp f'k{kk ds funsZ'kkuqlkj½ ¼MkW- ,p-ih- [kSjokj½ vij lapkyd mPp f'k{kk lapkyuk;y] uok jk;iqj] vVy uxj ¼N-x-½^^ 3rd Communication:- ^^Nrrhlx<+ 'kklu fpfdRlk f'k{kk foHkkx %% ea=ky; %% egkunh Hkou] uok jk;iqj] vVy uxj&492002 Øekad% ,Q 17&35@2020@ukS@55&4] uok jk;iqj] vVy uxj] fnukad 27 tqykbZ 2021 Áfr] lapkyd] fpfdRlk f'k{kk] NRrhlx<+] jk;iqjA fo"k;%& dksfoM&19 laca/kh leLr lqj{kk ÁfØ;k ,oa funsZ'kksa dk ikyu djrs gq, jkT; esa fpfdRlk f'k{kk foHkkx ds varxZr lapkfyr f'k{k.k laLFkkvksa dks 02 vxLr 2021 ls iqu% [kksyus ckcrA & & & 00& & & fpfdRlk f'k{kk foHkkx ds v/khu lapkfyr leLr 'kkldh; ,oa futh f'k{k.k laLFkkvksa dks fuEufyf[kr 'krksZa ds lkFk ÁkjaHk djus dh vuqefr Ánku dh tkrh gS%& ¼1½ fpfdRlk f'k{kk foHkkx ds varxZr lHkh 'kkldh; ,oa futh f'k{k.k laLFkkvksa esa lHkh d{kk;sa 02 vxLr] 2021 ls vkWQykbZu eksM esa ÁkjaHk dh tk,A ¼2½ fdlh Hkh fo|kFkhZ dks ;fn lnhZ] [kkaWlh] cq[kkj vkfn gks rks mls d{kk esa ugha cSBk;k tk,A ¼3½ vkWuykbZu d{kk;sa ;Fkkor lapkfyr dh tkrh jgsaxhA ¼4½ dsUnz ljdkj rFkk jkT; ljdkj }kjk le;≤ ij tkjh dksjksuk laØe.k ls cpko ds funsZ'kksa dk iw.kZr% ikyu lqfuf'pr fd;k tk,xkA ¼5½ lHkh f'k{k.k laLFkkvksa ds dejksa dh lkQ&lQkbZ Bhd Ádkj ls dh tk,A mijksDr 'krksZa dk ikyu vfuok;Z :i ls djk;k tkuk lqfuf'pr djsaA ¼jktho vfgjs½ voj lfpo NRrhlx< 'kklu fpfdRlk f'k{kk foHkkx^^ 6.
After reading such notification it shows that the University has been allowed to physical opening of all the colleges from 02.08.2021 with certain precautionary restrictions. Therefore, the permission has already been allowed by the State to conduct the off-line classes as such, I do not see any reason as to why the offline examination should be stopped only for the reason that certain clusters of colleges have been formed as examination centers. It is obvious and expected that the respondent Universities and colleges would adhere to the directions recently given by the State on 26.07.2021 to take care of all precautionary measures. Consequently, the off-line examinations which are scheduled are allowed to be held for the B.Sc. Nursing, M.Sc. Nursing and Post Basic B.Sc. Nursing courses from 16th of August, 2021 subject to strict precautionary compliance and the direction issued by the State Government. 7. With such observation, all the writ petitions stand disposed of.