Research › Search › Judgment

Madhya Pradesh High Court · body

2023 DIGILAW 646 (MP)

Subhash Kushwaha v. Deputy Registrar, Cooperative Societies District Singrouli

2023-07-04

ARUN MATHUR, CHANDRESH KUMAR KHARE

body2023
vkns'k 1- vihykFkÊ }kjk orZeku vihy U;k;ky; iath;d lgdkjh laLFkk,a e-ç- }kjk ç- Ø- ,p-v¨-@03@78@2021&22@0005 esa ikfjr vky¨P; vkns'k fnukafdr 12-4-2022 ls O;fFkr g¨dj] e-ç- lgdkjh lfefr;k¡ vfèkfu;e] 1960] ftls vkxs lqfoèkk dh n`f"V ls ^vfèkfu;e^ d¢ uke ls lac¨fèkr fd;k tk,xk] dh èkkjk 78¼2½ varxZr is'k dh xà gSA 2- çdj.k d¢ laf{kIr rF; bl çdkj gSa & vihykFkÊ d¢ fo#) vkfnoklh eNqvk lgdkjh lfefr e;kZfnr fr;jk ftyk flaxj©yh d¢ vè;{k }kjk vihykFkÊ d¨ iqfyl }kjk fxjrkj dj U;kf;d vfÒj{kk esa j[ks tkus ,oa vuqlwfpr tkfr] tutkfr ¼vR;kpkj fuokj.k½ vfèkfu;e d¢ vkj¨i dk mYys[k djrs gq, mi iath;d] lgdkjh laLFkk,a d¢ le{k ,d f'kdk;r dh x;hA f'kdk;r d¢ vkèkkj ij mi iath;d] lgdkjh laLFkk,a }kjk ,di{kh; ,oa vfèkdkjfoghu fookfnr vkns'k fnukad 10-12-2021 ikfjr fd;k x;k] ftls vihykFkÊ }kjk iath;d] lgdkjh laLFkk,a] e-ç- Ò¨iky d¢ le{k vihy çLrqr dj pqu©rh nh x;h] ftls vkns'k fnukad 13-4-2022 ls fujLr fd;k x;k] ftlls O;fFkr g¨dj vihykFkÊ }kjk orZeku f}rh; vihy vfèkdj.k d¢ le{k çLrqr dh x;hA 3- vihykFkÊ d¢ fo}ku vfèkoäk }kjk vihy Kki vuq:i ;g rdZ çLrqr fd;k x;k gS fd mi iath;d] lgdkjh laLFkk,a ,oa la;qä iath;d] lgdkjh laLFkk,a] e-ç-}kjk vihykFkÊ d¨ vfèkfu;e dh èkkjk 19,] 19lh@d ,oa 19lh@[k d¢ çkoèkku¨a d¨ utjvankt dj lquokà ,oa cpko dk volj fn, fcuk vkns'k ikfjr fd;k x;kA vfèkfu;e dh èkkjk 19 ,@d d¢ çkoèkku vuqlkj fdlh Òh O;fä d¨ fdlh vijkèk esa naMkfn"V fd;k tkuk vfuok;Z gS] tcfd vihykFkÊ d¨ mij¨ä vijkfèkd çdj.k esa naMkfn"V ugÈ fd;k x;k] cfYd fnukad 30-8-2019 ls n¨"keqä fd;k x;k] ftls Òh fo}ku U;k;ky;¨a }kjk utjvankt fd;k x;kA fdlh lapkyd ;k vè;{k d¢ fo#) ,d lkFk dk;Zokgh ugÈ dh tk ldrhA fopkj.k U;k;ky; }kjk vihykFkÊ d¨ viuk i{k çLrqr djus dk volj çnku ugÈ fd;k] blfy, foj¨fèkr vkns'k çkÑfrd U;k; ,oa vfèkfu;e d¢ çkoèkku¨a d¢ foijhr g¨us ls fujLr fd, tkus ;¨X; gSA 4- vr% mij¨ä vkèkkj¨a ij vihykFkÊ dh v¨j ls çLrqr orZeku vihy vLohdkj dh tkdj mi iath;d] lgdkjh laLFkk,a ftyk flaxj©yh ,oa la;qä iath;d lgdkjh laLFkk,a] e-ç- Ò¨iky }kjk ikfjr vkns'k¨a d¨ fujLr fd;k tkosA 5- çR;FkÊi{k gekjs le{k ,di{kh; jgkA 6- mÒ;i{k¨a d¢ rd¨Za ij fopkj fd;k x;k] vkns'k i=koyh ,oa fopkj.k U;k;ky; mi iath;d lgdkjh laLFkk,a ftyk flaxj©yh ,oa la;qä iath;d lgdkjh laLFkk,a] e-ç- Ò¨iky d¢ vfÒys[k¨a dk voy¨du fd;k x;kA 7- vihykFkÊ i{k }kjk mä vky¨P; vkns'k d¨ eq[; :i ls bl vkèkkj ij pqu©rh nh x;h gS fd çFke vihyh; tkosA 5- çR;FkÊi{k gekjs le{k ,di{kh; jgkA 6- mÒ;i{k¨a d¢ rd¨Za ij fopkj fd;k x;k] vkns'k i=koyh ,oa fopkj.k U;k;ky; mi iath;d lgdkjh laLFkk,a ftyk flaxj©yh ,oa la;qä iath;d lgdkjh laLFkk,a] e-ç- Ò¨iky d¢ vfÒys[k¨a dk voy¨du fd;k x;kA 7- vihykFkÊ i{k }kjk mä vky¨P; vkns'k d¨ eq[; :i ls bl vkèkkj ij pqu©rh nh x;h gS fd çFke vihyh; U;k;ky; ,oa fopkj.k U;k;ky; us èkkjk 19&,@d e- ç- lgdkjh l¨lk;Vh vfèkfu;e d¢ çkoèkku¨a d¨ le>us esa xaÒhj Òwy dh gS] D;¨afd mä çkoèkku¨a d¢ vuqlkj fdlh Òh O;fä d¨ fdlh vijkèk esa naMkfn"V fd;k tkuk vfuok;Z gS] tcfd vihykFkÊ d¨ vijkfèkd çdj.k esa naMkfn"V ugÈ fd;k x;k gSA vihykFkÊ d¨ lquokà dk volj u nsrs gq, çkÑfrd U;k; d¢ fl)kar¨a d¢ çfrdwy èkkjk 19&lh@d ,oa èkkjk 19&lh@[k e-ç- lgdkjh l¨lkbVh vfèkfu;e d¢ çkoèkku¨a d¨ utjvankt djrs gq, vky¨P; vkns'k ikfjr fd;k x;k gS] t¨ fd fujLr fd, tkus ;¨X; gSA 8- U;k;ky; mi iath;d] lgdkjh l¨lkbVh ftyk flaxj©yh d¢ }kjk fnukad 10-12-2021 d¨ vxzfyf[kr vkns'k ikfjr fd;k x;k gS & ^mä tkudkjh ,oa vfÒys[k¨a dk e-ç- lgdkjh l¨lkbVht vfèkfu;e] 1960 dh èkkjk 19,@d ,oa ch@[k d¢ çkoèkku¨a ls ijh{k.k fd;k x;k] ftld¢ vuqlkj ^^d¨Ã Òh O;fä fdlh l¨lkbVh d¢ lnL; d¢ :i esa ços'k çkIr djus d¢ fy, ik= ugÈ g¨xk v©j d¨Ã Òh lnL; fdlh l¨lkbVh dk lnL; ugÈ jgsxk ;fn & ^^og fdlh ,sls vijkèk d¢ fy, ftlesa uSfrd vèkerk vUroZfyr g¨] n.Mkfn"V fd;k x;k g¨ v©j n.Mkns'k d¢ volku dh rkjh[k ls ikap o"kZ dh dkykofèk u chr xà g¨^^ rFkk ^^;fn d¨Ã O;fä ftls fdlh l¨lkbVh d¢ lnL; d¢ :i esa ços'k fn;k x;k g¨] ckn esa mä fujgZrk d¢ vè;èkhu g¨ tk,] r¨ ,slk O;fä ml l¨lkbVh dk lnL; ugÈ jg tk,xk rFkk jftLVªkj mld¢ LFkku d¨ fjä Ĩf"kr djsxk^^A vè;{k eNyh ikyu lgdkjh lfefr e;kZfnr cu©yh ftyk flaxj©yh iath;u Ø- 484 dk iath;u fnukad 18-7-2018 d¨ gqvk Fkk] ftlesa Jh lqÒk"k dq'kokg vius d¨ U;kf;d vfÒj{kk esa gokykr esa jgus ftlesa uSfrd vèkerk vUroZfyr gS] d¢ rF; d¨ Nqikrs gq, lfefr esa lnL; d¢ :i esa ços'k çkIr dj lfefr d¢ vè;{k in ij eu¨uhr gq, Fks rFkk rn¨ijkar fnukad 30-7-2019 d¨ gq, lfefr d¢ u, lapkyd e.My d¢ fuokZpu esa Òh lfefr d¢ lnL;@vè;{k d¢ :i esa jgrs gq, iqu% lfefr d¢ vè;{k d¢ in ij fuokZfpr gq, Fks rFkk orZeku esa Òh lfefr esa lnL; d¢ :i esa jgrs gq, vè;{k d¢ :i esa ços'k çkIr dj lfefr d¢ vè;{k in ij eu¨uhr gq, Fks rFkk rn¨ijkar fnukad 30-7-2019 d¨ gq, lfefr d¢ u, lapkyd e.My d¢ fuokZpu esa Òh lfefr d¢ lnL;@vè;{k d¢ :i esa jgrs gq, iqu% lfefr d¢ vè;{k d¢ in ij fuokZfpr gq, Fks rFkk orZeku esa Òh lfefr esa lnL; d¢ :i esa jgrs gq, vè;{k in ij ;Fkkor cus gq, gSa] tcfd lgdkjh foèkku d¢ mij¨ä çkoèkku¨a d¢ rgr Jh lqÒk"k dq'kokg lnL;@vè;{k eNyh ikyu lgdkjh lfefr e;kZfnr cu©yh ftyk flaxj©yh lfefr esa lnL; cus jgus gsrq fujfgZr@v;¨X; gSA vr% e-ç- lgdkjh l¨lkbVht vfèkfu;e 1960 dh èkkjk 19 ,@d ,oa ch@[k d¢ rgr e-ç- 'kklu lgdkfjrk foÒkx dh foKfIr Øekad ,Q&5&2&2010 iUæg 1 lh fnukad 23-10-2010 ls çkIr iath;d dh 'kfä;¨a dk ç;¨x djrs gq, eSa nhfIr cuoklh mi iath;d lgdkjh lfefr;k¡ ftyk flaxj©yh Jh lqÒk"k dq'kokg lnL;@vè;{k eNyh ikyu lgdkjh lfefr e;kZ- cu©yh iath;u Ø- 484@fnukad 18-7-2018 ftyk flaxj©yh d¨ lfefr d¢ lnL; in ls fujfgZr dj mldk LFkku fjä Ĩf"kr djrh gw¡A^^ 9- mi iath;d }kjk ikfjr mä vkns'k ls O;fFkr g¨dj vihykFkÊ }kjk is'k dh x;h çFke vihy esa U;k;ky; iath;d] lgdkjh laLFkk,a }kjk fnukad 13-4-2022 d¨ fopkj.k U;k;ky; d¢ vkns'k fnukad 10-12-2021 d¨ ;Fkkor~ j[krs gq, fuEukuqlkj vkns'k ikfjr fd;k x;k gS%& vihykFkÊ d¢ }kjk çLrqr vihy ,oa çR;FkÊ d¢ }kjk çdj.k ls lacafèkr fjdkMZ rFkk çdj.k uLrh esa layXu nLrkost¨a d¢ voy¨du ls ;g Li"V gS fd vihykFkÊ ij vijkfèkd çdj.k 19@2017 fo'ks"k U;k;kèkh'k vuqlwfpr tkfr tutkfr ¼vR;kpkj fuokj.k½ vfèkfu;e flaxj©yh esa ntZ fd;k x;k Fkk] ftlesa vihykFkÊ d¨ fxjrkj dj fnukad 9-1-2017 ls fnukad 21-1-2017 rd U;kf;d vfÒj{kk esa Òh j[kk x;k Fkk rFkk bld¢ ckn vihykFkÊ d¨ tekur ij fjgk fd;k x;kA rRi'pkr~ fnukad 30-8-2019 d¨ fu.kZ; ikfjr dj vihykFkÊ d¨ n¨"keqä fd;k x;k FkkA ijarq çR;FkÊ d¢ }kjk çsf"kr fjdkMZ d¢ voy¨du ls ;g Òh Li"V gS fd laLFkk dk iath;u fnukad 18-7-2018 d¨ g¨us d¢ i'pkr~ vihykFkÊ d¢ }kjk tc laLFkk dh lnL;rk xzg.k dh x;h Fkh rFkk mld¢ i'pkr~ fnukad 30-7-2019 d¨ laLFkk esa u;s lapkyd e.My d¢ fuokZpu esa Òh vihykFkÊ iqu% laLFkk d¢ vè;{k in ij fuokZfpr gq, Fks] rRle; vihykFkÊ ij uSfrd vèkerk@vijkfèkd dk çdj.k ntZ Fkk v©j og tekur ij fjgk gqvk Fkk] ml le; og n¨"k eqä ugÈ gqvk FkkA vr% eè;çns'k lgdkjh l¨lkbVh vfèkfu;e 1960 dh èkkjk 19,@d ¼ch@[k½ esa ;g Li"V çkoèkku gS fd ^^d¨Ã Òh O;fä fdlh lapkyd e.My d¢ fuokZpu esa Òh vihykFkÊ iqu% laLFkk d¢ vè;{k in ij fuokZfpr gq, Fks] rRle; vihykFkÊ ij uSfrd vèkerk@vijkfèkd dk çdj.k ntZ Fkk v©j og tekur ij fjgk gqvk Fkk] ml le; og n¨"k eqä ugÈ gqvk FkkA vr% eè;çns'k lgdkjh l¨lkbVh vfèkfu;e 1960 dh èkkjk 19,@d ¼ch@[k½ esa ;g Li"V çkoèkku gS fd ^^d¨Ã Òh O;fä fdlh l¨lkbVh d¢ lnL; d¢ :i esa ços'k çkIr djus d¢ fy, ik= ugÈ g¨xk v©j d¨Ã Òh lnL; fdlh l¨lkbVh dk lnL; ugÈ jgsxk ;fn og fdlh ,sls vijkèk d¢ fy,] ftlesa uSfrd vèkerk vUroZfyr g¨] n.Mkfn"V fd;k x;k g¨ v©j n.Mkns'k d¢ volkj dh rkjh[k ls ik¡p o"kZ dh dkykofèk u chr xà g¨^^A mij¨ä çkoèkku ls Li"V gS fd vihykFkÊ d¢ }kjk tc laLFkk dh lnL;rk xzg.k dh x;h Fkh ml le; og laLFkk dh lnL;rk xzg.k djus d¢ fy, ik= ugÈ FkkA vr% mij¨ä foospuk d¢ vkèkkj ij mi iath;d] lgdkjh laLFkk,a] ftyk flaxj©yh d¢ }kjk ikfjr vkns'k Ø- 573 fnukad 10-12-2021 fofèk lEer çrhr g¨rk gSA vr% eè;çns'k 'kklu dh vfèklwpuk ,Q&5&1&99&iUæg&1 ,] fnukad 26-7-1999 d¢ }kjk eq>s çnÙk vfèkdkj¨a dk mi;¨x djrs çR;FkÊ }kjk ikfjr vkns'k fnukad 10-12-2021 d¨ fLFkj j[krs gq, vihykFkÊ }kjk çLrqr vihy fujLr dh tkrh gSA 10- èkkjk 19&,@d ,oa 19&ch@[k e-ç- lgdkjh l¨lkbVh vfèkfu;e d¢ çkoèkku¨a dk mYys[k djuk ge lehphu le>rs gSa t¨ fuEukuqlkj gS & èkkjk 19&,@d & lnL; dh fujgZrk,a & d¨Ã Òh O;fä fdlh l¨lkbVh d¢ lnL; d¢ :i esa ços'k çkIr djus d¢ fy, ik= ugÈ g¨xk v©j d¨Ã Òh lnL; fdlh l¨lkbVh dk lnL; ugÈ jgsxk ;fnA èkkjk 19&¼,@d½ & og vuqUe¨fpr fnokfy;k U;k; fu.kÊr fd;k tkus d¢ fy, vkosnd g¨ ;k vuqUe¨fpr fnokfy;k g¨A èkkjk 19& ¼ch@[k½ & og fdlh ,sls vijkèk d¢ fy,] ftlesa uSfrd vèkerk vUroZfyr g¨] n.Mkfn"V fd;k x;k g¨ v©j n.Mkns'k d¢ volku dh rkjh[k ls ik¡p o"kZ dh dkykofèk u chr xà g¨^^ ¼chch@[k[k½ & og flfoy vfèkdkj laj{k.k vfèkfu;e 1955 d¢ vèkhu d¢ fdlh vijkèk d¢ fy, n.Mkfn"V fd;k x;k g¨ v©j n.Mkns'k dk volku g¨us dh rkjh[k ls Ng o"kZ dh dkykofèk u chr xà g¨A ¼lh@x½ & og ;k mld¢ dqVqEc dk d¨Ã ,slk lnL;] t¨ fd mld¢ lkFk lkekU; fgr j[krk gS] ,slk dkj¨ckj djrk g¨ t¨ fd l¨lkbVh }kjk fd, tk jgs dkj¨ckj d¢ le:i g¨] ijarq [k.M ¼ch@[k½ d¢ micaèk ,sls O;fä d¨ ykxw ugÈ g¨axs t¨ fd foeqä tkfr;¨a d¢ m)kj rkjh[k ls Ng o"kZ dh dkykofèk u chr xà g¨A ¼lh@x½ & og ;k mld¢ dqVqEc dk d¨Ã ,slk lnL;] t¨ fd mld¢ lkFk lkekU; fgr j[krk gS] ,slk dkj¨ckj djrk g¨ t¨ fd l¨lkbVh }kjk fd, tk jgs dkj¨ckj d¢ le:i g¨] ijarq [k.M ¼ch@[k½ d¢ micaèk ,sls O;fä d¨ ykxw ugÈ g¨axs t¨ fd foeqä tkfr;¨a d¢ m)kj d¢ fy, vuU; :i ls cukà xà ;k cukà tkus okyh fdlh l¨lkbVh d¢ lnL; d¢ :i esa ços'k pkgrk g¨A ¼Ã@M½ & ;fn og ,slk O;fä gS ftls fdlh lgdkjh laLFkk dh lsok ;k ljdkjh lsok ls gVk fn;k x;k gSA Li"Vhdj.k %& bl èkkjk d¢ ç;¨tu¨a d¢ fy,& ¼1½ ^^foeqDr tkfr;¨a^^ ls vfÒçsr gS ,slh tutkfr;k¡ ftUgsa jkT; ljdkj] le;≤ ij lkèkkj.k ;k fo'ks"k vkns'k }kjk bl mièkkjk d¢ ç;¨tu d¢ fy, foeqä tkfr;¨a d¢ :i esa Ĩf"kr djsaA ¼2½ fdlh O;kikjh }kjk pyk, x, dkj¨ckj] ftld¢ varxZr lkgwdkjh dk dkj¨ckj vkrk gS] d¢ lacaèk esa ;g le>k tk,xk fd og ml dkj¨ckj d¢ le:i gS] t¨ fd fdlh foi.ku l¨lkbVh }kjk pyk;k tkrk g¨A 19- ch@[k & i'pkrorÊ fu;¨ZX;rkv¨a dk çÒko & ^^;fn d¨Ã O;fä ftls fdlh l¨lkbVh d¢ lnL; d¢ :i esa ços'k fn;k x;k g¨] ckn esa mä fujgZrk d¢ vè;èkhu g¨ tk,] r¨ ,slk O;fä ml l¨lkbVh dk lnL; ugÈ jg tk,xk rFkk jftLVªkj mld¢ LFkku d¨ fjä Ĩf"kr djsxkA^^A 11- mij¨ä çkoèkku¨a d¢ voy¨du ls ;g Li"V g¨ tkrk gS fd èkkjk 19&, e- ç- lgdkjh l¨lk;Vh vfèkfu;e 1960 d¢ çkoèkku mlh fLFkfr esa vkdf"kZr g¨rs gSa] tcfd fdlh O;fä d¨ uSfrd] vèkerk (Moral Turpitude) vFkok flfoy vfèkdkj laj{k.k vfèkfu;e d¢ vèkhu fdlh vijkèk d¢ fy, naMkfn"V (Sentenced) fd;k x;k g¨A 12- vfÒys[k¨a d¢ voy¨du ls ;g Li"V gS fd vihykFkÊ d¨ mij¨ä of.kZr çÑfr d¢ fdlh vijkèk esa U;k;ky; }kjk naMkfn"V (Sentenced) ugÈ fd;k x;k Fkk] cfYd og fnukad 9-1-17 ls fnukad 23-1-17 rd vuqlwfpr tkfr] tutkfr ¼vR;kpkj fuokj.k½ vfèkfu;e d¢ vijkèk esa U;kf;d vfÒj{kk esa jgk Fkk ,oa bl vijkèk ls lacafèkr vijkfèkd ç-Ø- 19@2017 esa U;k;ky; }kjk ikfjr fu.kZ; fnukad 30-8-19 d¢ rgr og n¨"keqä Òh g¨ pqdk Fkk] ijarq mä fofèkd çkoèkku¨a d¨ le>us esa n¨u¨a gh U;k;ky;¨a }kjk xaÒhj oSèkkfud =qfV dkfjr dh x;h gSA pwafd vihykFkÊ fdlh vijkèk esa nafMr ugÈ fd;k x;k FkkA blfy, èkkjk 19&,@d ,oa èkkjk 19&ch@[k e- ç- lgdkjh l¨lkbVh vfèkfu;e d¢ çkoèkku vkdf"kZr gh ugÈ g¨rs] bld¢ ckotwn n¨u¨a gh U;k;ky;¨a us 30-8-19 d¢ rgr og n¨"keqä Òh g¨ pqdk Fkk] ijarq mä fofèkd çkoèkku¨a d¨ le>us esa n¨u¨a gh U;k;ky;¨a }kjk xaÒhj oSèkkfud =qfV dkfjr dh x;h gSA pwafd vihykFkÊ fdlh vijkèk esa nafMr ugÈ fd;k x;k FkkA blfy, èkkjk 19&,@d ,oa èkkjk 19&ch@[k e- ç- lgdkjh l¨lkbVh vfèkfu;e d¢ çkoèkku vkdf"kZr gh ugÈ g¨rs] bld¢ ckotwn n¨u¨a gh U;k;ky;¨a us mij¨ä çkoèkku¨a d¢ vky¨d esa fookfnr vkns'k ikfjr fd, gSa] t¨ dnkfi fLFkj j[ks tkus ;¨X; ugÈ gSaA 13- mij¨ä laiw.kZ foospuk d¢ vkèkkj ij ge vihykFkÊ dh v¨j ls çLrqr ;g çFke vihy U;k;fgr esa Lohdkj djrs gq, U;k;ky; la;qä iath;d] lgdkjh laLFkk,a] e- ç- Ò¨iky }kjk ikfjr vkns'k fnukad 13-4-2022 ,oa mi iath;d] lgdkjh laLFkk,a] ftyk flaxj©yh }kjk ikfjr vkns'k fnukad 10-12-2021 vikLr djrs gSaA mÒ;i{k viuk okn O;; Lo;a ogu djsaA mÒ;i{k¨a d¨ vkns'k dh çfrfyfi çnku dh tk,A