JUDGMENT : 1. The Court convened through video conferencing. 2. Heard Shri Gopal Chaturvedi, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Ms. Saumya Chaturvedi, Salil Kumar Srivastava and B.M. Sahai, learned counsel for the applicant, Shri V.K. Shahi, learned Additional Advocate General assisted by Shri Prachish Pandey, learned A.G.A. for the State and Shri Shashank Singh, learned counsel for the complainant. 3. The present bail application has been filed by the applicant in F.I.R. No. 219 of 2021, under Sections 147, 148, 149, 307, 326, 427/34 I.P.C., Section 30 of Arms Act and Section 177 of M.V. Act, Police Station Tikuniya, District Lakhimpur Kheri with the prayer to enlarge him on bail. 4. As per the prosecution case, the applicant, who was in his Thar Mahindra vehicle followed by two other vehicles, came to the place of incident in high speed and killed the farmers by making indiscriminate firing. 5. On the written complaint of Jagjeet Singh s/o Hari Singh, the F.I.R. was lodged with the allegation that on 3rd October, 2021, farmers and labours of the local area were protesting peacefully at Agrasen Inter College Play Ground, Tikuniya, Kheri for showing the black flag to State Home Minister, Government of India, Mr. Ajay Mishra ‘Teny’ and Deputy Chief Minister Mr. Keshav Prasad Maurya, Government of U.P. It is further alleged in the F.I.R. that at about 3 p.m., applicant reached on the spot with 3-4 vehicle (four wheelers) along with 15-20 unknown persons armed with weapons. The applicant, who was sitting on the left side in the Thar Mahindra vehicle, started firing and the vehicle, which was moving ahead in high speed, crushed the crowd. Further allegation made in the F.I.R. is that due to fire arm injury, one Gurvinder Singh s/o Sukhvinder Singh died on the spot. Thereafter, the two vehicles including the vehicle of applicant overturned in the side ditch of the road, as a result, some pedestrians also received injuries. Thereafter, applicant run away from the spot by taking the cover of his firing. In the said incident, four farmers died, namely, Gurvinder Singh s/o Sukhvinder Singh r/o Motronia, Nanpara, Daljeet Singh s/o Hari Singh r/o Village Banjara Tanda, Nanpara, Nakshatra Singh s/o Sukkha Singh r/o Village Nandapurva Dhaurahara, Tehsil Khiri and Lavpreet Singh s/o Satnam Singh r/o Chaukhadafarm Palia Kalan, Kheri. 6. In the said incident, four farmers died, namely, Gurvinder Singh s/o Sukhvinder Singh r/o Motronia, Nanpara, Daljeet Singh s/o Hari Singh r/o Village Banjara Tanda, Nanpara, Nakshatra Singh s/o Sukkha Singh r/o Village Nandapurva Dhaurahara, Tehsil Khiri and Lavpreet Singh s/o Satnam Singh r/o Chaukhadafarm Palia Kalan, Kheri. 6. Shri Gopal Chaturvedi, learned Senior Counsel for the applicant submitted that applicant has falsely been implicated in the present case. It has further been submitted that in the ancestral village of the applicant, i.e., Banveerpur, a wrestling competition was being organised since long back and in the same tradition, on 3rd October, 2021, a wrestling competition was scheduled with a public meeting, in which, Hon’ble Deputy Chief Minister Mr. Keshav Prasad Maurya was the Chief Guest. Learned counsel for the applicant has submitted that in the name of farmers, some leaders of opposition parties, in association with anti social elements, decided to protest the visit of the Chief Guest in village Banveerpur on the ground that in the past, father of the applicant, namely, Ajay Mishra ‘Teny’, who is holding the post of State Home Minister, Government of India made some statement on the protest of the farmers in relation to some Agricultural Laws. Shri Chaturvedi further submitted that as per the decided schedule, the helicopter of the Chief Guest was to be landed at Maharaja Agrasen Play Ground Helipad, Tikuniya and thereafter, he had to go to the place of wrestling competition by road. However, without any permission, a number of protesters, who were armed with lathi and sword, gathered there along with notorious persons and encroached the entire area. 7. Submission of the learned counsel for the applicant is that incorrect description of the incident is given in the F.I.R. and as a matter of fact, three persons including the driver of the vehicle of the applicant were killed by the protesters and no such incident, as alleged, in the F.I.R. had taken place. It has vehemently been submitted by Shri Gopal Chaturvedi, learned Senior Counsel for the applicant that on being chased by the protesters, the driver of the vehicles tried to go away from there in order to save themselves, but the road was only 12 ft. widen and admittedly (in the F.I.R. itself) the protesters were standing on both sides of the road, due to which, the vehicles overturned into the ditch aside the road. widen and admittedly (in the F.I.R. itself) the protesters were standing on both sides of the road, due to which, the vehicles overturned into the ditch aside the road. It has further been submitted that one F.I.R. No. 220 of 2021, under Sections 143, 147, 148, 149, 323, 324, 336, 302, 109 I.P.C., P.S. Tikuniya, District Kheri was also lodged by Sumit Jaiswal with the allegation that on 3rd October, 2021, a wrestling competition was scheduled in the village of State Home Minister, Government of India, Ajay Mishra ‘Teny’, in which, Deputy Chief Minister Mr. Keshav Prasad Maurya, Government of U.P. had to arrive there as Chief Guest. It is further alleged in the F.I.R. that the informant along with others went to receive the Chief Guest. The informant was in the Thar vehicle, which was being driven by Hariom Mishra. However, in the way, the protesters attacked on the vehicles, in which, the driver of the Thar vehicle, namely, Hariom Mishra received head injury and he stopped the vehicle on the side of the road. Thereafter, the driver was dragged from the vehicle by the protesters. Informant-Sumit Jaiswal and others tried to run away from there to save their lives and succeeded, but Hariom Mishra and two others were caught by the protesters and later on, the informant got the information that they were killed by the protesters. 8. Shri Gopal Chaturvedi, learned Senior Counsel vehemently submitted that a belied story of firing has been concocted by the prosecution, as in the post mortem report of the body of the deceased farmers/protesters, no fire arm injury was found on their body. During the course of investigation, statement of the doctor, who conducted the autopsy of the alleged farmers, was also recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C., in which, he opined that all these injuries may be caused in a vehicle accident. Shri Chaturvedi further submitted that the applicant was called during the course of investigation and he joined and cooperated in the investigation and never misused the liberty given by the Investigating Agency. He also submitted that at the time of disposal of his bail application before the court below, incorrect facts were placed by the prosecution that the applicant is having criminal antecedent of two cases. He also submitted that at the time of disposal of his bail application before the court below, incorrect facts were placed by the prosecution that the applicant is having criminal antecedent of two cases. However, the applicant was implicated in one case, i.e., Case Crime No. 92 of 2005, under Sections 147, 323, 504, 506, 452 I.P.C., P.S. Tikuniya, District Kheri, in which, he has been acquitted by the trial court vide judgment and order dated 24.03.2018 passed in Criminal Case No. 1497 of 2017 (State Vs. Ashish Mishra @ Monu). (Copy of the judgment is annexed as Annexure No. 3 with the bail application). The applicant has no knowledge about the another case. Shri Chaturvedi emphasised that though as per the prosecution case itself, after the said incident, the applicant run away by making fires, but admittedly there is no such fire injury on any person. Learned counsel for the applicant vehemently submitted that the protesters brutally killed three persons, namely, Hariom Mishra, Shubham Mishra and Shyam Sunder, those were in the Thar vehicle. Learned counsel for the applicant next submitted that as per the admitted case of the prosecution, the vehicle was being driven by Hariom Mishra and the applicant was sitting on the left side and, therefore, the case of prosecution of crushing the protesters by the applicant is improbable. 9. Learned counsel for the applicant, thus, submitted that the applicant, who is in jail since 10.10.2021, is entitled for bail. It has also been submitted that the applicant is ready to cooperate in the trial and he will not misuse the liberty, in case, he is enlarged on bail. 10. Learned A.A.G. as well as learned counsel for the complainant vehemently opposed the prayer of the applicant. 11. Shri V.K. Shahi, learned A.A.G. relying on the contents of the counter affidavit, submitted that under the direction of the Hon’ble Supreme Court passed in Writ Petition (Criminal) No. 426 of 2021, investigation of the case in question as well as F.I.R. No. 220 of 2021 was conducted by the SIT under the monitoring of Justice (Retd.) Rakesh Kumar Jain, Hon’ble Judge, Punjab & Haryana High Court and supervised by S.B. Shiradkar ADG, Intelligence Headquarter, Nanded, Maharashtra with the members (1) Ms. Padmja Chauhan IG, IPS, (2) Dr. Preetinder Singh, DIG, IPS. Padmja Chauhan IG, IPS, (2) Dr. Preetinder Singh, DIG, IPS. Learned A.A.G. further submitted that in the said incident, by the vehicle of the applicant and his followers, protesters were dashed and following five persons, namely, Nakshatra Singh, Daljeet Singh, Lavpreet Singh, Gurvinder Singh and Raman Kashyap died and 13 other persons received injuries. Learned A.A.G. also submitted that all the injured persons were interrogated during the course of investigation and their statements were recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C. The statements of other eye witnesses were also recorded and they supported the prosecution version. He further submitted that statement under Section 164 Cr.P.C. was also recorded of few of the witnesses and all the witnesses of fact supported the prosecution version and stated that applicant came on the spot with his vehicle followed by other vehicles in high speed and crushed the protesters. Thereafter, he run away by firing. Learned A.A.G. also submitted that the statements of the doctors, who conducted the autopsy of the body of the deceased persons as well as medico legal examination of injured persons, were also recorded, in which, all of them stated that injuries found on the body of the deceased persons may have been caused by hitting from a vehicle. Shri Shahi also submitted that in the video clip, it is also found that vehicles are reaching on the spot. It is, thus, submitted that the applicant is not entitled for bail. 12. Shri Shashank Singh, learned counsel for the complainant, while supporting the arguments of the learned A.A.G., submitted that the applicant deliberately came to the place of protesters with the vehicle only with the intention to give lesson to them as due to their protest at the helipad, District Administration was compelled to change the route of the Chief Guest. Learned counsel for the complainant vehemently submitted that the weapons of the accused persons were also sent to the FSL, in which, it was found that weapons were used. He lastly submitted that in the incident, involvement of 17 persons was found along with the applicant, out of which, three persons, namely, Hariom Mishra, Subham Mishra and Shyam Sunder were killed by the crowd of the protesters and after detail investigation, charge sheet has been submitted against rest of the 14 persons including the applicant. It is, thus, submitted that the bail application is liable to be rejected. 13. It is, thus, submitted that the bail application is liable to be rejected. 13. I have considered the arguments advanced by the learned counsel for the applicant, learned A.A.G. for the State and the learned counsel for the complainant as well as gone through the bail application, counter and rejoinder affidavits along with other relevant documents appended with the bail application, as also the entire case diary of F.I.R. No. 219 of 2021 and F.I.R. No. 220 of 2021. 14. It is evident that a wrestling competition was scheduled on 3rd October, 2021 in village Banveerpur and the Deputy Chief Minister, Mr. Keshav Prasad Maurya was the Chief Guest of the said competition. It is further evident from the record that a public notice was published by Harnam Singh Verma, D.P. Singh, Tajinder Singh Virk, Guramneet Singh Mangat, Pinder Singh Siddhu, Richa Singh, Pushpraj Yadav and Pawan Kashyap inviting the farmers of District Kheri and nearby districts, including Sitapur, Saharanpur, Bareilly, Bahraich to reach at Agrasen Play Ground, Tikuniya, District Kheri on 3rd October, 2021 for showing black flag in the protest of the statement of State Home Minister, Government of India, Mr. Ajay Mishra ‘Teny’ against the farmers. It is also evident from the statements of the witnesses recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C. that about thousands of protesters gathered at the fixed place around the helipad covering both sides of the road. Due to the said gathering of the protesters, District Administration changed the route of the Chief Guest and decided not to get the helicopter of the Chief Guest landed at the helipad at Agrasen Play Ground, Tikuniya. As per the prosecution case, applicant along with 15-20 persons armed with firearm weapons etc., reached on the spot with the intention to teach lesson to the protesters. The case of the prosecution is that on the direction of the applicant, the protesters were crushed by Thar vehicle and thereafter, the vehicle was uncontrolled and overturned into a ditch aside the road. The rest of the vehicles, which were following the vehicle of the applicant, also overturned into ditch aside the road. Thereafter, applicant started indiscriminate firing and run away from the spot. 15. The rest of the vehicles, which were following the vehicle of the applicant, also overturned into ditch aside the road. Thereafter, applicant started indiscriminate firing and run away from the spot. 15. During the course of investigation, statement of witnesses was recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C., in which, they stated that the applicant was sitting in the Thar vehicle and he was directing to his driver to crush the protesters, on which, the driver hit the protesters by the aforesaid vehicle. Thereafter, the vehicle stopped on the left side of the road and another Fortuner vehicle, which was following the Thar vehicle also stopped, as one bus was parked over there. Thereafter, applicant run away by making fire. 16. However, from the inquest report as well as injury report of the injured persons, it is evident that no fire arm injury was found on anyone, rather the post mortem report as well as injury report clearly reveal that it is a case of accident by hitting with the vehicle. Moreover, it is highly surprising that in the site plan prepared by the Investigating Officer, the place where the bus was standing, is not shown. 17. During the course of investigation, statements of doctors, who conducted the post mortem of the deceased, Lavpreet, Gurvinder Singh, Nakshatra Singh and Raman Kashyap were recorded. On being asked the specific question by the Investigating Officer that whether any firearm injury was found on the body of the deceased persons, the doctors denied. The doctors stated that the injuries found on the body of the deceased persons could be caused by hitting from the vehicle. Statements of Dr. On being asked the specific question by the Investigating Officer that whether any firearm injury was found on the body of the deceased persons, the doctors denied. The doctors stated that the injuries found on the body of the deceased persons could be caused by hitting from the vehicle. Statements of Dr. K.K. Ranjan recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C., who conducted the autopsy of the body of Lavpreet Singh and Gurvinder Singh, are as under: ^^eq0 v0 la0 219@2021 Fkkuk frdqfu;ka tuin&[khjhA fnukad % 28-10-2021 dFku Mk0 ds0 ds0 jatu iq= Jh ih jke dk;Zjr@fu;qfDr ftyk efgyk fpfdRlky; tuin [khjh eks0 ua0& 9415359113 lEcfU/kr eq0 v0 la0 219@2021 /kkjk 147@148@149@279@338@304,@302@120ch Hkknfo Fkkuk frdqfu;ka tuin & [khjh] vUrZxr /kkjk 161 na0 iz0 la0] LFkku& Økbe czkUp fjtoZ iqfyl ykbUl tuin [khjhA us iwNus ij c;ku fd;k fd vkius esjs }kjk gLrk{kfjr fd;k gqvk ih0,e0 fjiksVZ fn[kk;k gS rks eSa mls ns[kdj c;ku vafdr djk jgk gawA fnukad 04-10-2021 dks iksLVekVZEk gkml [khjh ij esjh fM~;wVh yxh Fkh eq[; fpfdRlkf/kdkjh egksn; }kjk iksLVekVZe gsrq iSuy dk xBu fd;k x;k Fkk ftlesa fd esjs lkFk iSuy esa Mk0 vrqy dqekj f}osnh vkFkksZiSfMd ltZu ftyk fpfdRlky; y[kheiqj [khjh] Mk0 lrh'k dqekj tujy ltZu ftyk fpfdRlky; y[kheiqj [khjh FksA esjh Vhe }kjk e`rd yoizhr flag mez 19 o"kZ iq= Jh lruke flag fuoklh pkS[kM+k QkeZ Fkkuk ify;kdyk tuin [khjh dk 'ko foPNsnu dj ih,evkj la0&1091@2021 fjiksVZ rS;kj dh tks fd esjs gLrys[k esa gS rFkk ftl ij iSuy ds vU; nksuks MkDVjksa ds gLrk{kj ftls eSa Hkyh Hkkafr tkurk igpkurk gwaA ih0,e0 fjiksVZ dk fooj.k fUkEuor gSA 1- Abrased contusion 4 X 4 cm over top of Lt. shoulder. 2- Multiple Abrased contusion 10 X 8 cm over Lt. side of forehead and face. 3- Multiple Abrased contusion 25 X 6 cm over Rt. elbow, forearm, wrist and palm. 4- Abrased contusion - 6 X 5 cm over top of Rt. shoulder. 5- Abrased contusion - 3 X 2 cm over front of nose. 6- Multiple Abrased contusion - 40 X 30 cm both side of chest and abdomen. On dissection underlying all ribs of both side found fractured, both plura, Both lung, liver found lacerated and 2 lit clotted and fluid blood present in chest and abdominal cavity. 7- Abrased contusion-6 cm X 4 cm over front of Rt. knee. 8- Multiple Abrased contusion - 15 X 8 cm over front of Lt. palm. On dissection underlying all ribs of both side found fractured, both plura, Both lung, liver found lacerated and 2 lit clotted and fluid blood present in chest and abdominal cavity. 7- Abrased contusion-6 cm X 4 cm over front of Rt. knee. 8- Multiple Abrased contusion - 15 X 8 cm over front of Lt. palm. e`R;q dk dkj.k@izdkj & esjh Vhe ds Kku vkSj fu"d"kZ ds vk/kkj ij e`R;q dk dkj.k& death is due to shock and haemorrhage as a result of anti mortem injuries. iz'u& dkSu lh pksVs ckg~; gS vkSj dkSu lh pksVs vkUrfjd gSA mRRkj& pksV ua0&06 vkUrfjd pksVs gS vU; lHkh ckg~; gSA iz'u& mDr ih0,e0 fjiksVZ esa vafdr pksVsa fdl izdkj dh gSA mRRkj& 'kjhj esa lk/kkj.k o xEHkhj nksuks izd`fr dh pksVs gSA iz'u%& D;k bl izdkj dh pksVs fdlh okgu dh VDdj@dqpyus ls vkuk lEHko gSA mRrj& gk¡ fcYdqy laHko gSA iz'u%& D;k ih,e fjiksVZ esa fdlh /kkjnkj gfFk;kj o Qk;j vkeZ dh pksV ik;h x;h gSA mRrj& ughaA blds vfrfjDr crk;k fd esjs o esjs bUgh nks MkDVjks }kjk e`rd xqjfoUnj flag mez 18 o"kZ iq= lq[kfoUnj flag fuoklh xzke eksgjfu;ka Fkkuk eVsjk tuin cgjkbp dk 'ko foPNsnu dj ih,evkj la0 1092@2021 fjiksVZ rS;kj dh tks fd esjs gLrys[k esa gS rFkk ftl ij iSu ds vU; nksuks MkDVjks ds gLrk{kj ftls eSa HkYkh Hkkafr tkurk igpkurk g¡wA ih,e fjiksVZ dk fooj.k fuEuor gSa Antimortem Injuries 1- LW 5 cm x 3 cm x bone deep on Rt side of head 1 cm above Rt ear 2- LW 6 cm x 3 cm x bone deep over mid of forehead 4 cm above root of nose underlying frontal bone found cut. 3- LW 3 cm x 1 cm x bone deep over Lt eyebrow. 4- LW 3 cm x 2 cm x bone deep over Lt side of face just below Lt eye. 5- LW 2 cm x 0.5 cm x bone deep over Rt eyebrow. 6- Abrased contusion 15 cm x 10 cm over front of Lt mid arm underlying Lt humerous bone found fractured. 7- LW 1 cm x 1 cm muscle deep over front of Lt arm just above injury no. 5- LW 2 cm x 0.5 cm x bone deep over Rt eyebrow. 6- Abrased contusion 15 cm x 10 cm over front of Lt mid arm underlying Lt humerous bone found fractured. 7- LW 1 cm x 1 cm muscle deep over front of Lt arm just above injury no. 6 8- Abrased contusion 40 cm x 60 cm over front of chest and abdomen on dissection underlying all ribs both side found fractured, both pleura, both lungs, peritoneum, liver found lacerated and 1.5 lit clotted & fluid blood present is chest and abdominal cavity. 9- Abrased contusion 6 cm x 4 cm over back of Lt hand. 10- Abrased contusion 45 cm x 20 cm over Rt thigh, knee & leg underlying Lt femur bone found fractured 12- Abrased conceded 60 cm x 40 cm over back of chest, abdomen and both shoulder e`R;q dk dkj.k@izdkj esjh Vhe ds Kku vkSj fu"d"kZ ds vk/kkj ij e`R;q dk dkj.k death is due to shock and hemorrhage as a result of anti mortem injuries. iz'u& mDr ih,e fjiksZV esa vafdr pksVsa fdl izdkj dh gSA mRrj& 'kjhj esa lk/kkj.k o xEHkhj nksuks izd`fr dh pksVs gSA iz'u& D;k bl izdkj dh pksVs fdlh okgu dh VDdj@dqpyus ls vkuk lEHko gSA mRrj& gk¡] fcYdqy lEHko gSA iz'u& D;k ih,e fjiksVZ esa fdlh /kkjnkj oLrq dh pksV gSA mRrj& gk¡ batjh ua0 02 o 05 iz'u& D;k ih,e fjiksVZ esa Qk;j vkeZ ls pksV vkuk ik;k x;k gSA mRrj& ughaA** 18. Statement of Dr. Statement of Dr. Santosh Kumar Mishra, who conducted the autopsy of the body of Nakshatra Singh and Daljeet Singh, is as under : ^^eqŒvŒlaŒ 219@2021@Fkkuk frdqfu;k tuin [khjh fnukad 28-10-2021 dFku MkŒ Jh larks"k dqekj feJk iq= LoŒ Jh f'ko'kadj yky feJ fu;qfDr fu'psrd ftyk fpfdRlky; y[kheiqj [khjh eksŒ uEcj 9451403251 lEcfU/kr eqŒvŒlaŒ 219@2021 /kkjk 147@148@149@279@338@304,@302@120ch HkkŒnaŒfoŒ Fkkuk frdqfu;k tuin [khjh vUrxZr /kkjk 161 naŒÁŒlaŒ LFkku dzkbe czkUp fjtoZ iqfyl ykbUl tuin [khjh dFku & us iwNus ij c;ku fd;k fd vkius esjs }kjk gLrk{kfjr fd;k gqvk ih,e fjiksVZ fn[kk;k gS rks eSa mls ns[kdj c;ku vafdr djk jgk gwa fnukad 04-10-2021 dks eSa fu'psrd ds in ij ftyk fpfdRlky; y[kheiqj [khjh esa dk;Zjr Fkk esjs lkFk MkŒ jkts'k flag cky jksx fo'ks"kK ftyk fpfdRlky; y[kheiqj [khjh rFkk MkŒ jk?kosUæ Árki oekZ cky jksx fo'ks"kK ftyk fpfdRlky; y[kheiqj [khjh iSuy esa mifLFkr FksA mlh fnu lhŒihŒ prj flag Fkkuk frdqfu;ka ftyk [khjh }kjk e`rd u{k= flag iq= Jh lq[kk flag xzke ukunkiqjok etjk vesBh Fkkuk /kkSjgjk ftyk [khjh }kjk 'kke 03-40 feuV ij e`rd u{k= flag dk 'ko ih,e uEcj 1089@2021 diM+s esa lhy ekMZu ih,e gkml y[kheiqj [khjh esa gekjs le{k 'ko foPNsnu gsrq yk;k x;k 'ko dh igpku lhih prj flag }kjk dh x;h lhy dk feyku djus ij lgh ik;s tkus ds i'pkr 'ko foPNsnu 'kke 3-45 ij 'kq: fd;k x;k rFkk 04-25 ihŒ,eŒ ij lekIr fd;k x;k e`rd dh ÅapkbZ 170 lseh vkSlr dn dkBh dk Fkk e`rd ds diM+s ,d iSUV] usdj] ekstk@dqrkZ@cfu;ku@:eky rFkk ixMh FkhA e`R;q iwoZ vdM+u 'kjhj ds Åijh Hkkx ls fudy jgh Fkh ,oa uhps ds vaxks esa ekStwn Fks 'kjhj ds fiNys Hkkx esa ih,e LVSfuax ik;h x;h e`rd ds diM+ks ij lw[kk FkDdsnkj jDr dqN txgks ij ekStwn ik;k x;kA e`rd ij ik;h x;h pksVks dk fooj.k%& 1- [kjkl fy;s gq;s uhyxw fu'kku 08 lseh Xkq.kk 06 lseh cka;s da/ks ds fiNys Hkkx esaA 2- [kjkl fy;s gq;s uhyxw fu'kku 08 lseh xq.kk 04 lseh psgjs ds nkfguh rjQ vka[k ds uhps 3- QVk gqvk ?kko 02 lseh xq.kk 01 lseh xq.kk gMMh rd xgjk ukd ds nkfguh rjQ&foPNsnu ds mijkUr ukd dh gMMh VwVh gq;h ik;h x;hA 4- QVk gqvk ?kko 03 lseh xq.kk 02 lseh xq.kk gMMh rd xgjk lj ds cka;h rjQ dku ds 02 lseh ihNsA 5- QVk gqvk ?kko 04 lseh xq.kk 02 lseh xq.kk gMMh rd xgjk lj ds fiNys fgLls esaA 6- [kjkl fy;s gq;s uhyxw fu'kku 50 lseh xq.kk 40 lseh isV ,oa lhus ds vxz Hkkx esa&foPNsnu mijkUr lHkh ilfy;ka nksuks rjQ dh VwVh gq;h feyh nksuks QsQM+s mudh f>Yyh] isfjVksfu;e ,oa ;d`r QVs gq;s ik;s x;sA lhus ,oa isV dh xqgk esa 02 yh jDr FkDdsnkj [kwu ekStwn FkkA 7- QVk gqvk ?kko 08 lseh xq.kk 04 lseh xq.kk gMMh rd xgjk cka;h fupyh Vkax ,ady TokbUV ls 06 lseh Åij&foPNsnu mijkUr Vhfc;k ,oa fQcqyk gMMh VwVh gq;h ik;h x;hA 8- QVk gqvk ?kko 03 lseh xq.kk 03 lseh xq.kk gMMh rd xgjk nkfguh dksguh ds fiNys Hkkx esaA 9- [kjkl fy;s gq;s uhyxw fu'kku 10 lseh xq.kk 06 lseh nkfguh dksguh rFkk vxz Hkqtk ds fiNys HkkxA 10- [kjkl fy;s gq;s uhyxw fu'kku 08 lseh xq.kk 04 lseh nkfgus dqYgs ds Åijh HkkxA esjh jk; esa e`R;q dk le; yxHkx 01 fnu gS rFkk e`R;w dk dkj.k 'kkWd ,aM gsesjst tks fd ,aVh ekVZe batjh ds dkj.k gSA Á'u & mDr ih,e fjiksVZ esa vafdr pksVsa fdl Ádkj dh gSA mRrj & 'kjhj esa lk/kkj.k o xEHkhj nksuks Ád`fr dh pksVs gSA Á'u & D;k ;g pksVs fdlh xkMh ds 'kjhj ds Åij xqtjus ls vkuk laHko gSA mRrj & gka] ,slk gks ldrk gSA Á'u & mDr ih,e fjiksVZ esa dksbZ Qk;j batjh ls pksV vkuk ik;k x;k gSA mRrj & ugh blds vfrfjDr esjs o esjs nks bUgh MkDVjksa }kjk e`rd nythr ds 'ko dk 'ko foPNsnu ih,e uEcj 1090@21 ij fd;k x;k FkkA e`R;q iwoZ vdMu 'kjhj ds Åij ,oa uhps ds vaxks esa ekStwn Fks 'kjhj ds fiNys Hkkx esa ih,e LVSfuax ik;h x;h e`rd ds diM+ks ij lw[kk FkDdsnkj jDr dqN txgks ij ekStwn ik;k x;kA e`rd ij ik;h x;h pksVks dk fooj.k%& 1- QVk gqvk ?kko 01 lseh xq.kk 0-5 lseh fupys gksB ds e/; HkkxA 2- QVk ?kko 03 lseh xq.kk 01 lseh xq.kk gM~Mh rd xgjk flj ds ck;h rjQ dku ls 07 lseh ÅijA 3- fuyxw fu'kku 08 lseh xq.kk 06 lseh flj ds fiNys Hkkx esa&foPNsnu ds mijkUr vkDlhfiVy gM~Mh VwVh gq;h feyh rFkk esEcjsu vkSj efLr"d ds Åijh lrg ij [kwu ds FkDds ekStwn feysA 4- [kjkl fy;s gq;s uhyxw fu'kku 50 lseh xq.kk 30 lseh flus ,oa isV ds vxz Hkkx esa & foPNsnu ds mijkUr nksuks rjQ dh lHkh ilfy;ka VwVh ik;h x;h nksuks QsQM+s muds Åij dh f>Yyh] isfjVksfu;e] ;d`r QVs gq;s ik;s x;sA isV ,oa lhus dh xqgk esa nks yhVj jDr FkDdk ,oa rjy [kwu ekStwn FkkA 5- [kjkl fy;s gq;s uhyxw fu'kku 30 lseh xq.kk 10 lseh cka;h vxz Hkqtk ls ysdj dksguh rdA 6- [kjkl fy;s gq;s uhyxw fu'kku 15 lseh cka;s da/ks ds fiNys HkkxA 7- cgqr lkjs [kjkl fy;s gq;s uhyxw fu'kku 55 lseh xq.kk 15 lseh nkfgus gkFk ds Åij ls ysdj uhps rdA 8- [kjkl fy;s gq;s uhyxw fu'kku 36 lseh xq.kk 20 lseh cka;h rjQ Nkrh ds fiNys HkkxA esjh jk; esa e`R;q dk le; yxHkx 01 fnu gS rFkk e`R;q dk dkj.k 'kkWd ,aM gsesjst tks fd ,aVh ekVZe batjh ds dkj.k gSA Á'u & mDr ih,e fjiksVZ esa vafdr pksVsa fdl Ádkj dh gSA mRrj & 'kjhj eas lk/kkj.k o xEHkhj nksuks Ád`fr dh pksVs gSA Á'u & D;k bl Ádkj dh pksVs fdlh okgu dh VDdj@dqpyus ls vkuk laHko gSA mRrj & gka] fcYdqy laHko gSA** 19. Statement of Dr. Statement of Dr. K.P. Singh, who conducted the autopsy of the body of Raman Kashyap, is as under : ^^eqŒvŒlaŒ 219@2021 Fkkuk frdqfu;k tuin [khjh c;ku MkŒ dsŒihŒ flag iq= Jh uUgw flag fuoklh 103 jkeiqj jksM fo/kkSfy;k osLV ,oa dkyksuh ftyk cjsyh gky irk ftyk fpfdRlky; tuin [khjh ekŒ 9412377198 vk/kkj dkMZ uEcj 299111467546 lEcfU/kr eqŒvŒlaŒ 219@2021 /kkjk 147@148@149@279@338@304,@302@120ch HkkŒnaŒfoŒ Fkkuk frdqfu;ka tuin [khjh vUrxZr /kkjk 161 naŒÁŒlaŒ LFkku dzkbe czkUp fjtoZ iqfyl ykbUl tuin [khjh us iwNus ij crk;k fd fnukad 04-10-2021 le; 5-00 ,Œ,eŒ ij ftyk vf/kdkjh tuin [khjh ds vkns'kkuqlkj jkr esa d`f=e i;kZIr Ádk'k esa ekMuZ ihŒ,eŒ gkml esa rhu MkDVjksa ds iSuy }kjk e`rd jeu d';i iq= jkenqykjs fuoklh fu?kklu tuin [khjh dk iksLVekVZe fd;k x;k o iksLV ekVZe dh fofM;ksxzkQh eksŒ vkjhQ egcwc LVwfM;ks [khjh }kjk djk;h x;hA ftuesa esjs vykok MkŒ jktdqekj dksyh Jh chŒ,yŒ dksyh fuoklh 776 foyk ,YMhdks flVh vkbZŒvkbZŒ,eŒ jksM y[kuÅ o MkŒ jktdqekj iq= Jh gfjjke oekZ fuoklh 2@894 lsDVj ,p tkudkjhiqje y[kuÅ }kjk fd;k x;kA 'ko dks ykus ,oa igpku djus okys iqfyl dehZ dk uke vkj{kh jksfgr dqekj Fkkuk dksrokyh lnj ftyk [khjh }kjk yk;k x;k FkkA ftudh f'kuk[r vkj{kh jksfgr dqekj vkSj e`rd ds firk jkenqykjs us dhA e`rd jeu d';i vLirky esa fnukad 03-10-2021 dks le; 9-55 ihŒ,eŒ ij e`r voLFkk esa yk;k x;k FkkA e`rd dh ÅapkbZ 166 lsŒehŒ cukoV eksVh] dkBh vkSlru e`rd }kjk igus x;s oL=ksa esa ,d 'kVZ] ,d cfu;ku] ,d iS.V] ,d p<~Mh] ,d vaMjfo;j] ,d dM+k FkkA e`rd dh jk;xj ekfVZl ¼e`R;q i'pkr~ vdM+u½ nksuks iSjksa vkSj nksuksa gkFkksa esa mifLFkfrA ihŒ,eŒ LVsfuax ¼ihB esa½ ÁstsUV FkhA rFkk diM+s o 'kjhj ij dqN txgks ij [kwu yxk gqvk FkkA e`rd ds 'kjhj esa mifLFkr pksVs ¼,UVhekVZe batjh½ esa 1&,czsMsM daV~;wtu lkbt 25 xq.kk 15 lsŒehŒ nksuks rjQ psgjs o ekFks ijA 2&,cszMsM daV~;wtu lkbt 10 xq.kk 06 lsŒehŒ nkfgus da/ks ijA 3&,cszMsM daV~;wtu 50 xq.kk 15 lsŒehŒ nkfguh Hkqtk] vxz Hkqtk] dksfguh vkSj gkFk ds ihNs dh vksjA 4&ysfljsVsM ?kko&3 xq.kk 3 lsŒehŒ gM~Mh rd xgjk ¼cksu Mhi½ nkfgus dykbZ ds ihNsA 5&,cszMsM daV~;wtu& 15 xq.kk 06 lsŒehŒ ckbZ dykbZ vkSj gkFk ds ihNsA 06&,cszMsM daV~;wtu 40 xq.kk 30 lsŒehŒ Nkrh dh vkxs dh vksj vkSj isV dh vkxs dh vksjA ?kko dks [kksyus ij lHkh ilfy;ak nksuks rjQ dh VwVh gqbZ FkhA frYyh] fyoj nksuks QsQM+s ,oa mlds Åij dh f>Yyh vkSj isV dh f>Yyh QVh gqbZ Fkh vkSj yxHkx Ms<+ yhVj tek ¼DykVsM½ o iryk [kwu Nkrh vkSj isV esa ekStwn FkkA 7&cgqr lkjs daV~;wtu lkbt 35 xq.kk 30 lsŒehŒ ds nk;js esa Nkrh ds ihNs ekStwn FksA vek'k; [kksyus ij 100 xzke isLVh eSVsfj;y ekStwn FkkA e`rd dh e`R;q dk laHkkfor le; yxHkx vk/kk fnu vkSj e`R;q dk dkj.k 'kkWd o jDrL=ko Fkh tks e`R;q ds iwoZ vkbZ pksVksa ds dkj.k FkhA gekjs iSuy dh jk; ;g gS fd e`rd ds 'kjhj ij vkbZ lHkh pksVs fdlh Hkkjh pht ds 'kjhj ds Åij ls xqtjus dh otg ls vk ldrh gSA ÁŒ & D;k e`rd ds 'kjhj ij vk;h pksVksa ls gqbZ e`R;q okgu ds dqpyus ¼thi@dkj½ ls gks ldrh gS\ mŒ & gka] laHko gSA ÁŒ & D;k e`rd ds 'kjhj ij dksbZ Qk;j batjh ;k fdlh /kkjnkj gfFk;kj ls pksV gksuk ik;k x;k FkkA mŒ & ugha] ,slh dksbZ pksV ugha FkhA ÁŒ & D;k e`rd dks ekjus&ihVus dh Hkh dksbZ pksVsa gS\ mŒ & th ughaA** 20. Apart from the above, it is also evident from the record that cross case bearing F.I.R. No. 220 of 2021 was also registered by one Sumit Jaiswal with the allegation of attack by the protesters and killing of Hariom Mishra, Shubham Mishra and Shyam Sunder by protesters. However, surprisingly this fact is not mentioned in F.I.R. No. 219 of 2021. Moreover, the Investigating Officer of F.I.R. No. 219 of 2021 has not disclosed the place where the bodies of aforesaid three persons were lying, in the site plan. As per the post mortem reports of Hariom Mishra (driver of Thar vehicle), Shubham Mishra and Shyam Sunder (those were in the vehicle in question), they died due to ante mortem injuries found on their bodies. Statements of the doctors were recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C. in the cross case also, in which, they stated that cause of death of the said three persons are due to ante mortem injuries received by hard and blunt object. 21. Statement of Dr. Statements of the doctors were recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C. in the cross case also, in which, they stated that cause of death of the said three persons are due to ante mortem injuries received by hard and blunt object. 21. Statement of Dr. Rajkumar Koli (one of the member of the panel conducted the post mortem of said three persons) recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C. is as under:- ^^eq0 v0 la0 220@2021 /kkjk 143@109@147@148@149@323@324@336@302 Hkknfo Fkkuk frdqfu;ka tuin & [khjhA LFkku& dzkbe czkUp fjtoZ iqfyl ykbUl tuin [khjhA fnukad % 28-10-2021 dFku%& Mk0 jktdqekj dksyh iq= oh0,u dksyh fuoklh 776 foyk ,fYMdk flVh vkbZvkbZ,e jksM y[kuÅ gky irk ftyk fpfdRlky; [khjh eks0ua0 8299612640 vk/kkj dkMZ ua0600289026791 us iwNus ij crk;k fd fnukad 04-10-2021 le; 2-05 feuV ,-,e- ij ftykf/kdkjh tuin [khjh ds vkns'kkuqlkj jkr esa d`f=e i;kZIr izdk'k esa ekMZu ih,e gkml esa rhu MkDVjks ds iSuy }kjk e`rd 'kqHke feJk iq= Jh fot; feJk mez 26 o"kZ fuoklh xzke f'koiqjh vfXugks=h uxj [khjh dk iksLVekVZe ohfM;ksxzkQh dh mifLFkfr eas ohfM;ksxzkQj eks0 vkfjQ egcwc LVwfM;ks [khjh }kjk djk;h x;h ftles esjs vykok Mk0 ds0ih0 flag iq= Jh uUgw flg fuoklh 103 jkeiqj jksM fc/kkSfy;k osLV ,.M dkyksuh ftyk cjsyh gky irk ftyk fpfdRlky; tuin [khjh o Mk0 jktdqekj iq= Jh gfjjke oekZ fuoklh 02@894 lsVj ,p tkudhiqje y[kuÅ }kjk fd;k x;k 'ko dks ykus okys dk uke lhih vafdr pkSgku Fkkuk dksrokyh lnj ftyk [khjh o f'kuk[r djus okys dk uke lhih vafdr pkSgku rFkk vuwi feJk ¼pkpk½ us igpku dh e`rd 'kqHke feJk ftyk vLirky esa fnukad 03-10-2021 dks jkf= 9-50 ih-,e- ij yk;s x;s FksA e`rd dh ÅapkbZ 169 lseh cukoV e/;e vkSlru e`rd }kjk igus x;s oL=ksa esa ,d 'kVZ] ,d iSUV] ,d pMढh] ,d dykok] LVhy dM+k jk[kh /kkxk ,d] CySd /kkxk fon ykdsV ,d] e`R;w ds i'pkr vdM+u dh mifLFkfr Åijh vkSj fupyh nksuks Nksjks esa mifLFkr Fkh ih,e LVSfuax ihB esa mifLFkr Fkh lw[kk CyM diM+s vkSj 'kjhj ds dqN LFkkuks esa yxk gqvk Fkk e`rd ds 'kjhj esa mifLFkr pksVs ¼,aVhekVZe batjh½ &&& 1- QVk gqvk ?kko 04 xq.kk 01 lseh xgjkbZ gMMh rd cka;s rjQ ekFks ij rhu lseh cka;h HkkSa ls Åij ?kko dks [kksyus ij ?kko ds uhps QzUVy cksu ¼ekFks dh gM~Mh½ VwVh gq;h Fkh efLr"d f>Yyh ,oa efLr"d QVk gqvk FkkA tek gqvk [kwu efLr"d f>Yyh ds Åij ekStwn FkkA 2- QVk gqvk ?kko 02 xq.kk 01 lseh xgjkbZ gM~Mh rd cka;h vkbZczks ij ekStwn 3- ,cjsMsM daVh;wtu 30 xq.kk 15 lseh psgjs ds nksuks rjQ ekStwn] ekFks ds vxys fljs ij [kksiMh ds Åijh vkSj fupys tcM+s dks [kksyus ij nksuks rjQ ds VsEiksjy vkSj iSjkbZVy cksu ¼nksuks rjQ dku ds Åij dh gM~Mh o [kksiM+h ds nksuks rjQ fdukjs dh gM~Mh½ VwVh gq;h ik;h x;hA rFkk tek gqvk [kwu efLr"d dh f>Yyh ,.M efLr"d ds Åij ik;k x;kA 4- uhyxw pksV 15 xq.kk 10 lseh cka;s da/ks ds Åij ¼cgqr lkjs ,cjsMM daV~;w'ku 60 xq.kk 10 lseh ysQ~V vkeZ] vxze Hkqtk vkSj gkFk ds ihNs dh vksj ftlesa lcls cM+k daVh;wtu 15 xq.kk 03 lseh vkSj lcls NksVk 6 xq.kk 3 lseh 5- cgqr lkjs uhyxw fu'kku 60 xq.kk 15 lseh ds nk;js esa nkfgus da/ks] Hkqtk vfxze Hkqtk vkSj gkFk ds ihNs ftles lcls cM+h 10 xq.kk 2 lseh o lcls NksVh 05 xq.kk 2 lseh 6- cgqr lkjs uhyxw fu'kku 60 xq.kk 40 lsaeh Nkrh ds ihNs vkSj isV ij ?kko dks [kksyus ij ,d ls nl rd dh ilfy;ka VwVh gq;h ik;h x;hA nksuks rjQ dh QsQM+s ds Åij dh f>Yyh nksuks QsQM+s QVs gq;s ik;s x;s vkSj yxHkx ,d yhVj tek ¼DykVsM½ ,oa rjy [kwu Nkrh esa ik;k x;kA 7- cgqr lkjs uhyxw pksVs 13 xq.kk 10 lseh ds nk;js esa cka;s iSj vkSj ?kqVus ds vxz Hkkx esa 8- QVk gqvk ?kko 3 xq.kk 1 lseh xgjkbZ gMMh rd cka;s iSj ds e/; esa vxys fgLls esa 9- lqij fQf'k;y cuZ 15 xq.kk 10 lseh cka;s tka?k vkSj Vkax ds vUnj okys fgLls esa 10- lqij fQf'k;y cuZ 25 xq.kk 10 lseh vkSj nkfguh Vkax ds Åij 05 lseh ?kqVus ls uhps 11- lqij fQf'k;y cuZ 25 xq.kk 10 lseh isV ds fupys fgLls ij ukHkh ls 05 lseh uhps 12- uhyxw pksV 10 xq.kk 04 lseh nkfguh da/ks ds ÅijA e`rd ds vkek'k; esa ipkl xzke isLVh eSVsfj;y ekStwn FkkA e`rd dh e`R;q dk laHkkfor le; yxHkx vk/kk fnu vkSj e`R;q dk dkj.k SHOCK AND HAEMORRAGE tks e`R;q ls iwoZ vk;h pksVks ds dkj.k FkhA iz'u- e`rd 'kqHke feJk ds 'kjhj ij tks pksVs vk;h gS og fdl pht ls vk ldrh gSA mRrj- fdlh Hkh dBksj ,oa dqUn pht ls flj ij o 'kjhj ij ekjus ls vk ldrh gSA iz'u- D;k ;g pksVs fdlh okgu ds 'kjhj ds Åij ls xqtjus ij vkuk laHko gSA mRrj- th ugh ,slh dksbZ pksV ugh FkhA ^^eq0v0la0 220@2021 Fkkuk frdqfu;k tuin [khjh fnukad 28-10-2021 c;ku Mk0 jktdqekj iq= Jh gfjjke oekZ fu0 2@894 lsDVj ,p tkudhiqje y[kuÅ gky irk ftyk fpfdRlky; tuin [khjh eks0ua0 9415527148 vk/kkj ua0 575816637303 lEcfU/kr eq0v0la0 220@21 /kkjk 143@109@147@148@149@323@324@336@302 Hkknfo Fkkuk frdqfu;ka tuin & [khjhA m0iz0 vUrxZr /kkjk 161 n0iz0la0 LFkku dzkbe czkUp@,l0vkbZ0Vh0 fjtoZ iqfyl ykbUl tuin [khjh us iwoZ esa gLrk{kfjr vius }kjk fnukad 04-10-2021 dks rS;kj dh x;h iksLVekVZe fjiksVZ ns[kdj crk;k fd fnukad 04-10-21 le; 03-45 ,-,e- ij ftyk vf/kdkjh tuin [khjh ds vkns'kkuqlkj jkr esa d`f=e i;kZIr izdk'k esa ekMuZ ih,e gkml esa rhu MkDVjksa ds iSuy }kjk e`rd ';ke lqUnj iq= ckydjke fu- tQsjkflaxgk dyk Fkkuk flaxkgh tuin [khjh mez 35 o"kZ dk iksLVekVZe fd;k x;k o iksLVekVZe dh fofM;ksxzkQh eks0 vkjhQ egcwc LVwfM;ks [khjh }kjk djk;h x;hA ftlesa esjs vykok Mk0ds0ih0 flag iq= Jh uUgw flag fu0 103 jkeiqj jksM fo/kkSfy;k osLV ,aM dkyksuh ftyk cjsyh o Mk0 jktdqekj dksyh iq= Jh ch0,y dksyh fu0 776 foyk ,YMhdks flVh vkbZvkbZ,e jksM y[kuÅ }kjk fd;k x;kA ftudh f'kuk[r ,oa 'ko ykus okys dk uke vkj{kh yksds'k dqekj Fkkuk dksrokyh lnj tuin [khjh }kjk yk;k x;k FkkA e`rd ';ke lqUnj dks ftyk vLirky esa fnukad 03-10-2021 dks jkf= 10-00 cts yk;k x;k FkkA e`rd dh ÅapkbZ 165 ls0eh0] cukoV e/;e] dkBh vkSlruA e`rd }kjk igus x;s oL=ksa esa ,d iS.V] ,d csYV] ,d usdj] ,d 'kVZ] ,d cfu;ku] ,d dykok FkkA e`R;q i'pkr vdM+u Åij vkSj uhps nksuks ,DVªhfeVh esa mifLFkr FkhA ih,e LVsfuax 'kjhj ds ihNs ds fgLls esa mifLFkr FkhA feV~Vh gkFk vkSj iwjs 'kjhj o diM+ks esa yxh FkhA lw[kk tek gqvk [kwu diM+s o 'kjhj ds dqN Hkkxksa esa FkkA e`rd ds 'kjhj esa mifLFkr pksVsa ¼,UVhekVZe batjh½ esa 1&QVk gqvk ?kko 10 xq.kk 8 ls0eh0 xgjkbZ gM~Mh rd flj ds ihNs ik;h x;h] ?kko [kksyus ij uhps dh vkDlhfiVy cksu ¼[kksiM+h ds ihNs dh gM~Mh½ VwVh ik;h x;h] fnekx o fnekx dh f>Yyh QVh gqbZ FkhA tek gqvk [kwu ¼DyksVsM CyM½ f>Yyh ds Åij vkSj efLr"d ds vanj ik;k x;kA 2& ,cszMsM dUV~;wtu lkbt 20 xq.kk 15 ls0eh0 ekFks o flj esa ?kko [kksyus ij nksuks rjQ dh VsEiksjy vkSj iSjkbVy cksu ¼nksuks vksj ds dku ds Åij dh ,oa flj ds nksuks fdukjs ds rjQ dh gM~Mh½ VwVh gqbZ ik;h x;hA 3&eYVhiy daV~;wtu lkbt 60 xq.kk 32 ls0eh0 ds nk;js esa isV o Nkrh ds Åij ftlesa lcls cM+h pksV dk lkbt 20 xq.kk 4 ls0eh0 vkSj NksVh pksV dk lkbt 6 xq.kk 4 ls0eh0A e`rd dh e`R;q dk laHkkfor le; yxHkx vk/kk fnu vkSj e`R;q dk dkj.k dksek ¼e`R; iwoZ vk;h pksVksa ds dkj.k½ gqbZ gSA iz0& e`rd ';ke lqUnj ds 'kjhj ij tks pksVsa vk;ha gS og fdl pht ls vk ldrh gSa\ mRrj& fdlh Hkh dBksj ,oa dqan pht ds flj ij vkSj 'kjhj ij ekjus ls vk ldrh gSA iz0& D;k ;g pksVsa fdlh okgu ls vkuk laHko gS\ mRrj& ugha] okgu ls vkuk laHko ugha gSA^^ eq0 v0 la0 220@2021 Fkkuk frdqfu;ka [khjhA fnukad 28-10-2021 c;ku Mk0 jktdqekj dksyh iq= oh0,u dksyh fuoklh 776 foyk ,fYMdks flVh vkbZvkbZ,e jksM y[kuÅ gky irk ftyk fpfdRlky; [khjh eks0ua0 8299612640 vk/kkj dkMZ ua0 600289026791 lEcfU/kr eq0v0la0&220@21 /kkjk --------143@147@148@149@323@324@336@302 Hkknfo Fkkuk frdqfu;k tuin [khjh m0iz0 vUrxZr /kkjk 161 n0iz0la0 LFkku&dzkbe czkUp@,l0vkbZ0Vh fjtoZ iqfyl ykbUl [khjhA us iwoZ esa gLrk{kfjr vius }kjk 04-10-2021 esa rS;kj dh x;h iksLVekVZe fjiksVZ ns[kdj iwaNus ij crk;k fd fnukad 04-10-21 le; 02-50 ,-,e- ij ftyk vf/kdkjh tuin [khjh ds vkns'kkuqlkj jkr esa d`f=e i;kZIr izdk'k esa ekMuZ ih,e gkml esa rhu MkDVjksa ds iSuy }kjk e`rd gfjvkse feJk iq= jk/ks';ke feJk fu0 ijlsjk Fkkuk Qj/kku tuin [khjh mez 35 o"kZ dk iksLVekVZe fd;k x;k o iksLVekVZe dh ohfM;ksxzkQh eks0 vkjhQ egcwc LVwfM;ks [khjh }kjk djk;h x;hA ftuesa esjs vykok Mk0 jktdqekj iq= Jh gfjjke oekZ fu0 2@894 lsDVj ,p tkudhiqje y[kuÅ o Mk0ds0ih0 flag iq= uUgw flag fu0 103 jkeiqj jksM fc/kkSfy;k osLV yS.M dkyksuh ftyk cjsyh }kjk fd;k x;kA e`rd ds 'ko ykus okys dk uke vkj{kh dqynhi Fkkuk dksrokyh lnj tuin [khjh] jk/ks';ke feJk e`rd ds firk ,oa 'ko ykus okys dk uke vkj{kh dqynhi Fkkuk dksrokyh lnj ftyk [khjh }kjk f'kuk[r fd;k x;kA e`rd ds 'kjhj dks ftyk vLirky esa fnukad 03-10-2021 dks 10-05 ih-,e- ij yk;k x;k FkkA e`rd dh ÅapkbZ 165 ls0eh0] cukoV e/;e] dkBh vkSlruA e`rd }kjk igus x;s oL=ksa esa ,d 'kVZ] ,d pM~ढh] ,d cfu;ku] ,d csYV] ,d iS.V] nks tqjkQ] ,d twrk FkkA e`R;q i'pkr~ vdM+u Åij vkSj uhps nksuksa ,DlVªhfeVh esa mifLFkr FkhA ih,e LVsfuax ihB esa mifLFkr Fkh rFkk lw[kk tek gqvk [kwu 'kjhj vkSj diM+ksa ds dqN Hkkxksa esa ik;k x;kA e`rd ds 'kjhj esa mifLFkr pksaVs ¼,UVhekVZe batjh½&1& QVk gqvk ?kko 5 xq.kk 1 ls0eh0] xgjkbZ gM~Mh rd] ck;sa rjQ dh [kksiM+h ij ck;sa dku ls 5 ls0eh0 Åij ?kko [kksyus ij] ck;as rjQ dh VsEiksjy ,aM iSjkbVy gM~Mh ¼dku ds Åij dh] [kksiM+h ds ck;sa fdukjs dh gM~Mh½ QSzDpj o efLr"d f>Yyh vkSj efLr"d QVk gqvk FkkA lkFk gh esa efLr"d f>Yyh vkSj efLr"d ds Åij [kwu Hkh ik;k x;kA 2& cgqr lkjs QVs gq;s ?kko 20 xq.kk 20 ls0eh0 ds nk;js esa ekFks o [kksiM+h ds ihNs ik;s x;sA ?kko dks [kksyus ij QzUVy ,aM iSjkbVy cksu ¼ekFks ds vkxs dh vksj [kksiM+h ds fdukjs dh gM~Mh½ QSzDpj ik;h x;h lkFk esa gh efLr"d f>Yyh vkSj efLr"d f>Yyh vkSj efLr"d Hkh QVk gqvk ik;k x;kA o tek gqvk [kwu f>Yyh ds Åij vkSj efLr"d ds Åij ik;k x;kA 3- cgqr lkjs daV~;wtu 50 xq.kk 40 ls0eh0 ds nk;js esa isV vkSj Nkrh ds ihNs ftlesa lcls cM+k 15 xq.kk 4 ls0eh0 lcls NksVk 6 xq.kk 4 ls0eh0 4& QVk gqvk ?kko 2 xq.kk 0-5 ls0eh0 xgjkbZ dkfVZyst rd nkfgus dku ds ÅijA 5& eYVhiy cgqr lkjs dV~;wtu 13 xq.kk 10 ls0eh0 ds nk;js esa ck;sa Hkqtk ds ihNsA 6& lqij fQf'k;y cuZ 30 xq.kk 20 ls0eh0 Nkrh vkSj isV ds lkeusA ykbu vkQ jsMusl ekStwnA 7& lqij fQf'k;y cuZ 20 xq.kk 25 ls0eh0 ck;sa tka?k vkSj bfy;d dszLV ds ckgjh Hkkx ijA ykbu vkQ jsMusl izstsUVA e`rd dh e`R;q dk lEHkkfor le; yxHkx vk/kk fnu vkSj e`R;q dk dkj.k dksek gS tks e`R;q iwoZ vkbZ pksVksa ds dkj.k gqbZ gSA iz- e`rd gfjvkse feJk ds 'kjhj ij pksVsa fdl pht ls vk ldrh gS\ m- fdlh Hkh dBksj ,oa dqan pht ds flj ij vkSj 'kjhj ij ekjus ls vk ldrh gSA iz0- D;k ;g pksVsa fdlh okgu ds 'kjhj ds Åij ls xqtj tkus ls lEHko gS\ m0- th ughaA^^ 22. It is crystal clear from the statements of the witnesses that thousands of protesters were present at the place of incident and admittedly, a number of persons, who were outsiders, reached there from different districts and even from different States. The crux of all the statements of the witnesses either recorded by the Investigating Officer under Section 161 Cr.P.C. or recorded under Section 164 Cr.P.C., is that the applicant was sitting in the Thar vehicle and he was saying to his driver to hit the protesters. Further, it is the admitted case of the prosecution in the statements of the witnesses that thousands of protesters were present at the place of incident and they were standing on both sides of the road, which was 12 ft. widen, after which, there was 5 ft. kachhi road and thereafter ditch was there on both sides of the road. One of the witness, namely, Baljinder Singh Makad, whose statement was also recorded during the course of investigation, has stated that at the place of incident, about 10-15 thousand protesters were present and they were having arrangement of cooking of food, and the protest was being regulated by announcements on loudspeakers. 23. Indubitably, no firearm injury has been found on the body of the deceased or any other person, except the injury of the hitting from the vehicle. Furthermore, in case, the story of the prosecution is accepted, thousands of protesters gathered at the place of incident and there might be a possibility that the driver tried to speed up the vehicle to save himself, on account of which, the incident had taken place. 24. While considering the overall facts of the case, this Court cannot shut its eyes to the killing of three persons sitting in the Thar vehicle, including the driver, who were killed by the protesters. The photograph available in the case diary clearly reveals the brutality of the protesters, those were beating the said three persons, namely, Hariom Mishra, Shubham Mishra and Shyam Sunder. It is also relevant to mention here that the Investigating Officer of the Case Crime No. 220 of 2021 came to the conclusion that after the said incident of hitting of the protesters by the Thar vehicle, the protesters chased Shubham Mishra, Hariom Mishra and Shyam Sunder and they were beaten brutally, on account of which, they died. It is also relevant to mention here that the Investigating Officer of the Case Crime No. 220 of 2021 came to the conclusion that after the said incident of hitting of the protesters by the Thar vehicle, the protesters chased Shubham Mishra, Hariom Mishra and Shyam Sunder and they were beaten brutally, on account of which, they died. The said conclusion was drawn by the Investigating Officer on the basis of video clip aired by the protesters themselves in relation to the incident, in which, several persons were found beating Shubham Mishra, Hariom Mishra and Shyam Sunder (deceased), out of which, four persons have been identified and charge sheet has been prepared against them, namely, Kulvinder Singh, Karamjeet, Gurpreet Singh and Vichitra Singh. However, rest of the persons could not be identified by the Investigating Officer. It is expected from the Organisers of the protest to assist in the investigation and provide the details of the rest of the accused persons, whose involvement are found in the video clip as well as photographs collected by the police during the course of investigation. 25. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case in toto, it is evident that as per the F.I.R., role of firing was assigned to the applicant for killing the protesters, but during the course of investigation, no such firearm injuries were found either on the body of any of the deceased or on the body of any injured person. Thereafter, the prosecution alleged that the applicant provoked the driver of the vehicle for crushing the protesters, however, the driver along with two others, who were in the vehicle, had been killed by the protesters. It is further evident that during the course of investigation, notice was issued to the applicant and he appeared before the Investigating Officer. It is also evident that the charge sheet has already been filed. In such circumstances, this Court is of the view that the applicant is entitled to be released on bail. 26. It is further evident that during the course of investigation, notice was issued to the applicant and he appeared before the Investigating Officer. It is also evident that the charge sheet has already been filed. In such circumstances, this Court is of the view that the applicant is entitled to be released on bail. 26. Let applicant - Ashish Mishra @ Monu be released on bail in F.I.R. No. 219 of 2021, under Sections 147, 148, 149, 307, 326, 427/34 I.P.C., Section 30 of Arms Act and Section 177 of M.V. Act, Police Station Tikuniya, District Lakhimpur Kheri, on his furnishing personal bond and two reliable sureties each of the like amount to the satisfaction of the court concerned subject to following conditions:- (1) Applicant will not try to influence the witnesses or tamper with the evidence of the case or otherwise misuse the liberty of bail. (2) Applicant will fully cooperate in expeditious disposal of the case and shall not seek any adjournment on the dates fixed for evidence when witnesses are present in the Court. (3) Applicant shall remain present, in person, before the trial court on the dates fixed for (a) opening of the case, (b) framing of charge; and (c) recording of statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C. (4) Applicant shall not leave the State without permission of the court concerned. (5) The party shall file computer generated copy of order downloaded from the official website of High Court Allahabad, self attested by it alongwith a self attested identity proof of the said person(s) (preferably Aadhar Card) mentioning the mobile number(s) to which the said Aadhar Card is linked, before the concerned Court/Authority/Official. (6) The concerned Court/Authority/Official shall verify the authenticity of the computerized copy of the order from the official website of High Court Allahabad and shall make a declaration of such verification in writing. Any violation of above conditions will be treated misuse of bail and learned Court below will be at liberty to pass appropriate order in the matter regarding cancellation of bail. 27. However, before parting with the judgment, it is noteworthy to mention here that there was serious lackness of the District Administration, as some persons, for their political benefits, call innocent persons, without due permission under law. 27. However, before parting with the judgment, it is noteworthy to mention here that there was serious lackness of the District Administration, as some persons, for their political benefits, call innocent persons, without due permission under law. In the present case, though the order under Section 144 Cr.P.C. was operating, thousands of persons from different districts, even from other States gathered at one place, which was very well within the knowledge of the District Administration, as is evident from the statement of its officials, but neither any preventive action was taken nor any action against the organisers had been taken. Section 30(3) of the Police Act, 1861 provides that the permission is required for any assembly or procession on the public road. As per the provisions of Section 31 of the Police Act, 1861, it is the duty of the police to keep order on the public road and in public streets. Section 30 as well as Section 31 of the Police Act are being reproduced hereunder : "30-A. Powers with regard to assemblies and processions violating conditions of licence-(1) Any Magistrate or District Superintendent of Police or Assistant District Superintendent of Police or Inspector of Police or any Police Officer-In-charge of a station may stop any procession which violates the conditions of a licence granted under the last goregoing section, may order it or any assembly which violates any such conditions as aforesaid to disperse. (2) Any procession or assembly which neglects or refused to obey any order given under the last preceding sub-section shall be deemed to be an unlawful assembly. 31. Police to keep order on public roads, etc.-It shall be the duty of the police to keep order on the public roads, and in the public streets, thoroughfare, ghats and landing places and at all other places of public resort, and to prevent obstructions on the occasions of assemblies and processions on the public roads and in the public streets, or in the neighbourhood of places of worship, during the time of public worship and in any case when any road, street, thoroughfare, ghat or landing place may be thronged or may be liable to be obstructed." 28. Therefore, Chief Secretary of the State of U.P. is hereby directed to issue necessary direction and guidelines for regulating such type of assemblies and procession in order to avoid the inconvenience caused to the citizens on account of such types of assemblies. 29. Senior Registrar of this Court is directed to communicate this order to the Chief Secretary, Government of U.P. for necessary compliance, forthwith. 30. The photocopies of the case diaries of F.I.R. No. 219 of 2020 and F.I.R. No. 220 of 2020, as provided by the learned A.A.G. on 24.01.2021 to the Bench Secretary, is hereby returned to the learned A.A.G.