Research › Search › Judgment

Madhya Pradesh High Court · body

2023 DIGILAW 499 (MP)

District Co-operative Central Bank Ltd. Datia v. Sitaram Ahirwar

2023-04-18

ARUN MATHUR, CHANDRESH KUMAR KHARE

body2023
vkns'k 1- vihykFkÊ cSad }kjk orZeku çFke vihy mi iath;d ¼U;kf;d½ lgdkjh laLFkk,a] Xokfy;j }kjk çdj.k dekd@lh&09@2018 esa ikfjr vkns'k fnukad 22-4-2021 ls O;fFkr gksdj lgdkjh lfefr;k¡ vfèkfu;e 1960] ftls vkxs lqfoèkk dh –f"V ls vfèkfu;e ds uke ls lacksfèkr fd;k tkosxk dh èkkjk 78 ¼1½ varxZr çLrqr dh xà gSA 2- blh vkyksP; vkns'k ls O;fFkr gksdj cdk;k osru HkÙks fnyk, tkus gsrq çR;FkÊ }kjk Hkh çFke vihy Ø- 59@2021 vfèkdj.k ds le{k is'k dh xà gSA nksuksa vihy varxzZLr rF; ,oa ifjfLFkfr;k¡ leku gksus ls nksuksa vihyksa dk fujkdj.k bl vkns'k ds }kjk lesfdr :i ls fd;k tk jgk gSA çdj.k ds laf{kIr rF; bl çdkj gSa fd çR;FkÊ] vihykFkÊ cSad esa lfefr çcaèkd ds in ij dk;Zjr FkkA cSad lfefr çcaèkd ds :i esa lsok lgdkjh lfefr eqjsjk esa dk;Zjr jgus ds nkSjku mlds }kjk dS'k ØsfMV ,EIykÃt varxZr jkf'k #- 1653665-81 dk vkgj.k rFkk çkFkfed Ñf"k lk[k lgdkjh laLFkk e;kZ- oMkSudyk esa blh en esa #- 982557-04 dk vkgj.k rFkk o"kZ 98&99 esa 'kk[kk çcaèkd nfr;k ds çfrosnu vuqlkj [kkn lek;kstu dh jkf'k #- 231403-00 tek djk;k tkuk 'ks"k gksus fo"k;d fd, x, vfu;fer dk;ks± ds fy, mls fnukad 25-4-2016 dks fuyafcr fd;k tkdj fnukad 15-7-2016 dks vkjksi i= çnku fd;k x;kA fnukad 2-9-2016 ds vkns'kkuqlkj Jh jkedqekj ikjk'kj] çHkkjh 'kk[kk çcaèkd 'kk[kk lsoढ+k dks ekeys esa tkap vfèkdkjh fu;qä fd;k x;k ftuds }kjk fnukad 12-1-2017 dks tkap çfrosnu is'k fd;k tkdj yxk, x, vkjksi çekf.kr ik;k tkuk vfHkfyf[kr fd;k x;kA mä tkap çfrosnu ds fu"d"kksa ds vkèkkj ij çR;FkÊ dks tkap çfrosnu Þdh çfr lfgr fnukad 15-7-16 dks dkj.k crkvks lwpuki= tkjh fd;k tkdj Þlsok lekfIrÞ dk naM çLrkfor fd;k x;kA ,rnksijkar vihykFkÊ cSad ds tkap eaMy desVh ds le{k fnukad 28-11-2006 24-3-2017 dks mifLFkr gq, ,oa çR;FkÊ dks O;fäxr lquk x;k ,oa varr% vkns'k Øekad@1177&, fnukad 7-4-2017 }kjk çR;FkÊ dks lsok lekfIr ds n.M ls nafMr fd;k x;kA 3- çR;FkÊ }kjk mäkns'k dks la;qä iath;d Xokfy;j ds le{k fnukad 31-1-2018 dks vfèkfu;e dh èkkjk 55 ¼2½ varxZr fookn is'k dj pqukSrh nh xà ftls vkns'k fnukad 20-8-18 }kjk mi iath;d Xokfy;j dks fofèkor fujkdj.k gsrq varfjr fd;k x;kA fo}ku U;k;ky; mi iath;d Xokfy;j }kjk çdj.k dks d 55 ¼2½ &09@2018 ds :i esa ntZ dj mHk;i{kh; lk{; xzg.k dj ekeys esa vkyksP; vkns'k fnukad 22-4-2021 }kjk fookn dks Lohdkj djrs gq, çR;FkÊ ds fo:) laikfnr foHkkxh; tkap dks nwf"kr gksuk vfHkfuèkkZfjr djrs gq, çR;FkÊ vkns'k fnukad 20-8-18 }kjk mi iath;d Xokfy;j dks fofèkor fujkdj.k gsrq varfjr fd;k x;kA fo}ku U;k;ky; mi iath;d Xokfy;j }kjk çdj.k dks d 55 ¼2½ &09@2018 ds :i esa ntZ dj mHk;i{kh; lk{; xzg.k dj ekeys esa vkyksP; vkns'k fnukad 22-4-2021 }kjk fookn dks Lohdkj djrs gq, çR;FkÊ ds fo:) laikfnr foHkkxh; tkap dks nwf"kr gksuk vfHkfuèkkZfjr djrs gq, çR;FkÊ ds fo#) ikfjr n.Mkns'k fujLr djrs gq, çR;FkÊ ds fo:) iwoZ çpfyr foHkkxh; tkap dk;Zokgh dh leh{kk dj fofèk ds LFkkfir flènkarksa ds varxZr iqu dk;Zokgh fd, tkus dh Lora=rk çnku dh xà Fkh- ftlls O;fFkr gksdj vihykFkÊi{k }kjk orZeku vihy vfèkdj.k ds le{k is'k dh xà gSA 4- vihykFkÊi{k rQsZ fo}ku vfèkoäk }kjk vihy Kki vuqlkj rdZ is'k djrs gq, fo}ku fopkj.k U;k;ky; ds vkns'k dks nwf"kr gksuk bu vkèkkjksa ij vfHkdfFkr fd;k x;k fd çR;FkÊ }kjk is'k fookn çFke –"V;k le;kofèk ckfèkr :i ls is'k fd;k x;k FkkA çR;FkÊ }kjk fd, x, xaHkhj vkÆFkd vfu;ferrkvksa ds lacaèk esa foLr`r tkap dk;Zokfg;ka lsok fu;ekarxZr l{ke çkfèkdkjh }kjk dh xà FkhA çR;FkÊ }kjk mi iath;d ds le{k mlds funksZ"k gksus fo"k;d rF; is'k ugÈ fd, Fks vihykFkÊi{k }kjk is'k tokcnkos dks utjvankt djrs gq, xcudrkZ çR;FkÊ deZpkjh ds i{k esa dkYifud vkèkkjksa ij vkyksP; vkns'k ikfjr fd, tkus esa fo}ku mi iath;d }kjk fofèkd =qfV dkfjr dh xà gSA U;k;ky; mi iath;d ds le{k çR;FkÊ }kjk mlds dk;Zdky esa laLFkkvksa esa vfu;ferrk;sa çekf.kr gksus] mls lsok fu;ekèkhu dkj.k crkvks lwpuki= çnku fd, tkus tkp vfèkdkjh }kjk tkap ds le; fofèkor vkgwr fd;k tkdj tkap mijkar çfrosnu lfgr vafre dkj.k crkvks lwpuki= çnku fd;k tkdj O;fäxr lquokà dk volj çnku fd;k tkuk nLrkostkas }kjk çekf.kr fd;k x;k Fkk] rFkkfi] fo}ku mi iath;d }kjk nwf"kr foHkkxh; tkap ds vkèkkj ij çR;FkÊ dks lsok esa iquLFkkZfir djus fo"k;d vkyksP; vkns'k ikfjr fd, tkus esa fofèkd =qfV dkfjr dh xà gSA fo}ku vèkhuLFk U;k;ky; }kjk fdlh Hkh lk{; ds çfrijh{k.k esa oÆ.kr rF;ksa ds lacaèk esa foospuk ugÈ djrs gq, ,di{kh; vkns'k ikfjr fd;s tkus esa fofèkd =qfV dkfjr dh xà gSA fo}ku vèkhuLFk U;k;ky; }kjk çR;FkÊ ds fo:) likfnr foHkkxh; tkap fdl çØe ls nwf"kr ikà xÃ] bldk mYys[k vkyksP; vkns'k esa ugÈ fd;k x;k gS- lk{; dh foospuk fd, cxSj] fcuk miyCèk lk{; ds lsok lekfIr vkns'k vfHk[kafMr fd, tkus esa fofèkd =qfV dkfjr dh xà gSA fofèk ds LFkkfir flènkar gS fd nwf"kr foHkkxh; tkap ik, tkus dh n'kk esa tkap U;k;ky; }kjk çR;FkÊ ds fo:) likfnr foHkkxh; tkap fdl çØe ls nwf"kr ikà xÃ] bldk mYys[k vkyksP; vkns'k esa ugÈ fd;k x;k gS- lk{; dh foospuk fd, cxSj] fcuk miyCèk lk{; ds lsok lekfIr vkns'k vfHk[kafMr fd, tkus esa fofèkd =qfV dkfjr dh xà gSA fofèk ds LFkkfir flènkar gS fd nwf"kr foHkkxh; tkap ik, tkus dh n'kk esa tkap çR;koÆrr dj vipkjh deZpkjh dks fuyafcr j[ks tkus fo"k;d fofèkd çkoèkku ds mYya?ku esa çR;FkÊ dks lsok esa iquLFkkZfir fd, tkus fo"k;d vkyksP; vkns'k ikfjr dj fofèkd =qfV dkfjr dh xà gSA vèkhuLFk U;k;ky; ds le{k çR;FkÊ }kjk is'k fookn le;kofèk ckfèkr :i ls is'k gksus ,oa jhMj }kjk fuèkkZfjr frfFk ij çHkkoh U;k;ky;hu dk;Zokgh fd, tkus esa fofèkd =qfV dkfjr dh xà gSA fo}ku fopkj.k U;k;ky; }kjk çR;FkÊ ds fo:) lafLFkr foHkkxh; tkap ls lacafèkr ewy vfHkys[k vkgwr fd, fcuk] mlds ifj'khyu ds cxSj gh foHkkxh; tkap nwf"kr gksus fo"k;d fu"d"kZ fudkys tkus esa fofèkd =qfV dkfjr dh xà gSA vr,o mijksä vkèkkjksa ij orZeku vihy Lohdkj dh tkdj vkyksP; vkns'k fujLr fd, tkus fo"k;d çkFkZuk dh xÃA vius rdZ ds leFkZu esa fo}ku vfèkoäk }kjk vfèkdj.k }kjk 2020 ¼1½ vkj,u 315 vkSj 2006 vkj,u 25 ds U;k; –"Vkar lanÆHkr fd,A çR;FkÊi{k }kjk vkyksP; vkns'k dk iw.kZ leFkZu djrs gq,] rdZ çLrqr fd;k x;k gS fd mlds }kjk vihykFkÊ cSad }kjk çlkfjr foHkkxh; tkp fo"k;d vkns'k fnukad 2-9-2016 ds vuqde esa tkap vfèkdkjh jkedqekj ikjk'kj }kjk laikfnr tkap dk;Zokgh nwf"kr gksus ls mä tkap dk;Zokgh ds vkèkkj ij ikfjr n.Mkns'k dks fujLr fd;k tkuk çkÆFkr fd;k x;k ,oa mi iath;d }kjk ikfjr vkns'k ds vuqØe esa çR;FkÊ dks cSad lsok esa cdk;k osru lfgr iquLFkkZfir fd, tkus fo"k;d vkns'k çnku fd;k tkuk fuosfnr fd;k x;k gSA vr,o] mä vkèkkjksa ij vihykFkÊi{k }kjk is'k orZeku vihy lkjghu gksuk vfHkdfFkr djrs gq, fujLr fd;k tkuk çkÆFkr fd;k x;k gSA 5- mHk;i{kksa ds fo}ku vfèkoäkx.kksa ds rdZ lqus] i=koyh dk voyksdu fd;k x;kA 6- i=koyh ds voyksdu ls fofnr gksrk gS fd fo}ku mi iath;d Xokfy;j }kjk vkyksP; vkns'kkuqlkj çR;FkÊ ds fo:) laikfnr foHkkxh; tkp ds lacaèk esa fu"dÆ"kr fd;k x;k gS fd & Þtkap ds oä le; le; ij oknh dks lwfpr fd;k x;k vkSj mlds }kjk vius i= Hkh fn, x, gSaA ,d i= fnukad 22-9-2016 dks fn;k tkdj lk{; gsrq le; dh ekax dh xà gSA i= fnukad 5-1-2017 ls vkjksiksa dks vLohdkj djrs gq, dFku fn, gSa ftlesa laikfnr foHkkxh; tkp ds lacaèk esa fu"dÆ"kr fd;k x;k gS fd & Þtkap ds oä le; le; ij oknh dks lwfpr fd;k x;k vkSj mlds }kjk vius i= Hkh fn, x, gSaA ,d i= fnukad 22-9-2016 dks fn;k tkdj lk{; gsrq le; dh ekax dh xà gSA i= fnukad 5-1-2017 ls vkjksiksa dks vLohdkj djrs gq, dFku fn, gSa ftlesa lek;kstu ds lacaèk esa Li"V :i ls jkf'k;ksa ds lek;kstu ugÈ fd, tkus dk ys[k fd;k x;k gSA blds i'pkr tc eSa uLrh dk voyksdu djrk gwa rc ikrk gwa fd lek;kstu ds Çcnq ij çLrqrdrkZ ;k cSad dh vksj ls dksà Bksl lk{; ugÈ nh xà gSA ogÈ tkap vfèkdkjh Jh ikjk'kj }kjk Hkh tkap ds nkSjku bl lacaèk esa lkjxÆHkr ijh{kk ugÈ dh xà vkSj u gh bl lacaèk esa dksà nLrkosth lk{; tkap uLrh esa nÆ'kr gksrh gSA oknh ds mij yxk, x, vkjksi Ø- 1] 2] 3 dk;Z ds vuqde esa gSa Çdrq bl lacaèk esa fdlh Hkh lk{kh dk dFku fy;k tkuk ;k çek.k laxzfgr fd;k tkuk vfHkys[k ij nÆ'kr ugÈ gksrk gSA vkjksi Ø- 4] 5] 6 ds ifjis{; esa tkap uLrh esa flQZ [kkrksa dh udysa layXu gSa Çdrq ;fn fdlh jkf'k dk viHk{k.k fd;k x;k gS vFkok lek;kstu ugÈ gqvk gS rc bl lacaèk esa Bksl lk{; dk gksuk vko';d gS tks fd tkap uLrh esa ugÈ ikrk gwaA blds mijkar Hkh Jh ikjk'kj dh tkap ij gh fn[kkoVh t‚p e.My xfBr dj fn;k x;k ftuds }kjk Jh ikjk'kj dh tkap ij gh fu"d"kZ fudkyrs gq, viuk çfrosnu ys[kc) dj fn;k gSA egRoiw.kZ rF; ;g gS fd vkjksi Ø- 4] 5] 6 ds vuqlkj vk{ksfir jkf'k dk ;ksx #- 2904479-65 gksrk gS tks :- 10 yk[k ls vfèkd gS rc tkap dh dk;Zokgh gsrq lsok fu;e Ø- 49-3-2 ¼3½ ds çkoèkku ykxw ,oa vuqlfjr gksaxs---- bl çdkj tkap dk;Zokgh foHkkxh; tkap cksMZ }kjk dh tkuh pkfg, Fkh rc Jh ikjk'kj }kjk tkap djk, tkus dk dksà vkSfpR; çrhr ugÈ gksrk gSA Çdrq] orZeku çdj.k esa tkap Jh ikjk'kj }kjk dh xà rRi'pkr Jh ikjk'kj ds çfrosnu ij tkap e.My dh dk;Zokgh dj ys[kc) dj fn;k x;k bl çdkj ls foHkkxh; tkp fuf'pr :i ls nwf"kr Lo:i dh gSA------ mijksä foospuk ds vuqlkj oknh ds fo:) dh xà foHkkxh; tkap =qfViw.kZ ,oa nwf"kr Lo:i dh gksuk çekf.kr gS rnuqlkj blh vuqØe esa tkjh lsok lekfIr vkns'k ---fnukad 7-4-2017 fujLr fd;k tkrk gSA oknh Jh ikjk'kj ds çfrosnu ij tkap e.My dh dk;Zokgh dj ys[kc) dj fn;k x;k bl çdkj ls foHkkxh; tkp fuf'pr :i ls nwf"kr Lo:i dh gSA------ mijksä foospuk ds vuqlkj oknh ds fo:) dh xà foHkkxh; tkap =qfViw.kZ ,oa nwf"kr Lo:i dh gksuk çekf.kr gS rnuqlkj blh vuqØe esa tkjh lsok lekfIr vkns'k ---fnukad 7-4-2017 fujLr fd;k tkrk gSA oknh vU; dksà jkf'k fuyacu vofèk@ lsok ls i`Fkd jgus dh vofèk dk dksà osru çkIr djus dk vfèkdkjh ugÈ gksxkA- -----pwafd çfroknh cSad esa turk ,oa 'kklu dk èku osf"Br gS ,slh n'kk esa çfroknh dks ;g vfèkdkj gksxk fd og lsok fu;eksa dk v{kj'k% ikyu djrs gq, oknh dh iqu% foHkkxh; tkap dj ldsxkAÞ 7- ;gk¡ ;g Hkh mYys[kuh; gS fd çR;FkÊ ds fo:) vihykFkÊi{k }kjk laikfnr foHkkxh; tkap dks ftyk lgdkjh dsUæh; cSad deZpkjh ¼fu;kstu] fucaèku ,oa dk;ZfLFkfr½ fu;e 1982] ftls vkxs lqfoèkk dh –f"V ls Þlsok fu;eÞ ds uke ls lacksfèkr fd;k tk;sxk] ds fu;e Ø- 58 ds çkoèkkukUrxZr laikfnr ugÈ fd;k tkuk fu"dÆ"kr fd;k x;k gSA ,slh n'kk esa fo}ku fopkj.k U;k;ky; }kjk foHkkxh; tkp dh çfØ;k dks nwf"kr ik, tkus fo"k;d fu"d"kZ dk vfHkys[ku] mfpr ifjyf{kr gksrk gSA 8- deZpkjh lsok fu;eksa ds vuqlkj foHkkxh; tk¡p esa çFker deZpkjh ds fo:) yxk, x, vkjksiksa ds lacaèk esa foHkkx }kjk vius lkf{k;ksa ds dFku djk, tkrs gSa ,oa foHkkxh; tkp ds le; vkjksiksa ls lacafèkr tks nLrkost çLrqr fd, x, gSa- mUgsa lk{; esa çnÆ'kr fd;k tkdj çn'kZ vafdr djk;k tkrk gS ,oa lkf{k;ksa ds dFkuksa ij çfrijh{k.k dk volj vipkjh deZpkjh dks çnku fd;k tkrk gSA lkFk gh vipkjh deZpkjh dks [k.Mu Lo:i lk{; is'k djus dk volj Hkh çnku fd;k tkuk gksrk gSA bl –f"V ls] foHkkxh; tkap vfèkdkjh }kjk fofgr çfØ;k dk ikyu ugÈ fd;k tkuk ifjyf{kr gksrk gSA fofèk dh ;g LFkkfir fLFkfr gS fd foHkkxh; tkap ftl çde ls nwf"kr ikà xà gks- ml çde ls iqu% tkp fd, tkus gsrq vuq'kklfud çkfèkdkjh dks çfrçsf"kr dh tkuh pkfg,A bl lacaèk esa eku loksZPp U;k;ky; }kjk U;k; –"Vkar 1997 AIR SCW 1650 “Board of Management SVT Educational Institution and another v.- A- Raghupathy Bhat and others”] 2003 ,l- lh-lh- ¼,y ,aM ,l½ 877 rFkk 1997 ¼1½ ,e-ih-MCY;w- ,u- 58 iatkc jkT; cuke M‚- gjHktu ÇlgÞ okys ekeyksa esa çfrikfnr fofèk fl)kar mYys[kuh; gSaA bl lacaèk esa vfèkdj.k }kjk vihykFkÊ rQsZ lanÆHkr U;k; –"Vkar 2020 ¼1½ vkj,u 315 vkSj 2006 vkj,u 25 esa “Board of Management SVT Educational Institution and another v.- A- Raghupathy Bhat and others”] 2003 ,l- lh-lh- ¼,y ,aM ,l½ 877 rFkk 1997 ¼1½ ,e-ih-MCY;w- ,u- 58 iatkc jkT; cuke M‚- gjHktu ÇlgÞ okys ekeyksa esa çfrikfnr fofèk fl)kar mYys[kuh; gSaA bl lacaèk esa vfèkdj.k }kjk vihykFkÊ rQsZ lanÆHkr U;k; –"Vkar 2020 ¼1½ vkj,u 315 vkSj 2006 vkj,u 25 esa O;ä er Hkh voyksduh; ,oa voyacuh; gSaA 9- mijksä foosfpr rF;ksa ls Li"Vr;k ifjyf{kr gksrk gS fd fo}ku vèkhuLFk U;k;ky; }kjk ikfjr vkyksP; vkns'k esa tgk¡ rd bldk lacaèk ç'uxr çR;FkÊ ds fo:) ikfjr lsok lekfIr vkns'k fnukad 7-4-2017 dks fujLr fd, tkus ls lacafèkr gS] dks fujLr fd, tkus esa dksà fofèkd =qfV dkfjr ugÈ dh xà gSA Çdrq fo}ku fopkj.k U;k;ky; }kjk ikfjr vkyksP; vkns'k ds Hkkx & ßpwafd çfroknh cSad esa turk ,oa 'kklu dk èku oSf"Br gS ,slh n'kk esa çfroknh dks ;g vfèkdkjh gksxk fd og lsok fu;eksa dk v{kj'k% ikyu djrs gq, oknh dh iqu foHkkxh; tkap dj ldsxkAÞ ds LFkku ij vxzfyf[kr vk'k; dk vkns'k ikfjr fd;k tkrk gS& vihykFkÊ cSad çcaèku dks funsZf'kr fd;k tkrk gS fd ekeys esa] çR;FkÊ ds fo:) yxk, x, vkjksi Ø- 4-5-6 ds vuqlkj vk{ksfir jkf'k dk ;ksx #- 2904479-65 gksrk gS tks : 10 yk[k ls vfèkd gS rc tkap dh dk;Zokgh gsrq lsok fu;e Ø- 49%32 ¼3½ ds çkoèkku ykxw ,o vuqlfjr djrs gq, çR;FkÊ ds fo#) lafLFkr foHkkxh; tkp çdj.k dk fofèklEer çfd;kUrxZr fofHkUu çØeksa dks fofèkor ifjiwfrZ djrs gq, orZeku vkns'k çkfIr ls rhu ekg dh le;kofèk eè; fujkdj.k djuk lqfuf'pr djsaxs( ;gka ;g Hkh Li"V fd;k tkrk gS fd orZeku tk¡p ds nkSjku çR;FkÊ dh çkfLFkfr ¼gSfl;r½ ogÈ jgsxh] tks iwoZorÊ foHkkxh; tk¡p ds nkSjku FkhA ifj.kkeLo:i] çR;FkÊ }kjk çLrqr çFke vihy Øekad 59@2021 fujLr djrs gq, orZeku çFke vihy Ø- 58@2021 dk fujkdj.k blh :i esa fd;k tkrk gSA çR;FkÊi{k dks vihykFkÊ cSad çcaèku ds le{k fnukad 10-5-2023 dks vfxze dk;Zokgh gsrq mifLFkr jgus gsrq funsZf'kr fd;k tkrk gSA mHk;i{k viuk okn O;; Lo;a ogu djsaA mHk;i{kksa dks vkns'k dh çfrfyfi çnku dh tk;sA ns'k dh ,d çfr çFke vihy Ø- 59@2021 ds vfHkys[k esa j[kh tkdj mDr vihy Hkh rn~uq:i fujkÑr jgsA vkns'k dh izfrfyfi lfgr v/khuLFk U;k;ky;ksa ds vfHkys[k vfoyac okfil gksA urhtk ntZ jftLVj gks i=koyh vfoyac fjdkWMZ :e Hksth tk,A