JUDGMENT 1. Mr. Gajendra, learned senior advocate appears on behalf of petitioner and draws attention to order dated 21st November, 2022. We reproduce paragraph 6 from said order. '6. We have perused, inter alia, impugned order. Prima facie, it appears, recommendation no.1 is the reason for rejection. The recommendation is reproduced below. '1. The team verified feasibility to provide 2nd road connectivity from the south side (NH-5) of the hotel site. But the team did not consider it proper as it would pose serious problem for maintenance and repair of heavy water pipe line passed to the nearby high level water tank. Executive Engineer, GPEO have raised objection for using the site for road purpose in his letter No.19283 dtd. 1.11.2014.'' 2. Mr. Babu, learned advocate, Additional Government Advocate appears on behalf of State and submits, his instructions are, the additional land cannot be allotted to petitioner for construction of road in view of the reasons reproduced above. 3. Mr. Gajendra draws attention to certificate dated 12th April, 2019 also containing opinion of Chief Engineer (Roads and Building) Retd., engaged by petitioner. The opinion is extracted and reproduced below. 'During my visit, I saw construction of a massive structure of the Hotel building in progress. For reaching the spot of the Hotel site I had to go on the Industrial Estate road on the back side of the allotted land site and take a turn to reach the Water supply Pump house gate over a vacant space which is being used as ingress and outgress for the purpose of building construction. There is no direct access of the Hotel building to the service road of N.H. No.5. If a 40 ft. or 50 ft wide road would be constructed from the Hotel building site of Smt. Rajashree Gajendra on the adjoining Southern side Govt. vacant land crossing the water supply pipe line with minimum 1 ft height over it there shall be absolutely no difficulty for maintenance of that stretch of pipe line nor any damage would be caused.' 4. State will file additional affidavit dealing with the certificate. The affidavit will be accepted on adjourned date upon advance copy served. 5. List on 3rd January, 2023.