Research › Search › Judgment

Calcutta High Court · body

2024 DIGILAW 859 (CAL)

Visha Hindu Parishad v. State of West Bengal

2024-04-19

JAY SENGUPTA

body2024
JUDGMENT : Jay Sengupta, J: 1. This is an application praying for direction upon the respondents to allow ‘Ram Navami Shova Yatra’ in its usual route in Kolkata on April 21, 2024. 2. Affidavit of service filed in Court is taken on record. 3. Learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioner submits as follows. The petitioner is a registered religious society, which arranges and performs various religious activities and rituals for the masses. In order to celebrate “Ram Navami”, the petitioner decided to take out a rally on April 21, 2024. Although “Ram Navami” was celebrated on April 17, 2024, there were important religious activities to be performed on that day. So, a decision was taken to take out a rally on the immediate following Sunday. About 800-1000 devotees would participate in the Shovayatra. The route will be from Garia More to Baghajatin to Sulekha to Jadavpur Police Station and after making an U turn towards Jadavpur Super Market and then the procession will end at 8B, Bus Stand. An application was made on April 15, 2024 by e-mail. A hard copy of the application was served upon the local police station in the morning of April 16, 2024. However, the police authorities rejected the petitioner’s prayer to hold the shovayatra on April 21, 2024 and on April 16, 2024 at about 8.36 pm permitted the petitioner to hold a rally on the next day i.e., on April 17, 2024. It was too short a time to comply with a notice. The petitioner has been holding such rally since 2016. The petitioner undertakes that the rally would be held peacefully and without display of any arms. 4. Learned Advocate General representing the State submits as follows. The State has objection for the petitioner to hold the rally on April 21, 2024. First, that particular day has no religious significance. More importantly, there is dearth of police personnel because of the ensuing Lok Sabha elections. On April 21, 2024 certain examinations are to be held like UPSC and NDA examinations and some centres would be there on the said route. The examinations will be held till 5 pm. There is also a training programme for polling officers to be held in the morning. In the interest of justice, the petitioner ought to choose another day for holding such rally. 5. The examinations will be held till 5 pm. There is also a training programme for polling officers to be held in the morning. In the interest of justice, the petitioner ought to choose another day for holding such rally. 5. It appears that an application for holding the rally on April 21, 2024 was made by the petitioner on 15/16.04.2024, but on 16.04.2024 at about 8.36 pm they were requested to prepone the rally and do it on the next day i.e., on 17.04.2024. This was clearly not possible logistically. 6. Evidently, the procession was in connection with Ram Navami and permission was sought well before 17.04.2024, the date on which it was celebrated. 7. April 21, 2024 is a Sunday. There will be less pressure on the traffic. Examinations that are to be held would admittedly be over by 5 pm. Therefore, it will be more convenient to allow the rally on that very day from 6 pm or so instead of on any other day. 8. Every citizen has a right to express himself or practice his own faith, albeit, subject to the reasonable restrictions and a number of similar rallies have been allowed to be held. 9. Therefore, I do not find any reason not to allow the petitioner to hold the religious rally on April 21, 2024. 10. Let the rally be held by the petitioner on the said route on April 21, 2024 between 6 pm and 8 pm, however, subject to the following conditions: (1) The total number of participants shall not exceed a number of about 600. In order to ensure that the number of participants is limited to 600, the petitioner shall make necessary announcements, if required. (2) The organisers shall nominate 5 persons from amongst themselves who shall be held responsible for conducting the procession. (3) No vehicles shall be permitted in the said procession except for the one, which would carry the tableau and the idol of Lord Rama. (4) The participants shall not carry or brandish any arms or weapons. (5) The participants and the organisers shall not use any foul language or incite violence. (6) Since the model code of conduct for the Elections is now in operation, the participants shall abide by the same. (7) The participants shall also abide by relevant pollution norms including sound norms. Only normal sound system should be used. (5) The participants and the organisers shall not use any foul language or incite violence. (6) Since the model code of conduct for the Elections is now in operation, the participants shall abide by the same. (7) The participants shall also abide by relevant pollution norms including sound norms. Only normal sound system should be used. No disc jockey shall be allowed in the said procession. (8) The participants in the procession shall not halt or pause at any place and would continue to gradually proceed towards their final destination. 11. The police authorities, on their part, shall ensure that they deploy adequate number of armed personnel to ensure peace and to see that no harm ensues either to the participants or to the residents and the passersby. 12. If necessary, the State shall make request for Central Para Military Forces with a prior notice of 24 hours’ to the concerned authority including the Nodal Officer/IG, CAPF. 13. With these observations, the writ petition is disposed of. 14. Plain copy of this order duly countersigned by the Assistant Registrar (Court) be given to the parties on usual undertakings.