Research › Search › Judgment

Gauhati High Court · body

2024 DIGILAW 1114 (GAU)

Runu Deka, W/O Lt. Dipak Deka v. National Insurance Co. Ltd.

2024-08-16

PARTHIVJYOTI SAIKIA

body2024
JUDGMENT : Parthivjyoti Saikia, J. Heard Mr. S.C. Pandit, learned counsel representing the appellants as well as Mrs. R.D. Mozumdar, learned counsel appearing for the Respondent No.1. 2. This is an appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 against the judgment and award dated 29.05.2013, passed by the learned Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Nalbari in MAC Case No.84 of 2012. 3. On 17.02.2012 at about 2.20 P.M., Dipak Deka was driving a motorcycle. At Mazdia, the vehicle bearing Registrations No.AS 14/A-7677 had hit the motorcycle of Dipak Deka. He sustained injuries and died on the same day at about 5.30 P.M. 4. The deceased was 45 years old at the time of his death. He was a Government employee doing the job of Panchayat Secretary, No.22, Dakhin Khetri, Dharmapur Panchayat. He left behind his wife and two children. 5. The Tribunal considered his basic pay of Rs.14,180/- as the basis for calculating the compensation. 6. Finally, the Tribunal awarded a compensation of Rs.15,58,500/-. 7. Being aggrieved by the said judgment, the present appeal has been filed on the ground that the Tribunal should have held the net pay of the deceased as the basis for calculating the compensation amount. 8. I have considered the submissions made by the learned counsel of both sides. 9. This Court is of the opinion that the learned Tribunal in spite of having documentary evidence relating to the monthly income of the deceased, erroneously held that the monthly income of the deceased was Rs.14,180/-. 10. Therefore, the judgment of the Tribunal requires to be interfered with. The modified calculation will be like this– Amount already paid to the claimant Amount already paid to the claimant Rs.15,58,500/-. Income = Rs.20,996/- as per page 4 of the LCR- Ext.2- Salary Certificate. Future prospect – 43%, Multiplier 13, Deduction 1/3rd. 30% of Rs.20,996/- Rs.6,298/-. Dependency calculation will be Rs.20,996/- + Rs.6,298/- = Rs.27,294/-. 1/3rd of Rs.27,294/- Rs.9,098/- Rs.27,294/- – Rs.9,098/- Rs.18,196/- Rs.18,196/- X 13 (Multiplier) X 12 = Rs.28,38,576 + Rs.70,000/- (conventional amount) Rs.29,08,576/-. Contribution of deceased towards accident 25% Rs.7,27,144/-. Total Compensation = Rs.29,08,576/- - Rs.7,27,144/- (25% contribution towards accident) Rs.21,81,432/- Rs.21,81,432/- - Rs.15,58,500/- (Amount already paid by insurance company) Rs.6,22,932/-. Payable Rs.6,22,932/- (Rupees six lakhs twenty two thousand nine hundred thirty two) only. 11. Now, the appellants shall be entitled to receive only Rs.6,22,932/-. 12. The appeal is allowed accordingly. 13. Contribution of deceased towards accident 25% Rs.7,27,144/-. Total Compensation = Rs.29,08,576/- - Rs.7,27,144/- (25% contribution towards accident) Rs.21,81,432/- Rs.21,81,432/- - Rs.15,58,500/- (Amount already paid by insurance company) Rs.6,22,932/-. Payable Rs.6,22,932/- (Rupees six lakhs twenty two thousand nine hundred thirty two) only. 11. Now, the appellants shall be entitled to receive only Rs.6,22,932/-. 12. The appeal is allowed accordingly. 13. The Insurance Company is directed to deposit Rs.6,22,932/-in the Registry of this Court within next 6(six) weeks. It is further directed that failure to pay the money within next six weeks, would cause the Insurance Company to pay an interest at the rate of 6% per annum from the date of filing of the claim petition. Upon deposit of the said amount, it shall be disbursed in favour of the claimants without any riders. 14. The appeal is accordingly allowed. Send back the LCR.